house_of_hannah's profile picture

house_of_hannah's review

5.0
dark mysterious tense medium-paced

Thank you so much to Kodansha Comics and NetGalley for providing me with an e-ARC; it is greatly appreciated.

Right off the bat this manga gives off strong Danganronpa vibes, and it does not disappoint ! I am a lover of mystery and whodunit. Coming up with theories is just always fun for me, so this series is just right up my alley. The fact that the main character's survival depends on them figuring out the mystery just makes it that much more intriguing. 

At first it seems like the story is going to be contained to the island that the main cast travels to right at the beginning. However, it actually flips between the island and several characters on the mainland. This gives us multiple threads of the mystery as different characters discover different information. 

Do not expect a lot of action in this volume, as it is heavily dialogue based. There's a lot of world-building, character backgrounds, case background, and you can definitely tell that some people are hiding secrets. It ends on the perfect cliffhanger, and I 100% want to continue with this series. The story is 5/5 for me. 

The art in this is also incredibly detailed, and there is a pretty heavy use of shadow. The characters look great, but you can tell the tropes they are based off of. Regardless, the art is also a 5/5 for me. I love when the quality stays fantastic for the entire volume. 
 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

mweis's review

5.0
emotional mysterious tense fast-paced
allbookedup's profile picture

allbookedup's review

5.0
adventurous dark informative tense medium-paced

Thank you NetGalley for supplying me this arc in response for an honest review. 

While I have not read the source material and cannot speak to how close it stands, The Decagon House Murders Vol 1 is an amazing start to what will hopefully be an exceptional series.

Despite not a lot of action happening the plot is engaging and kept me wanting to know more about the past of Tsunojima Island and the mystery society that has traveled here while on spring break. The art style is beautiful and shows clear story telling to aid and guide the main story along while engaging me into the mysterious murders that took place on the island.

I loved the dual storylines of the society on the island and the two members who stayed behind but have their own, linked, mystery to solve.

Despite this mystery not having a lot of action and it’s mainly people voicing theories and accusations, the way it all ties together left me wanting more and more to understand who is the culprit (culprits?) 

Each character has a famous mystery authors name (giving me slight bungo stray dogs vibes), a fun detail for mystery die hards, the pages of character design sprinkled in between chapters also gave a nice introduction and  another excuse to look at the amazing art done by Hiro Kiyohara.

Overall, I loved this volume and definitely recommend for anyone who likes manga mysteries or mysteries in general and will definitely be picking up future volumes.


Expand filter menu Content Warnings
ravensandpages's profile picture

ravensandpages's review

5.0
dark mysterious slow-paced

ARC received from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

I wasn't expecting this manga to capture my heart like this, but I'm obsessed! This manga is an adaptation of Yukito Ayatsuji's novel, The Decagon House Murders, in which a murder mystery novel club takes a trip to an island that was the site of an unsolved murder and arson. In tandem, the club members at the decagon house and a few members outside become wrapped up in solving the grisly mystery, but they soon discover they can't trust the "facts" of the case... much less each other, since someone seems to be playing a game with them all that might end with most of them dead.

I loved this story. I adore murder mysteries, and the idea of a club where each member takes on the name and style of a mystery writer interested me right off the bat. The character design and background art style perfectly set the mood for this story and I loved how the two storylines work together to slowly reveal what might have really happened the night of the island massacre. The side notes about each member's design and the author name they've taken on also added a lot to the story, and there was just so much I adored about this novel! I'm already in love with both Ellery and Van, and I would probably trade my soul for a physical edition of this volume. Everything here was done very well and I will absolutely be picking up the rest of this series. I can't recommend this enough to other murder mystery lovers!

 ❧ 5 ★