Scan barcode
giadaleggeg's review
4.0
Thanks to Net-Galley for providing me with an e-arc in exchange to an honest review.
I loved it, I liked the adaptation of The Hound Of the Baskevilles, is very well written, quick and easy to please a classic and great writer like Doyle even to the little ones, the images are cute and funny.
#kidsSherlock #NetGalley
I loved it, I liked the adaptation of The Hound Of the Baskevilles, is very well written, quick and easy to please a classic and great writer like Doyle even to the little ones, the images are cute and funny.
#kidsSherlock #NetGalley
awanderingreader's review
5.0
This novel is a solid adaptation of The Hound of the Baskervilles for younger readers.
As a Sherlock Holmes fan, I love the idea of introducing his works to a new generation. With the right editing, Holmes' stories can resonate with and be appropriate for young readers. This book had all the right editing. The author portrayed the essence of this classic story very well in language accessible to elementary school readers at a length they would not find too challenging. Nothing vital to the story was left out and I think the author did a really good job of making an intriguing story with just the bare bones included.
I would love to see more Holmes adaptations by this author and I would recommend it for readers 2nd grade and up.
As a Sherlock Holmes fan, I love the idea of introducing his works to a new generation. With the right editing, Holmes' stories can resonate with and be appropriate for young readers. This book had all the right editing. The author portrayed the essence of this classic story very well in language accessible to elementary school readers at a length they would not find too challenging. Nothing vital to the story was left out and I think the author did a really good job of making an intriguing story with just the bare bones included.
I would love to see more Holmes adaptations by this author and I would recommend it for readers 2nd grade and up.
laurahuskinson's review
4.0
I received a digital copy of this book for review through NetGalley
The story of the Hound of the Baskervilles is one that I have loved for many years, I first began reading Sherlock Holmes stories late in Primary School and it has been a series that I have loved ever since. The BBC television adaptation of the books made my love grow even more so when I saw this book was available on NetGalley I leapt at the chance to download it.
In this graphic novel the story itself is abridged which makes it much faster to read than Conan-Doyle's original novel, making it perfect for someone looking for a quick read and refresh of a story, or an introduction into an otherwise daunting world. However, I felt the illustrations were nothing special; I do feel though that if this were purchased as a physical book these drawing would work fantastically as a colouring book.
Read my review here: http://laurareads95.wordpress.com/2014/10/02/sherlock-holmes-the-hound-of-the-baskervilles-graphic-novel-adaption/
The story of the Hound of the Baskervilles is one that I have loved for many years, I first began reading Sherlock Holmes stories late in Primary School and it has been a series that I have loved ever since. The BBC television adaptation of the books made my love grow even more so when I saw this book was available on NetGalley I leapt at the chance to download it.
In this graphic novel the story itself is abridged which makes it much faster to read than Conan-Doyle's original novel, making it perfect for someone looking for a quick read and refresh of a story, or an introduction into an otherwise daunting world. However, I felt the illustrations were nothing special; I do feel though that if this were purchased as a physical book these drawing would work fantastically as a colouring book.
Read my review here: http://laurareads95.wordpress.com/2014/10/02/sherlock-holmes-the-hound-of-the-baskervilles-graphic-novel-adaption/
anaelwynn's review
3.0
I am a very big fan of Sherlock Holmes and having the opportunity to read one of the stories as a graphic novel adaptation made me happy.
This graphic novel is quite short and each panel is packed with information. The art style is simple and clear making it easy to understand what is going on in each panel. The language is understandable, the text bubbles are not overwhelmed with dialogue. Therefore it is a very easy version of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's work.
I thought that there should be a few 'silent' panels, as every single one was packed with information. I feel if there ware 'more show, not tell' panels it would have made this graphic novel more enjoyable. All in all this was an enjoyable read where we get a glimpse of the work of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Though I had some problems with it I found it enjoyable and I flew through it.
This graphic novel is quite short and each panel is packed with information. The art style is simple and clear making it easy to understand what is going on in each panel. The language is understandable, the text bubbles are not overwhelmed with dialogue. Therefore it is a very easy version of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's work.
I thought that there should be a few 'silent' panels, as every single one was packed with information. I feel if there ware 'more show, not tell' panels it would have made this graphic novel more enjoyable. All in all this was an enjoyable read where we get a glimpse of the work of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Though I had some problems with it I found it enjoyable and I flew through it.
jessie_h's review
4.0
I'm a huge Sherlock Holmes fan. He is one of my favorite literary characters ever. So I jumped at the chance to read this graphic novel. It was fun and I think it will help the younger generation get into reading the collection of Sherlock stories.
It took one of my favorite Sherlock stories, Hound of the Baskervilles, and turned it into a graphic novel. The illustrations were nice, but they are definitely not my favorite. Although, if I had a physical copy I would probably color them myself. The adaptation was done well so that the reader will be able to follow the story. It includes all of the really significant events and conversations the original contains.
It is definitely a fast paced adaptation which makes it an enjoyable graphic novel. I would highly recommend it! Although I would recommend reading the actual story shortly after.
It took one of my favorite Sherlock stories, Hound of the Baskervilles, and turned it into a graphic novel. The illustrations were nice, but they are definitely not my favorite. Although, if I had a physical copy I would probably color them myself. The adaptation was done well so that the reader will be able to follow the story. It includes all of the really significant events and conversations the original contains.
