2.12k reviews for:

The Magnolia Palace

Fiona Davis

3.79 AVERAGE

christeen's profile picture

christeen's review

4.0

BOTM & Libby audio read

jodiekuhnallen's review

3.0

This was good and kept my attention but there was just something I didn’t love.

A pretty good read.

For full review click here

booksndogs4me's review

3.0

Starting to feel formulaic.
misshappyapples's profile picture

misshappyapples's review

4.0

A typical Fiona Davis where a fictional story is weaved with a historical place and persons. I love the Frick so I was looking forward to this. And I enjoyed the story about an artists model (très scandaleuse) trying to escape an even greater scandal by disgusting herself as a personal assistant to Miss Helen Clay Frick. I flew through this.

akarently's review

3.75

Fun historical fiction! I really enjoyed the Frick family. I enjoyed the author's writing style. I didn't think it needed to be a mystery (almost didn't realize it was) and was there enjoying the historical fiction aspect. I liked the past and present jumps. I enjoyed Lillian's story more, though I felt like we were getting off track going to upstate NY visit at the end of the book. I enjoyed the notes at the end giving information on the historical/true bits. The ending/wrap up with the "escape" just felt awkward to me. But overall enjoyable. 

xandadu's review

4.0

I've never been a huge fan of historical fiction, but I think that's because I always associate it with WWII. I don't want to continuously read stories about WWII. This was really fun though. I liked our 2 main characters, especially Lillian. I was fascinated with her job for the Frick family (partly because I would love to do something like that). And I definitely want to visit the Frick mansion the next time I'm in New York City.

vscalera's review

5.0

Loved it. Never suspected the true murdered and am about to go frisk.org to the the house and paintings!

dhrutibc's review

3.0

3.5 stars. It was a good book, and I was interested In figuring out the mysteries, but I felt like the ending was rushed and very convenient in a way that took me out of the story.

nagemnoynek's review

1.0

I must’ve spoiled myself by reading The Spectacular first, which I loved. I also loved The Address. Then I read a few others and have found them to be rather boring. I enjoy her writing style, just not the topic. I got about halfway through this and realized it’s been taking me several weeks to get to the halfway point, whereas with her other two I loved, I read in a few days. There are just too many good books out there to slog through one I dislike. DNF