You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

272 reviews for:

Lady Roberta

Eloisa James

3.35 AVERAGE

dark slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No
bingley's profile picture

bingley's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH: 22%

(250101)
Too much superficial banter. Too much quirky, whimsical cleverness. 
'Ha Ha, I'm so witty, and can return a barb, and keep this repartee going for pages and pages that readers never get a break from all my CLEVERNESS.'

I started for the plot, but I'm at chapter 6, 22% through, and I'm missing the emotional heart of the characters and story. (probly doesn't help that I just finished Lisa Kleypas' amazing Scandal in Spring right before this)

FMC: Even when Roberta is alone, she still has a clever, ironic comment to make about her situation. And that situation cuts away from any genuine connection I can feel for the characters. 

I wanna know how they actually feel about something and whether what they SAY they feel is actually true or not. I want to be able to understand the emotional heart of a character, to at least know and see they HAVE one.

DNF, unfortunately.

If her other books are written similarly, I likely won't read her others. Wompwomp
emotional funny hopeful lighthearted tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

Personally, when it comes to POV's I like only the hero and heroine, maybe a scene or two with someone else to explain something, but this was constantly changing. I didn't actually read the synopsis before reading because I previously read the first book in the spin off of this series and was like shit I'm going back to the start, so in the beginning I assumed Villers was the hero of this book and couldn't figure out why because he's a wanker, and I couldn't get over the number of times to mentioned they were RELATED... I mean sure, they're fourth cousins I wouldn't even say 'oh were cousins' they're just another person, but they kept calling each other cousin and stuff and it really weirded me out.

The slow burn up to that sex scene at like 80-83% had me so red in the face I had to stop reading, and then I realised it was 2am and finished the rest of it because I needed to know what happened before I could sleep, so now it's 3am and I'm glad I read it. Personally not a fan of the time period because of the wigs and powder, and the bloody mindset of the people (legit said Damon was a bad person because he was raising his bastard child and didn't send him to the country to be raised by someone else. Lol. And everyone's views on children in this killed me. Even Roberta got on my nerves about it. She was legit disgusted by everything he did until she started boning his dad. Personally I thought he was adorable, but I guess it's the times. I wish there had have been a moment that was more 'oh I love this kid too' but there wasn't which made me sad but with how everyone talks about kids in this it also kind of made sense because they really just seem to hate kids lol

Not a standard historical. There multiple romantic relationships being developed here, and while Roberta and Damon get their HEA, the other ones don't all resolve.

Definitely a series where the primary relationship will change focus each book, but the secondary relationships will keep being developed across multiple books. It's an intriguing way of doing a series.

3.5 stars

Liked it more by the end, will continue the series.

Roberta is the sheltered daughter of an overemotional lower nobility in Regency England. Her distant cousin, Duchess Jemma, has just returned from France to look after her politically ambitious estranged husband. Roberta wants to avoid becoming an old maid and beseeches her cousin to help her find a man.

A romance with some blush-worthy scenes, this was out of my usual comfort zone for books. It was a light read and a perhaps a good beach read. I didn't enjoy it particularly because the characters were so annoying! Roberta was so naive and foolish. I am not particularly certain I understood her even by the end. The other characters were just sort of frustrating and took away from the pleasure of reading the book.

After reading other reviews that complained of the third person, multi-character book, I felt compelled to disagree. It takes a bit of getting used to since most HF stories are told in first person, I found it refreshing and enjoyed being immersed in several characters’ lives simultaneously, especially since they each had their own appeal. I’m looking forward to reading more books in this series.

This book was a mess. Just... All over the place.

This was not great. At all. So instead of making a list of things I didn't like about it, which I felt might be mean, I made a list of things I'm glad for about it. 1) I'm glad it was free on my library audio app! 2) I'm glad I listened to it. I would have DNF'd this if I had had to sit and look at the words for hours of my life. By listening to it, I was able to do constructive things, like laundry and cooking, so I didn't feel like I was totally wasting my time. 3) I'm glad this wasn't my first Eloisa James book, or it may have been my last. I like her books generally. 4) I'm glad that I was able to listen to this at 2x speed for the last 1/4 of the book. On one hand I wanted to be done already, but on the other I did want to find out if the side stories were going to be resolved (they were't. Sigh.).