It is definitely a fast paced adaptation which makes it an enjoyable graphic novel. I would highly recommend it! Although I would recommend reading the actual story shortly after.
charliebookfanatic's review
2.0
A hound is roaming around Baskerville Hall and it's attacking people. Holmes and Watson are going to investigate this seemingly centuries-old family curse.
Review
I never really read graphic novels, only mangas. It's only 48 pages and this I found to be quite refreshing from the long books I usually read.
Simple black-white illustrations, but they told the story wonderfully.
They changed the dialogue, but I still recognised Holmes and Watson in their distinct voices.
The other characters don't have a distinct personality. They're all telling facts all the time. Never once, they're actually having fun or feel real. All they are, are little robots made to aid the plot.
Holmes is completely flawless and it bugs me to no end. He literally knows everything about everyone by just looking at them. At some times it's quite farfetched and unbelievable.
To be really honest with you, in some of the stories I feel like Watson is just there. He really doesn't add anything. In this graphic novel I actually liked Watson more than I did Holmes. Even up to the point that I was disappointed when he came back into the story.
The story was enjoyable. It's a really short version of The Hound of Baskervilles and you still get the whole story. It was an okay read for me, but I did like the illustrations.
Thank you to Dover Publications for this eARC.
Review
I never really read graphic novels, only mangas. It's only 48 pages and this I found to be quite refreshing from the long books I usually read.
Simple black-white illustrations, but they told the story wonderfully.
They changed the dialogue, but I still recognised Holmes and Watson in their distinct voices.
The other characters don't have a distinct personality. They're all telling facts all the time. Never once, they're actually having fun or feel real. All they are, are little robots made to aid the plot.
Holmes is completely flawless and it bugs me to no end. He literally knows everything about everyone by just looking at them. At some times it's quite farfetched and unbelievable.
To be really honest with you, in some of the stories I feel like Watson is just there. He really doesn't add anything. In this graphic novel I actually liked Watson more than I did Holmes. Even up to the point that I was disappointed when he came back into the story.
The story was enjoyable. It's a really short version of The Hound of Baskervilles and you still get the whole story. It was an okay read for me, but I did like the illustrations.
Thank you to Dover Publications for this eARC.
annathea's review
5.0
Zgodnie z zasadą, że doskonałości się nie poprawia, TBF nie dodało do powieści nic. I to działa! A jak dobrze się słucha.
mordredrisika's review
2.0
Final Verdict: An interesting take on the classic story, but ultimately failing to make a connection with the audience.
Sherlock Holmes: The Hound of the Baskervilles follows the plot of the original story by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. In this adventure the famed detective Sherlock Holmes and his friend and occasional assistant Dr. John Watson head to the Devonshire moors to try and investigate a family curse and try and save the last Baskerville heir from a hound-like beast.
For as short as this adaptation is it is a rather accurate abridgment of the original. Some of the original dialogue is still there, including my favorite exchange which you can view below. However, there were also points where things jumped a bit, and it might be hard to follow or understand if you have not read the original material. The good news is that because the original story was so strong, there was little chance of this not being interesting as well.
The trouble with this book is I cannot tell who the intended audience is. The plot is a bit advanced and complicated for kids. The artwork is not that inspired and while I like adult coloring books, this one has no appeal to me to color in. If it was meant for kids it feels like the plot should have been more streamlined or simplified. If it is meant for an adult coloring book, I think they would have been better served to have larger blocks of text and then more elaborate or interesting pictures filling up whole pages. Part of dislike for the art is that with lines only it is very hard to tell the various Victorian men apart, especially when you only see part of them. It made it a bit confusing to tell who was talking or even who was actually present, and I know the story.
So while an interesting read, I am not sure who I would recommend this for. Probably some older kids and fans of Doyle’s work will be those best served by this story, but it was not one of my favorite adaptations.
Review originally posted: https://francesandlynne.wordpress.com/sherlock-holmes-the-hound-of-the-baskervilles-graphic-novel/
Sherlock Holmes: The Hound of the Baskervilles follows the plot of the original story by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. In this adventure the famed detective Sherlock Holmes and his friend and occasional assistant Dr. John Watson head to the Devonshire moors to try and investigate a family curse and try and save the last Baskerville heir from a hound-like beast.
For as short as this adaptation is it is a rather accurate abridgment of the original. Some of the original dialogue is still there, including my favorite exchange which you can view below. However, there were also points where things jumped a bit, and it might be hard to follow or understand if you have not read the original material. The good news is that because the original story was so strong, there was little chance of this not being interesting as well.
The trouble with this book is I cannot tell who the intended audience is. The plot is a bit advanced and complicated for kids. The artwork is not that inspired and while I like adult coloring books, this one has no appeal to me to color in. If it was meant for kids it feels like the plot should have been more streamlined or simplified. If it is meant for an adult coloring book, I think they would have been better served to have larger blocks of text and then more elaborate or interesting pictures filling up whole pages. Part of dislike for the art is that with lines only it is very hard to tell the various Victorian men apart, especially when you only see part of them. It made it a bit confusing to tell who was talking or even who was actually present, and I know the story.
So while an interesting read, I am not sure who I would recommend this for. Probably some older kids and fans of Doyle’s work will be those best served by this story, but it was not one of my favorite adaptations.
Review originally posted: https://francesandlynne.wordpress.com/sherlock-holmes-the-hound-of-the-baskervilles-graphic-novel/
singinglight's review
3.0
I’ve read most of Holmes before, but somehow I hadn’t read this one. Atmospheric, creepy, and marvellous. [June 2010]
More...