Reviews

Greatest Hits by Laura Barnett

caitlinsbooks's review

Go to review page

5.0

Wow, what a book. I’m being cheesy, but I really connected with this story. It made me write lyrics furiously, which I really struggle to do sometimes,
and I really enjoyed listening to the songs as I was reading.
Cass is flawed and selfish and talented and broken and strong and w o w. The tales of family and friends and love and loss interlaced with a shining music career (and some not so great moments) all worked in harmony and I loved every second.

flowerbob's review

Go to review page

3.0

Somewhat predictable, but the telling improved as it went along. I found some of the latter parts quite touching.

irelandreads's review

Go to review page

3.0

I thought the first 100 pages and the last 100 pages of this book dragged, and I think with editing the story would have been so much more exciting to read. Having said that, I enjoyed the middle section of this book quite a lot and the prose was engaging and lively. However, I found some of the storylines confusing as it was unclear to me when the events were taking place. All in all, a good read if you have the time but with some editing this could have been four stars.

suebarsby's review

Go to review page

5.0

Laura Barnett's The Versions of Us still sits on my TBR pile but I was interested in the idea of her second novel, especially when it was announced that Kathryn Williams would be providing an accompanying soundtrack.

Greatest Hits is the story of Cass Wheeler, a retired folk-pop singer-songwriter from the 1970s who takes a day to listen to her back catalogue and choose 16 songs to represent her life and work. As she does so, the story of her life emerges and we find out more about why each was written and what Cass has gone through to get to where she is, isolated and alone, but about to emerge with an album of new material.

Each chapter starts with a song and charts a part of Cass's life, from her entrance into the world as the daughter of a vicar who christens her Maria because he feels she should, leaving Cassandra as her middle name. Cass's mother has depression and leaves her husband and daughter to run away to Canada when Cass is a young girl. This act changes Cass's life - emotionally in ways she takes years to recover from, and physically as she moves from her devastated father to live with her aunt and uncle. It is there that she takes her first real steps to a musical career.

Told purely from Cass's point of view, the book is nevertheless a clear-eyed account of the mistakes we make as we get through life, and is unskimping on the details - the drug taking, drinking, domestic abuse. This is a novel about consequences, how we live with them, and about the elusive second chance.

jackielaw's review

Go to review page

3.0

“Larry knows what it is to lose oneself for hours – days, even – in the act of creation; and to only understand, when the mind and body are finally calm once more, what it is that has been created. What, in that act, the artist is trying to make sense of, even though no sense can ever truly be made of this dizzying, maddening, impossible, beautiful life; and, of course, of its culmination, its crescendo and its inevitable loss.”

Greatest Hits, by Laura Barnett, tells the story of fictional singer-songwriter, Cass Wheeler, from her childhood growing up the only child of a London vicar and his depressed wife, through her rise to the heady heights of international fame, and then to her retirement from the music scene following personal tragedy. Along the way are exhausting months on the road, abandoned friends, broken marriages, and the apparently requisite over-indulgence in drugs of all kinds.

The structure of the story is wrapped around a series of sixteen songs representing Wheeler’s life. The lyrics – written by the author and real life singer-songwriter Kathryn Williams – have been put to music and will be released as a studio album to coincide with the publication of the book. This is not the first time publishers have collaborated to create associated music – I am aware of singles from Fahrenheit Press and Orenda Books. It is still, however, an interesting idea.

The story is set over the course of a day as Wheeler decides on the tracks to be released from her back catalogue in a new album being planned to enable her to emerge from retirement. As each song is selected the timeline moves to describe the events that provided their inspiration. Hints are dropped in the contemporary setting and then explained in these flashbacks. With a cast of characters spanning more than six decades it took concentration to remember who was who between the time periods.

Although polished and fluid I was not fully engaged until near the end. The contemporary sections felt like interruptions in what was an otherwise compelling tale. I did question why anyone would want fame, something that Wheeler herself noted when she saw the life an old friend was leading. Much is made of how artistic creatives cannot stifle their urges, even those that carry risk of self-destruction.

There is a poignancy to any life story as, over time, family and friends will inevitably be lost to abandonment, disagreement, and death. Words will be spoken that cannot then be forgotten, resentments form that damage all involved. Wheeler makes choices, repeats mistakes, holds grudges and must live with the consequences. The depiction of her as a daughter – to both the women charged with her care – and then as a mother, made for interesting reading. There was little new in this but it was perceptively portrayed.

Wheeler’s life with its hurts and privileges is rendered to demonstrate that success happens moment by moment and can be measured in many ways. Even if not convinced by the construction, this tale is well written. I will listen out for the album when it too is released.

My copy of this book was provided gratis by the publisher, Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
More...