Reviews

All-Star Western, Volume 3: The Black Diamond Probability by Jimmy Palmiotti, Justin Gray, Moritat

ogreart's review

4.0

Bringing in the classic tale of Jekyll and Hyde was very interesting. Bringing them and Jekyll's formula to 1880's era Gotham City made for an interesting mixture. Seeing how Hex, Black, and Arkham dealt with this was entertaining. And the added element of the Barbary Ghost being there as well just added to the fun.

dantastic's review against another edition

4.0

This collects Jonah Hex #0 plus All Star Western #13-16. Mr. Hyde is in Gotham City and the only one who can stop him is Jonah Hex!

I've softened on my previous stance on Hex in Gotham. I'm still not a fan of it but I'm making the best of the situation. Gray and Palmiotti weave Mr. Hyde into the DC Universe with a black diamond that I should have tipped to immediately. Moritat on art is aces. Tying Hex to the rest of the DC Universe isn't something I need but I guess it doesn't hurt anything. Fun stuff. 4 out of 5 stars.

modkuraika's review against another edition

4.0

It's Palmiotti and Gray on Jonah Hex and it involves Doctor Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, I think that's a pitch in and of itself. Good stuff.

roseflows's review against another edition

adventurous fast-paced

2.0