2.75 AVERAGE


Really enjoyed this. It is fast paced, breathless at times. I loved Declan Hughes' Ed Loy series although I thought the last one, City of Lost Girls, was weaker than previous. This passed me by though and I discovered it by fortunate accident. The novel is a departure from the excellent Irish-noir of the Ed Loy books, an American-set domestic thriller similar in may respects to those of Linwood Barclay or Harlan Coben. The book is well-written and Hughes' choice of words is almost poetic at times, a joy to read with only a couple of caveats - a) he has a habit (that I don't recall from his other books) of using a) and b) lists when describing characters recollections or choices and b) occasionally introducing a scene by pulling back, almost cinematically, and using an omnipotent narrator to describe the action below (look at them talking, we can almost but not quite hear what they are saying, let's go in...). both of these only served to temporarily pull me out of what was otherwise a fairly frantic page-turner of a novel.

Great premise, awesome start up, fell apart somewhat towards the end. The actual conclusions were satisfying, but there was a jump that never felt right to bring the main characters where they needed to be and a lack of clarity about one of the primary plot lines.

Made it halfway. Couldn't finish.

The story premise was good, but the storyline was choppy and needed some editing. It might've been more enjoyable if the story was more polished.

This was my first time reading this author. It was a library book.

I chose this book thinking it would be a spooky read for Halloween and the readathons. It was set at Halloween, both past and present. I liked Claire and Danny, even when I was unsure about who and what they really were. I even liked Donna and Charlie, maybe because they were, at least, honest and accepting of who they were. The plot was fairly twisty with lots of potential suspects and nobody to truly trust. Then came the explosions. Those I didn’t see even though I had the off kilter feelings. I’m not saying more, though I want to, because anything else will give you no reason to read the book. I think you should read it. I was devouring the last third of the book. Why then 4 Stars? I wanted to know more about someone though if the author chose to make a guess true, I would have felt like punching him in the nose. But to me, that’s a pretty good thing. It means the author did his job. For me, the best books are those that invite me in to the story, make me forget reality and make me feel. You don’t punch people, even in fantasy, unless you are feeling. Deeply feeling. He lost a star because I’ll be forever wondering. It’s almost like a punch. Read the book.

This was my first time reading this author. It was a library book.

I chose this book thinking it would be a spooky read for Halloween and the readathons. It was set at Halloween, both past and present. I liked Claire and Danny, even when I was unsure about who and what they really were. I even liked Donna and Charlie, maybe because they were, at least, honest and accepting of who they were. The plot was fairly twisty with lots of potential suspects and nobody to truly trust. Then came the explosions. Those I didn’t see even though I had the off kilter feelings. I’m not saying more, though I want to, because anything else will give you no reason to read the book. I think you should read it. I was devouring the last third of the book. Why then 4 Stars? I wanted to know more about someone though if the author chose to make a guess true, I would have felt like punching him in the nose. But to me, that’s a pretty good thing. It means the author did his job. For me, the best books are those that invite me in to the story, make me forget reality and make me feel. You don’t punch people, even in fantasy, unless you are feeling. Deeply feeling. He lost a star because I’ll be forever wondering. It’s almost like a punch. Read the book.