Reviews

The Shadow in the Glass by J.J.A. Harwood

Only show reviews with written explanations

jayrbradley's review

3.0

Was lent this a year ago and finally finished it lol. Fun premise and good pacing but ultimately kind of toothless. Could see this as a good YA read

lolocole's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.0

When they said Gothic Cinderella, they meant it. There is a menacing energy driving this book. It's coated with Ella's desperation, with impossible situations, with the claustrophobia of being a women with no resources but violence.
This book had me in a thrall- it was like the impulse to stare at a car crash. You know something horrible has happened, you know equally with the pit in your stomach that you don't actually want to see destruction, and you find your eyes glued to it anyway.
I am fascinated by the loose ends of this story.

Was Ella the one murdering all along? Was there even a woman in the dark? Was murder even necessary for the wishes? Was there such thing as a soul? If not, was Ella's death/suicide at the end a result of guilty paranoia? Did she kill her mother? Why are the accounts of her as a child so cryptic and violent and disorienting? What happened to change the violent silent child? Did Mrs. Pembroke die as a result of magic? I am just reeling.

The fact that Ella was an unreliable narrator didn't really hit home until half of the book had flashed by. We were so deep in her head, feeling the injustices piled upon her and the girls she worked with that the increasing wild nature of her justifications for her actions felt like a startling revelation.
Being a woman is so scary.

Content Warnings