Scan barcode
sherylk's review against another edition
4.0
This might be one of those, "if you only read one book this year" books - in that it truly captures what is going on in America today. Not my America, of $5 lattes, but of people struggling to make ends meet, facing deep questions about identity, and many other important things taking place right now. I noticed this book in Denver's Tattered Cover bookstore, and seeing that it included writing by Ann Patchett, Roxane Gay, and Rebecca Solnit was enough to convince me. After reading it, I found many, many more wonderful authors sharing their stories and those of others, and I learned a lot.
otterno11's review against another edition
4.0
This is a diverse collection of essays, short stories, and poems that reflect upon the current state of extreme disparity in the United States, where the tiny percentage enjoy staggering wealth while the vast majority get by with less and many with nothing at all. The inequality endemic in American culture is evident but a lot of people - especially the white, the privileged, the naive - seem hesitant to really engage with the racial, economic, environmental, and political injustice that plagues our nation.
The essays here, some original, some collected from various other publications, while perhaps not delving too deeply into politics, are good introductions to the viewpoints of many vulnerable groups in our societies. As these prominent writers explore issues of racism, immigration, homelessness, poverty, work and gender from the perspectives of rural and urban, north and south, across ethnic and religious backgrounds, the reader gets a broad view of the US.
Most interestingly, the novelists Karen Russell and Claire Vaye Watkins each wrote gripping personal essays, the former about homelessness in Portland and the latter her childhood squatting on public land in the Mojave, while Roxane Gay’s short story set in rural Michigan was among the strongest in the book. The most compelling, to me, were the journalistic “Death by Gentrification” discussing gentrification and police brutality in San Francisco by Rebecca Solnit and Patricia Engel’s portrait of Miami, “La Ciudad Mágica.” Eula Biss’ essay on “White Debt” and Chris Offutt’s “Trash Food” were also interesting, though not without flaws. All in all, each piece offers much food for thought if not an in depth discussion on current affairs.
Most interestingly, the novelists Karen Russell and Claire Vaye Watkins each wrote gripping personal essays, the former about homelessness in Portland and the latter her childhood squatting on public land in the Mojave, while Roxane Gay’s short story set in rural Michigan was among the strongest in the book. The most compelling, to me, were the journalistic “Death by Gentrification” discussing gentrification and police brutality in San Francisco by Rebecca Solnit and Patricia Engel’s portrait of Miami, “La Ciudad Mágica.” Eula Biss’ essay on “White Debt” and Chris Offutt’s “Trash Food” were also interesting, though not without flaws. All in all, each piece offers much food for thought if not an in depth discussion on current affairs.
The essays here, some original, some collected from various other publications, while perhaps not delving too deeply into politics, are good introductions to the viewpoints of many vulnerable groups in our societies. As these prominent writers explore issues of racism, immigration, homelessness, poverty, work and gender from the perspectives of rural and urban, north and south, across ethnic and religious backgrounds, the reader gets a broad view of the US.
Most interestingly, the novelists Karen Russell and Claire Vaye Watkins each wrote gripping personal essays, the former about homelessness in Portland and the latter her childhood squatting on public land in the Mojave, while Roxane Gay’s short story set in rural Michigan was among the strongest in the book. The most compelling, to me, were the journalistic “Death by Gentrification” discussing gentrification and police brutality in San Francisco by Rebecca Solnit and Patricia Engel’s portrait of Miami, “La Ciudad Mágica.” Eula Biss’ essay on “White Debt” and Chris Offutt’s “Trash Food” were also interesting, though not without flaws. All in all, each piece offers much food for thought if not an in depth discussion on current affairs.
Most interestingly, the novelists Karen Russell and Claire Vaye Watkins each wrote gripping personal essays, the former about homelessness in Portland and the latter her childhood squatting on public land in the Mojave, while Roxane Gay’s short story set in rural Michigan was among the strongest in the book. The most compelling, to me, were the journalistic “Death by Gentrification” discussing gentrification and police brutality in San Francisco by Rebecca Solnit and Patricia Engel’s portrait of Miami, “La Ciudad Mágica.” Eula Biss’ essay on “White Debt” and Chris Offutt’s “Trash Food” were also interesting, though not without flaws. All in all, each piece offers much food for thought if not an in depth discussion on current affairs.
kawai's review against another edition
4.0
Timely, eclectic, thought-provoking. It’s an anthology with a purpose, to mine the inequality that is the ever-present reality of America. So many good pieces in here, from Claire Vaye Watkins to Kristin Valdez Quade to a million others. Well worth it.
georgia29's review against another edition
4.0
I liked some stories more than others but there were very few I disliked. Eye opening but not surprising, would recommend.