You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

2.12k reviews for:

The Magnolia Palace

Fiona Davis

3.79 AVERAGE

lauralarua's profile picture

lauralarua's review

3.0
informative mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

a_novel_idea11's review

4.0

A beautiful story about overcoming the past, self-growth, and solving a mystery.

It's 1919 and Lillian Carter a/k/a Angelica is one of the most famous women in New York. Serving as a muse to some of the most well recognized artists of the time, Lillian isn't ready to accept that with the death of her mother and her prime behind her, life must change. But when she becomes a prime witness (or suspect?) in a murder, Lillian must disappear in plain sight. By happenstance, Lillian is admiring a statue (of herself) when she's invited into the Frick home for an interview. Upon being offered the job as private secretary to Miss Helen Frick, Lillian's entire life changes in a flash.

50 years later, Veronica is in the Frick House with several other models for a Vogue photo shoot. When the shoot goes horribly wrong and Veronica extracts herself from the situation, she finds herself locked in the Frick home after hours during a citywide blackout. Prior to being trapped, Veronica stumbled across several handwritten clues detailing a scavenger hunt. By the light of day, she and Joshua, an intern who also found himself trapped during the blackout, begin the hunt. Together, they will find so much more than they bargained for.

This was a really well done story. I loved that the two timelines were still both set in the past and both involved models of different sorts. I was enraptured with both storylines but slightly preferred Lillian's as Miss Helen was quirky and fascinating to me.

I loved how both women - Veronica and Lillian - were both naive but also both had major growth throughout the story. Both women were forced to overcome obstacles from trauma in their past and discrimination due to their profession.

With the exception of the house, it wasn't super clear how the two storylines intersected for much of the novel but I really enjoyed how everything played out and tied together.

This was a novel I struggled to put down and couldn't wait to pick back up. I felt connected to the characters, loved the historical fiction aspect, thoroughly enjoyed the mystery, and even liked the romances.

This is a must read for historical fiction lovers!

Thank you to Dutton and NetGalley for a copy of this wonderful novel.

readsdreamsplans's review

4.0

This wasn't my favorite book by Davis, but I still really enjoyed it. As always with her books, I am a fan of the duel timelines, strong female characters, and the overlaying of nonfiction over the fiction plot.
teresainohio10's profile picture

teresainohio10's review

1.0

I was completely enthralled with the Spectacular and the history of the Rockettes and the FBI first using profiling to catch a criminal. So I was excited to grab another novel by her, with the book blurb figured it would the history of modeling in NYC and the art world. Sadly I was disappointed.

We get two storylines, that the only connection is the building. It was just abrupt to be ripped from one decade to another decade. There was no connection between the two unitl the end. I felt like I was reading two books at once and the ending was forced to bring them together and it didn't seem plausible.
nicolen17's profile picture

nicolen17's review

1.0

This book was so incredibly boring. It wasn’t until the end listening to the author’s note that I learned it was historical fiction, which shouldn’t mean anything, but I’m thinking she should have stuck to fiction or non-fiction, but not both.
bookstowineto's profile picture

bookstowineto's review

4.0

Loved this book! Was able to get a copy through book of the month. This story has a dual timeline of 1919 and 1966. Taken place at the Frick house (1919) and the museum ( same location 1966). A murder, missing diamond, and an art scandal all take place. The writing is amazing and then book flows quickly.
fblizz's profile picture

fblizz's review

4.5
mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

4.5 rounded to 5.  An enjoyable historical fiction set in two timelines. The author did a lot of research of the time periods and people the book was based on. 

ravenousrat's review

4.0

Give me a good historical setting that tells an interesting story and I’m hooked. This story definitely hits the mark and tells a story from two time periods that link together a story within the famous Frick mansion in NYC. While I appreciated the modern story (1966) that brings closure to the storyline from 1919, I really loved the earlier time period and how it brought this historical property to life during its prime. The characters are more engaging in the earlier time period, for me, as well.

kenziemwright's review

4.0

3.5 stars rounded up. Great premise, ultimately underwhelmed me based on my expectations but overall a good read.

arriettymtnkj's review

3.0
medium-paced