Scan barcode
Reviews
On Desperate Ground: The Marines at The Reservoir, the Korean War's Greatest Battle by Hampton Sides
mellowdave's review against another edition
emotional
tense
medium-paced
5.0
I bought the book to gain an understanding of the events at the Chosin Reservoir during the Korean Conflict, and I came away with that understanding, as well as a strong interest in learning more. I don't think I can day anything more favorable about a history book.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Violence, War, Murder, and Gore
gswain's review
5.0
Highly recommend this book and the author if interested in nonfiction. Very well written and I learned a ton.
kumipaul's review
4.0
Well-told story of war's brutality in one series of battles. What a waste of good lives just to stoke the egos of arrogant generals.
nermutbundaloy's review against another edition
dark
emotional
informative
sad
tense
medium-paced
4.75
neaful's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
informative
inspiring
fast-paced
4.5
jeremyanderberg's review against another edition
5.0
The Korean War is often referred to as America's "forgotten war." That phrase might now even be a bit of a cliche, as recent years have seen quite a few books released on the subject. While there are innumerable stories to be told, many center around its most famed battle: the Battle of Chosin Reservoir.
On Desperate Ground covers this battle, and is truly one of the better history narratives I've ever read. I was irrevocably hooked from the very first chapter.
What sets this book apart is how well Sides sets the stage for the battle that unfolds. He gets into the whys and hows of the war before getting into the nitty gritty and often gory details. It's written and structured and reads like a novel with clear protagonists and antagonists (often being US leadership rather than enemy soldiers), page-turning battle scenes with truly unbelievable acts of individual courage and heroism, and breathtaking descriptions of nightmarish landscapes and climates (with temperatures during the fighting plunging well below zero).
Sides writes better than I possibly could what sets the Battle of Chosin Reservoir apart from other engagements, and makes it so eminently worth telling about:
"Few battles can boast so many notable instances of individual courage, carried out on such inhospitable terrain, in such impossible weather, in conditions of such intimate combat, against such overwhelming numerical odds. The extremity of the predicament brought to the fore a naked survival instinct, a ferocious camaraderie, and a rare improvisational spirit."
So many reading list additions here. Sides immediately got me interested in learning all I could about the Korean War and its primary players, so I added to my list a bunch of books in that realm — only a couple of which I've already bought . . . sorry Jane. I also now want to read all of Sides' other books. I've read Hellhound on His Trail, about the hunt for MLK's killer, which was great, so I had some inkling this book would live up to the hype.
I've not read many books about the Korean War (Adam Makos' fabulous Devotion being the only other one), but On Desperate Ground really seems like the perfect, heroic starting point. Again, one of the better history books I've read, and one that I'll be recommending for a long time to come.
On Desperate Ground covers this battle, and is truly one of the better history narratives I've ever read. I was irrevocably hooked from the very first chapter.
What sets this book apart is how well Sides sets the stage for the battle that unfolds. He gets into the whys and hows of the war before getting into the nitty gritty and often gory details. It's written and structured and reads like a novel with clear protagonists and antagonists (often being US leadership rather than enemy soldiers), page-turning battle scenes with truly unbelievable acts of individual courage and heroism, and breathtaking descriptions of nightmarish landscapes and climates (with temperatures during the fighting plunging well below zero).
Sides writes better than I possibly could what sets the Battle of Chosin Reservoir apart from other engagements, and makes it so eminently worth telling about:
"Few battles can boast so many notable instances of individual courage, carried out on such inhospitable terrain, in such impossible weather, in conditions of such intimate combat, against such overwhelming numerical odds. The extremity of the predicament brought to the fore a naked survival instinct, a ferocious camaraderie, and a rare improvisational spirit."
So many reading list additions here. Sides immediately got me interested in learning all I could about the Korean War and its primary players, so I added to my list a bunch of books in that realm — only a couple of which I've already bought . . . sorry Jane. I also now want to read all of Sides' other books. I've read Hellhound on His Trail, about the hunt for MLK's killer, which was great, so I had some inkling this book would live up to the hype.
I've not read many books about the Korean War (Adam Makos' fabulous Devotion being the only other one), but On Desperate Ground really seems like the perfect, heroic starting point. Again, one of the better history books I've read, and one that I'll be recommending for a long time to come.