Reviews

I Do: An Anthology in Support of Marriage Equality by Cassidy Ryan, Mallory Path, Jeanne Barrack, Fiona Glass, Lisabet Sarai, Lee Rowan, Z.A. Maxfield, P.A. Brown, Clare London, Zoe Nichols, Kris Jacen, Tracey Pennington, Allison Wonderland, Storm Grant, Jerry L. Wheeler, Moondancer Drake, Alex Beecroft, Emma Collingwood, Marquesate, Charlie Cochrane, Erastes, Sharon Maria Bidwell

marlobo's review

3.0

The Lindorm's Twin by Tracey Pennington - 2 stars

Desire and Disguise by Alex Beecroft - 3 stars

The Roaming Heart by Charlie Cochrane - 2 stars

Outed by Clare London - 4 stars.
«Couldn’t social acceptability be achieved with discreet familiarity, rather than wearing a lurid slogan on a tight T-shirt?» <3

Lust in Translation by Storm Grant - 3 stars

Making Memory by Lisabet Sarai - 2 stars

Swansong by Sharon Maria Bidwell - 3 stars

Finally Forever by Jeanne Barrack - 2 stars

Code of Honour by Marquesate - 4.5 stars

Tango and Temptation by Z.A. Maxfield - 1 star

The Mistake by P.A. Brown - 2, 5 stars

Holy Macaroni by Allison Wonderland - 3,5 stars

The Snow Queen by Erastes - 1 star

Better Than Beautiful by Zoe Nichols & Cassidy Ryan - 2 stars

Semi-detached by Emma Collingwood - 3 stars

Rules of the Game by Mallory Path - 3,5 stars

Templeton's in Love by Jerry L. Wheeler - 3 stars

True Love by Moondancer Drake - 3 stars

Salad Days by Fiona Glass - 1,5 stars

Wedding Announcement by Lee Rowan  - 2 stars

bookcraft's review

4.0

Varying quality in the stories, as with nearly any anthology. No real clunkers, though, and a couple that are exceptionally good. I skipped a couple of stories because I haven't been in the mood for f/f lately, another because I'm not much on fantasy, and didn't finish one that was stylistically not to my tastes. Exceptional stories are bolded, and all are individually rated on a scale of one to five stars.

"The Lindorm's Twin" by Tracey Pennington (UNREAD)
"Desire and Disguise" by Alex Beecroft (****)
"The Roaming Heart" by Charlie Cochrane (****)
"Outed" by Clare London (****)
"Lust in Translation" by Storm Grant (***)
"Making Memory" by Lisabet Sarai (UNREAD)
"Swansong" by Sharon Maria Bidwell (***)
"Finally Forever" by Jeanne Barrack (DNF)
"Code of Honour" by Marquesate (*****)
"Tango and Temptation" by Z.A. Maxfield (****)
"The Mistake" by P.A. Brown (****)
"Holy Macaroni (and Cheese)" by Allison Wonderland (UNREAD)
"The Snow Queen" by Erastes (*****)
"Better Than Beautiful" by Zoe Nichols & Cassidy Ryan (UNREAD)
"Semi-detached" by Emma Collingwood (****)
"Rules of the Game" by Mallory Path (***)
"Templeton's in Love" by Jerry L. Wheeler (****)
"True Love" by Moondancer Drake (UNREAD)
"Salad Days" by Fiona Glass (***)
"Wedding Announcement" by Lee Rowan (****)

jaimesamms's review

5.0

Let me just say, this is one anthology I thoroughly enjoyed. There wasn't a story in it I didn't like, and that is unusual. The cause is an important one, and I'm pleased to recommend this book to any m/m romance reader.

You can see my review of the whole book at Dark Diva Reviews

http://ddrreviews.blogspot.com/2009/10/i-do-anthology-in-support-of-marriage.html

mariesen's review

4.0

More like 3,5 stars 😅