Reviews

Dark Passage by Ridley Pearson

Only show reviews with written explanations

olliepop01's review

adventurous challenging dark emotional funny hopeful informative inspiring mysterious reflective relaxing sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

mandajo's review

Go to review page

adventurous dark mysterious tense medium-paced

4.0

This is the best book in the series yet! I'm ready to read the final book to see how this all ends.

allisonleslie's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark hopeful tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.5

I love these books. The accuracy to the Disney Dream ship, cast member procedures and character integrity always impress me. Can’t wait to see where the next book’s adventure takes us.

postitsandpens's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

DISCLAIMER: Because this is the sixth book in the Kingdom Keepers series, this review does contain some references to occurrences in the previous books. Major plot points or spoilers, however, are avoided.

I am at a loss when it comes to my feelings about this series. It started out so incredibly strong, with awesome world-building and likable characters. I loved the inside look at the inner workings of Disney that most tourists and fans don't get to see, from the behind-the-scenes mechanics of rides and attractions, to the glimpse inside the areas of the parks that only Cast Members are allowed inside. The idea of five teenagers being turned into holograms - and then told that their "other" job (aside from marketing) is to fight the Overtakers, or Disney villains, who are trying to gain control of the Parks and turn them decidedly darker. But as the series has gone on, instead of the awesome action scenes and battles between good and evil, the books have devolved into Relationship Drama (and yes, it deserves capital letters) between the main characters. And that's just majorly disappointing to me.

I mentioned in my review of Shell Game that the editing of these books has become extremely lackluster. In that book, there were lines of dialogue that didn't match up to the speaker, misspellings galore, and gaping plot holes. I mentioned that I didn't like the fact that Mr. Pearson turned Tia Dalma into a villain, either, and considering her huge role in Dark Passage, my unhappiness with that move has grown exponentially. I'm sorry, but she's NOT evil. She very clearly was helpful in the Pirates films, and I don't like what he's done with her character at all. I can get behind the other villains - the Evil Queen from Snow White, and Maleficent from Sleeping Beauty, to name a few, because that's exactly how they were written in their original fairy tales. Their evilness, if you will, makes sense. Tia Dalma's? Not so much.

Considering that the main part of this book is supposed to be about the Kingdom Keepers' fight against the Overtakers, way too much of this book is taken up with teenage drama of various sorts. Not only do you have the typical love interest stuff - Willa likes Philby, Charlene likes Maybeck and Finn (but maybe Maybeck more?), Finn likes Amanda, but finds himself also crushing on new character Storey Ming (who is WAY too old for him and therefore should NOT be crushing back, ugh), Philby also likes Storey but probably Willa more, and, just, seriously, STOP. Chapter after chapter of this book is taken up with all this ~drama~ about who likes whom, and it's just ridiculous. I also am getting really tired of the increasing strain between Finn and Philby and who is the true "leader" of the Keepers. And while I used to like Wayne, I find him at fault for most of it, so my dislike of him has also grown in each installment. Philby is a massive jerk, who likes to prove he's the smartest and basically says things just to make Finn angry, and also revels in the fact that Wayne has told him some things he hasn't told Finn. The only character I really liked in this book was Maybeck, who at least isn't treating everyone terribly!

I also need to mention that the editing of this book was no better than Shell Game. It's overly long (see that paragraph above regarding all the drama) and there were typos throughout (and this was a hardback copy, not the e-book version). At one point Philby tells Willa that her idea is "brilliant" and then five lines later he tells her it's "too risky". What? Which is it? That's just one example, but there are moments of this throughout the book. Every time it happens it just really knocks the reader out of the story, which further lowers your enjoyment.

Dark Passage is the most disappointing installment in the series thus far. Considering that the books have gotten worse as they've gone along, I have little hope that the final installment will be any better. If we could just go back to the main plot of this series - the battle against the Overtakers - and stop with all the unnecessary romantic "intrigue" then I think you'd have a decent finale. Alas, I don't hold out much hope of that happening. Will I still read book seven? Yes, because I've devoted myself to the previous six, and I want to see how everything ends. Will I enjoy it? Unfortunately, that seems extremely unlikely.

***

To see more of my reviews, please visit me @ Read and Reviewed!

rileyo627's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

i have mixed feelings about this one. i feel like this rewrite relied heavily on on the character dynamics which isolates itself from the others but i really liked that. there weren’t many solo chapters– everyone always had at least one partner. it stayed pretty true to the original, although it was much shorter and i felt like there wasn’t really a true reason for it. i really only have two main problems with the book, and honestly it’s because of missing details in the previous books.

the relationships between the characters are my favorite part, however it seems like finn and amanda are the only couple to actually have some sort of development. from the beginning, it’s clear that they like each other and it’s slowly been building up since. as for philby and willa, it’s been hinted but no real statements to indicate that they like each other. there have been comments and observations by other characters but that’s about it. there has been almost nothing that would have made me think maybeck and charlene liked each other, except for maybe a total of three lines in all six books. this means in the last chapter, when willa and charlene kiss the boys to wake them up, it seemingly comes out of nowhere. if i hadn’t read the original series, i probably would have been shocked and confused because there has been nothing in the previous books that led up to this.

my other problem was dillard. he has barely been in the series in general, and he’s supposed to be finn’s best friend. there’s supposed to be this tension because finn has other, “cooler” friends that dillard is jealous of, but there’s never any doubt that finn and dillard are incredibly close. this is what makes his death so impactful in the the original series. since him and finna have barely interacted in the rewrites, it’s hard to feel that sad about him dying in front of finn. i even feel like finn didn’t display a ton of emotion either.

that being said, i didn’t hate it, but i didn’t love it either. i was a little disappointed, but at this point i wasn’t expecting much. it only makes me want to reread the original copies more.