Reviews

Darwin and the Mysterious Mr. X: New Light on the Evolutionists by Loren Eiseley

octavia_cade's review

Go to review page

4.0

Loren Eiseley is my favourite science writer, and as I worked my way through this book I was initially a little disappointed. I read him for his images and language, and yet half the book isn't by him at all! But as I read, my expectations began to readjust.

Eiseley takes a detailed look here at the influence of the zoologist Edward Blyth on Darwin's theory of evolution. I'd never even heard of Blyth, but the evidence is convincing: Darwin had heard of him, and used his work as a (pretty much unacknowledged) stepping stone in the development of his own. A large section of this book is therefore given over to reprinting three of Blyth's papers (also his eventual obituary by a contemporary). These were interesting reads, even if they don't reach Eiseley's level of science writing - but what does? And there was plenty of Eiseley to content me, especially in his concluding essays on the place of man in evolutionary thought.

Informative, well-researched, and absolutely worth the read.
More...