Reviews

Molly Make-Believe by Eleanor Hallowell Abbott

thenovelbook's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Fluffy, kinda silly turn-of-the-century romance. It was fun to read, but not too profound. What got me to read it was the interesting premise: Man who is very sick is disappointed because his fiancee is going on vacation and seems to think he can just fend for himself, so she won't hardly even write letters to him. In passing, she suggests that he subscribe to a letter service: you can sign up to receive love letters, letters from a historical figure, letters from a squirrel, letters from a pirate, etc., etc. (Yes, I said squirrel.) That just cracked me up and I wish that such a thing really existed. He, of course, signs up for love letters, thinking that when his fiancee returns he will use them to educate her on the type of letters that he wanted her to write. But you can pretty much guess the rest.

spilled's review against another edition

Go to review page

Written in 1897. Lots of wit, some unfortunate phrases of the time. The protagonist ruminates on the question of growing to fall for your pen-pal without knowing if it is truly a beautiful young woman or instead somebody old or male or a "Cullud Pusson" (which is put in quotes and spelled like that. so much cringe). For what it is and when it was written, it does have its charm, and sometime I enjoy reading things written in different times to remind myself that what feels timeless and immovable about society today is temporary in the end.

unabridgedchick's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This was a cute book. Absolutely cute. I was a reminded a bit of cute classic films like The Shop Around the Corner and Christmas in Connecticut -- a little screwball, very improbable, and ultimately adorable.

The premise is very simple: Carl Stanton, a Boston businessman, is housebound with rheumatism (in this case, terrible pain and malingering cold of some kind) while his cool and gorgeous fiancée Cornelia winters in Jacksonville with her mother. In her goodbye letter, Cornelia tells him she will "honestly try to write every Sunday" but that she's unwilling to literally promise that -- never mind sending him daily missives filled with sentimentality. As a dig, or a joke, she includes an advertisement for the Serial-Letter Company and suggests he look in to it. For a fee, he can choose the correspondent of his choice -- a Banda Sea Pirate, murderous and blood-curdling; a Gray Plush Squirrel, prowly, scampery, deliciously wild; a favorite historical character, historically reasonable and vivaciously human; or love letters in shy, medium, or very intense.

Unable to resist -- who could? -- Carl provides his brief biography, writes a check for an extravagant amount, and thinks smugly that he'll save the letters to show Cornelia, in hopes of teaching her how to be passionate. A day later, a messenger shows up with a cheery, sweet, loving letter and a woolen blanket and that's when Stanton's world gets a bit messy. His correspondent is charming and chirpy and adorable, and Stanton is consumed with wanting to know The Truth: who is his Molly Make-Believe? Like any reasonable person, he assumes the worst, and wants the best, and in general tortures everyone about this.

Abbbott's writing is a bit florid, but I really enjoyed it: it made me laugh, it was so evocative, and it has the feel of a vintage advertisement or postcard, all curlicues and extravagant promises. This section is from early on, one of his first, brief letters from fiancée Cornelia:

Not till the fifth day did a brief little southern note arrive informing him of the ordinary vital truths concerning a comfortable journey, and expressing a chaste hope that he would not forget her. Not even surprise, not even curiosity, tempted Stanton to wade twice through the fashionable, angular handwriting. Dully impersonal, bleak as the shadow of a brown leaf across a block of gray granite, plainly -- unforgivably -- written with ink and ink only, the stupid, loveless page slipped through his fingers to the floor. (p12)


Even though this book is set during Boston's miserably wet winters, it was a perfect read for these unseasonably delicious warm days. I spent one night on my porch reading this -- it's about 80 pages -- and it was a great diversion from the heavier reading I've been doing.
More...