You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

3.81 AVERAGE

sammygee's review

5.0

My favorite book in the Alice series! This was the first book Naylor wrote about Alice, though now it falls 4th in the series behind the 3 prequels.

Alice is in 6th grade and new to Silver Springs. She struggles with the idea of whether or not she is growing backwards as evidenced by all of her embarrassing moments.

Longing for a mother, Alice sets her sights on Miss Cole, a glamorous 6th grade teacher. She is sure that if she can just get placed in Miss Cole's class, then she will be living a life close to perfection. As fate would have it, Alice is placed in plain old Mrs. Plotkin's class. Though she's not happy about it, she decides she can live with her placement after Mrs. Plotkin recommneds her as a substitute Safety Patrol member which means she can spend Wednesday lunches in Miss Cole's classroom as she oversees the group.

Over the course of the school year Alice's feelings towards Mrs. Plotkin begin to change. She begins helping out in her classroom after school cleaning and organizing. Mrs. Plotkin becomes exactly the female influence she was longing for and it is Mrs. Plotkin that she misses when she makes a solo train trip to Chicago to visit family.

Alice is the kind of young girl that is relatable with a good heart. She doesn't always behave in admirable ways (she has told a lie or two in her time), but she is a character who really wants to do the right thing. She has a great relationship with her brother and her father and feels comfortable enough to express herself and ask the questions a girl on the verge of puberty needs to know.

I have read this book many times and love it more with each rereading. The Alice series has frequently been challenged for its frank discussion of sex, drugs, suicide, school violence, etc but it a series I would highly recommend for young girls to grow on. I'd recommend this title to girls grades 4-6.

jgurniak's review

4.0

I think every girl can relate to Alice in some way.
hopeful inspiring fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

traceyw14's review

3.0

a cute, coming of age story, totally appropriate for a 6th grader, which is the age of Alice in this story. I have heard that not all of the Alice books are middle school appropriate, content-wise, but this one certainly is.

I don't remember which book of the series it was, but I owned an Alice book that I literally typed up into a Word doc as a way to practice my typing skills, so I must've liked the book quite a bit
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Loveable characters: Yes

This book aged so well and I feel like it was almost even more enjoyable to read at 29 because it was somehow reassuring that we never really fully grow up

laurasandberg23's review

5.0
fast-paced
suzanjackson's profile picture

suzanjackson's review

4.0

I loved this novel - part of 25-book series - about a girl named Alice who just wants to fit in and grow up. Read my full review at:

http://bookbybook.blogspot.com/2014/09/middle-grade-review-agony-of-alice.html
akirahbeloved's profile picture

akirahbeloved's review

5.0
emotional funny hopeful lighthearted reflective fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes