jameshaus's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I have most of the rest of Johns' run in single issues, so to be fair I"m starting here on goodreads. Some of the best writing in the DCU. I had greatly over-estimated Mark Waid's contribution on my first read through. In fact, I'm trashing all of those issues, but Johns' material is a keeper. The man knows how to create interesting villains and compelling storylines. Returning the rogues to terrifying status was by far his best contribution though. Most of the time I feel like he's the only guy in the DCU that remotely understands how to create a mythology. All of his issues are highly recommended.

testpattern's review

Go to review page

2.0

Somewhere, in a parallel universe, someone has written a Flash comic that is the bright, shiny flashing plastic fun thing that a Flash comic should be. Until we can reach that dimension, we're stuck with forgettable nonsense like this. Still, Gorilla Grodd=Always Good.
More...