You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

hinkle's review

5.0
dark informative slow-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark emotional informative medium-paced

carolinethereader's review

3.0
informative

aploinard's review

5.0
challenging dark emotional hopeful informative reflective sad tense medium-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
rebeccazh's profile picture

rebeccazh's review

4.0
challenging dark informative medium-paced

I almost skipped this because I thought See What You Made Me Do was comprehensive enough. I'm glad I didn't and this reads well together. In many ways, this covers similar areas - victims, batterers, and solutions - but this book goes into quite a bit of detail of a few selected case studies to then talk about the larger trends. It makes me feel like I knew all the people Snyder was writing about, and it feels more personal, in a way.

As usual, this topic is harrowing. It is always upsetting and horrifying to read about these women who are being tortured and abused. (Part of the anguish of Dorothy and Michelle's deaths is that it seemed so preventable)

One part I really appreciated was the second part, about the batterers. Why do they behave like this? (Or as Neil Websdale asks, 'why do they stay?') is a question that the second part tries to address. We get a bit of a glimpse into their lives and it's a very sad reality that an environment of poverty, toxic masculinity, and other issues like mental health etc, create a toxic effect on men. One of the examples that sticks with me is Donte (?) who went through the intervention programme and learnt to be better was in situations where aggressiveness and violence were prized and keeps him alive. So he went right back into it. 
dark emotional informative
roxyc's profile picture

roxyc's review

3.5
challenging slow-paced
zippz's profile picture

zippz's review

4.5
challenging dark emotional hopeful informative medium-paced

Incredibly informative and thorough.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
pagesofpins's profile picture

pagesofpins's review

4.0

There's some excellent material here, especially if you've heard people flippantly blame domestic violence on women for not leaving. The book breaks down ways the system fails women in DV situations, why leaving is so dangerous, and why women feel like they have to take their abuser back. The focus is overwhelmingly on preventing domestic violence homicide. 

Minus one star for the self indulgent interjections from the author, who is rather privileged. This was very well done, but something from a working class  author would have a welcome additional perspective. There's also a section on how a man who committed familicide justifies his continued existence through cheap divine grace, which the author writes off as just how modern Christianity works, instead of the twisted weirdness it is. We don't delve very deep into situations that don't end in homicide, likely because it would be a whole second book, but I'd be interested in hearing from the women (and men, and nonbinary ppl) who lived.
challenging emotional informative sad medium-paced