Scan barcode
jake_evan_'s review against another edition
dark
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
You know I love a story about a concerned neighbor and a self righteous congregation.
I thought this was a great 80's horror movie vibe story. It felt like those classic slasher/horror movies in the good and the bad ways. In terms of the bad, I felt like there was a lot of unnecessary scenes that just dragged out the story without really adding much substance to the characters or the overall mood of the novel. I did not really end up caring too much about any of the characters; the closest I would say is Dawn and she's more of a side character. I wish we also got more in-depth exploration of the Rust Maidens because the concept is so freaking cool and I kind of wish a different author came up with this concept and explored it more in depth. However, I do think that the 'horror' of the story is supposed to come from how terrible of people everyone is instead of the grotesque nature of the supernatural elements. I thought this did such a good job of exploring how people will fake a smile and take any excuse to finally act on all of the negative opinions they ever had of you. In reality, this is a story of a town full of judgemental church goers who finally had an excuse to publicly condemn and exile all of the 'abominations' that, in their opinion, have been keeping the town from flourishing. I love how we explore different stereotypes in our 5 girls (The artist, the outcast, the teen-mom, preachers daughter, and lead's best friend) and how their public hatred intermingled with the theme of choice. I really really REALLY love how it focused a lot on personal choice and the fact that no one has the right to tell you what is right for you. Again, the Rust Maiden concept is so disgusting and weird and epic and unsettling and I want more from this concept and I would love to see it explored more and to get some insight on what caused this metamorphosis and more exploration of what exactly happened to them at the end. I WANT MORE.
The writing style of this was a bit too soggy with unnecessary figurative language and unneeded scenes in my opinion. I also just literally gave 0 effs about the plot in the modern day: lowkey could have been a 4 star if that whole plot line just didn't exist. However, I did find the poetics of Kiste's language to be really beautiful and very engaging in the suspenseful and intense moments of the story.
I feel like I said a lot of bad but this concept and the theme of choice and found-family and the eeriness of it all will definitely stick with me. I was completely hooked for the last 70 ish pages, reallly good suspense and stakes.
I thought this was a great 80's horror movie vibe story. It felt like those classic slasher/horror movies in the good and the bad ways. In terms of the bad, I felt like there was a lot of unnecessary scenes that just dragged out the story without really adding much substance to the characters or the overall mood of the novel. I did not really end up caring too much about any of the characters; the closest I would say is Dawn and she's more of a side character. I wish we also got more in-depth exploration of the Rust Maidens because the concept is so freaking cool and I kind of wish a different author came up with this concept and explored it more in depth. However, I do think that the 'horror' of the story is supposed to come from how terrible of people everyone is instead of the grotesque nature of the supernatural elements. I thought this did such a good job of exploring how people will fake a smile and take any excuse to finally act on all of the negative opinions they ever had of you. In reality, this is a story of a town full of judgemental church goers who finally had an excuse to publicly condemn and exile all of the 'abominations' that, in their opinion, have been keeping the town from flourishing. I love how we explore different stereotypes in our 5 girls (The artist, the outcast, the teen-mom, preachers daughter, and lead's best friend) and how their public hatred intermingled with the theme of choice. I really really REALLY love how it focused a lot on personal choice and the fact that no one has the right to tell you what is right for you. Again, the Rust Maiden concept is so disgusting and weird and epic and unsettling and I want more from this concept and I would love to see it explored more and to get some insight on what caused this metamorphosis and more exploration of what exactly happened to them at the end. I WANT MORE.
The writing style of this was a bit too soggy with unnecessary figurative language and unneeded scenes in my opinion. I also just literally gave 0 effs about the plot in the modern day: lowkey could have been a 4 star if that whole plot line just didn't exist. However, I did find the poetics of Kiste's language to be really beautiful and very engaging in the suspenseful and intense moments of the story.
I feel like I said a lot of bad but this concept and the theme of choice and found-family and the eeriness of it all will definitely stick with me. I was completely hooked for the last 70 ish pages, reallly good suspense and stakes.
rene_lytle's review against another edition
dark
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
spookymom1989's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
badseedgirl's review against another edition
4.0
This book touched a place in my soul. I also grew up in a Rust belt town and watched our major industry close. I remember the low voices my parents spoke in when they were talking about what they were going to do when my Dad's plant closed. I think that is why this book touched me in such a personal way.
The storyline itself was an odd tale, that wiggled around on the page refusing to be pinned and pigeon-holed into any one genre.
The storyline itself was an odd tale, that wiggled around on the page refusing to be pinned and pigeon-holed into any one genre.
libraryofalibrarian's review against another edition
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
goblinhearted's review against another edition
I absolutely loved the concept and the setting. I really, really wanted to like this. The main character's internal dialogue / personification just felt so... rough? Edgy? Immature? It felt too much like the audience of the book was younger kids.
kayzie7's review against another edition
5.0
That was an amazing book! I expected it to be good but I didn't expect to be blown away! It's well written and the characters are well developed. It discusses so many issues to do with familial and societal expectations and capitalism. I honestly can't wait to read everything else Gwendolyn Kiste has written!
theduchess93's review against another edition
5.0
WOW. This book was just absolutely incredible. The prose was beautiful and somehow nostalgic, the characters were devastatingly complex, and it was the perfect length to tell the story fully without over-telling. I'm buying every book by this author.