Reviews

Wasps in the Ice Cream by Tim McGregor

Only show reviews with written explanations

ryantlabee's review against another edition

4.0

Title: An Engaging Tale with an Audio Book Misstep: "Wasps in the Ice Cream" Review

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5 stars)

Tim McGregor's "Wasps in the Ice Cream" offers a captivating and atmospheric story that delves into the complexities of forbidden love, small-town secrets, and the consequences of our choices. While the novel itself is a pleasant and engaging read, it's important to note that the audio book's narrator leaves much to be desired, detracting from the overall experience.

Set in the summer of 1987, the narrative follows Mark Prewitt, a teenager grappling with the challenges of navigating his father's new marriage and spending aimless hours with his friends. Drawn into a web of peer pressure, Mark reluctantly participates in a cruel prank targeting the reclusive Farrow sisters, only to later regret his actions deeply.

McGregor expertly crafts the bond between Mark and George, the middle sister of the Farrow family, who is portrayed as an intriguing and complex character. George's practice of witchcraft and her use of folk magic to protect her loved ones adds depth to the story, providing a unique backdrop for the blossoming relationship between her and Mark. Their shared moments of loneliness, love for books, and exploration of homemade spells create an authentic connection that captivates readers.

The supernatural elements take center stage when George invites Mark to partake in a séance to communicate with her deceased sister, unraveling a tale of mystery and tragedy. McGregor adeptly maintains a sense of suspense, keeping readers engrossed and eager to uncover the truth.

However, it's crucial to address the issue with the audio book narration, which unfortunately hampers the overall experience. The narrator's delivery is marred by an inflection that constantly sounds like he's posing a question, creating a jarring effect. This peculiar intonation almost made me abandon the audio book altogether, as it failed to capture the true essence of the story. It's disheartening when the narrator's performance distracts from the otherwise immersive atmosphere and well-crafted characters.

Despite the audio book's shortcomings, McGregor's storytelling shines through, particularly in his portrayal of small-town life. The stifling environment, permeated by gossip and judgment, provides a palpable backdrop for Mark and George's forbidden relationship. The tension rises as their secret becomes increasingly difficult to conceal, and the author deftly explores the theme of loyalty, prompting readers to ponder the choices we make when faced with conflicting loyalties and self-discovery.

In conclusion, "Wasps in the Ice Cream" delivers an engaging and atmospheric tale that seamlessly weaves together themes of forbidden love, witchcraft, and small-town secrets. Tim McGregor's narrative keeps readers invested throughout, despite occasional pacing issues. However, it's important to note that the audiobook narration detracts from the overall experience, with the narrator's questionable delivery style proving distracting. For those seeking an immersive read, opting for the physical book version may be a more rewarding choice.

littlespookysmut's review

Go to review page

5.0

So I thought this book was going to be horror or thriller but I was actually pleasantly surprised at this coming-of-age story. It reminded me of The Virgin Suicides and the old Stephen King I read when I was younger. This story is very sad but I also thought it was very sweet.