Reviews with content warning for Ableism - Swimming Back to Trout River

Reviews tagging 'Ableism'

Swimming Back to Trout River by Linda Rui Feng

7 reviews

kaneebli's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.0

Content Warnings

maggies's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative reflective slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

I regret that I found this book unbearably boring. It did not keep me engaged and I found my mind wandering often. The characters felt real, but I couldn't bring myself to love them, so I wasn't particularly interested in what happened to them. Ah well, can't win them all.

Content Warnings

just_one_more_paige's review

Go to review page

emotional reflective medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

My second to last of the 2022 Aspen Words longlist books! I brought this one on a trip with me and almost finished it on a single flight from Denver to Raleigh; once I started it, I just couldn't stop. Also, if we're keeping track, this is another one (which at this point is at least half of the reads) that I would not have picked up without them appearing on this longlist. So, my gratitude to the exposure this reading challenge is giving me remains strong.

In Swimming Back to Trout River, we follow a few main characters as they navigate recent history in China (including survival of the Cultural Revolution) and immigration to the United States in a variety of ways. Dawn is a musician who must give up the violin to survive the attack on arts and the bourgeois within China. Momo embraces the changes communism brings, at least to start, which causes a lifelong rift between himself and his college friend, Dawn. Cassia is struggling to deal with a traumatic personal experience, leaving Beijing to get away from the memories as soon as she could. Junie is Momo and Cassia' daughter, born in the late 1970s and mostly raised by her grandparents, after her parents' immigration to the United States. But Junie's life faces some major (unwanted) changes when a letter arrives informing her that her family will be brought together again, in America, to celebrate her 12th birthday. This novel unfolds these four stories, interwoven together, until the conclusion where we see how they all, in finale, intersect.

So first, like I said, once I got into this book, the story-telling just carried me along with it. I was swept up by the characters and their individual developments, which all felt very fully dimensional, considering that this isn't a very long novel. Momo and Cassia take center stage, as they are developed both as individuals and as parents, but Dawn is almost equally central, and Junie holds as much space as a sheltered 12-year-old can. Basically, my point is, the character development is wonderful. Along with that, I was subtly blown away by the story itself. As I was reading, I was just moving along with the storytelling, which had a very understated vibe to it. But after finishing, and sitting with my immediate thoughts/reactions, I realized that there was a very impressive depth of humanity in these pages, unearthed and brought to the light, that I didn't even fully register until after it was over. The intermingling of memories of the past, the choices in the present, and the interplay of those realities on the way a life unfolds, is an affecting framework of this story.

I loved the look at the power of art (specifically music) and the way that it inspires and gives purpose and connects people in a way that nothing else can imitate. It is a touchstone, a cornerstone, of culture across generations and space and I love the way it endured throughout this novel, even in the places where all efforts were put not only into ignoring it, but actively quashing it. As my partner always says, the art is what is remembered about past civilizations, more than anything else it is what leaves an indelible mark. I also loved, and this harkens back to my earlier point about the understated tone of the writing, the many kinds of courage and following dreams that don’t make always make as big a splash as far as a dramatic telling, but still are life-changing, routine shattering, extraordinary, for those who act on them. Feng writes, so meticulously, the way these decisions render the characters both recognizable and completely foreign unto themselves, their ideas of who they are and their expectations of who they would be. This is such a universal pattern/ truth and it's so recognizable, despite how different these characters' lives may seem.

I have a few other random thoughts that I'm just gonna collect here at the end. There was physical disability rep that I have never seen on-page before, with a really interesting way of adapting, based on the setting (rural China). A beautiful take, one that I am going to work to internalize, that Feng wrote on this topic, was along these lines: without the rest of us (looking differently from her), she’d never know anything was missing. I mean, what a way to reframe disability (a deeply needed and necessary way). This was also the second AAPI-authored novel that mentions the idea of "yuanfen," the sort of universe-guided connections between people, that I've read in the past couple months. The other, if I am remembering correctly, was Beasts of a Little Land. And it's a concept that I really appreciate because truly there are so many times in real life that connections appear that would almost seem overdone/cheesy in fiction, so reading examples of this cultural explanation for it was really cool. Finally, my two iffy spots. First, I can't decide how I felt about the foreshadowing of Junie's (seemingly big) future, without ever getting any fulfillment on details. I'm not against it, I just can't decide if I'm unsatisfied in a good literary way or in an actually unfinished way. Second, the end of Momo and Cassia’s story. I won't give spoilers, becasue it's a big one, but I just felt like it was too fast/abrupt for the rest of the writing style. I wish a similar endpoint could have been reached with a plot point that better fit the vibe.

Overall, this was such a quietly and tenderly handled telling, considering the amount of grief and trauma that it covered (on this note, I have to mention the content warnings for loss of a child and accidental-injury death, as well as the generall repressive regime of Mao's China). I sped through the compelling and nicely paced story and, while it's not a favorite of the 2022 longlist bunch, it is a very solid addition and deserved the spot and recognition. If you are looking for a well-balanced, multi-POV, character-developed novel, with an insight into finding your place in unforgiving/unaccepting worlds, the connective power of music, and a bit of family drama, then I would definitely recommend this one.

“After all, wasn't it true that to love someone is to figure out how to tell yourself their story?” (I noted this one right away, when I started reading and then it was actually especially mentioned in the author's acknowledgements.)

“It didn’t occur to her that he might have been lonely, and that sometimes the lonely used things to fill up the space vacated by people.”

“In physics, there were always boundary conditions, and you could understand a great deal about a problem by thinking of its two extremes. Music, it seemed to him, lacked such boundaries. One could go on and on in any one direction without ever coming back.”

“He was impatient for time to pass, so that in his life, there would be less yearning and more having, less becoming and more being.”

“It’s in our nature to give things value, and there are times [...] when we have to give these things up in order to stay whole, in order to keep going.”

“But there are certain decisions that seem so right in retrospect that they irreversibly erase thoughts that any alternatives ever existed.”

“She knew that the universe had a way of surprising you with its murkier logic. In this logic, you could give birth to one child and end up raising another. As atonement. Or remuneration. Or however that otherworldly accounting worked.”

“Vocabularies we’re simply impoverished when it came to obscure sorrows.”

“How strange was the ebb and flow of resilience in the space between two people!”

“He knew he was sometimes driven to hopes that were the wrong size for this world.”

Content Warnings

onewoman_bookclub's review

Go to review page

emotional reflective sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

Content Warnings

serendipitysbooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional reflective sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

The first book for the #aspenwordsbookclub is in the bag, and it was a good one. Swimming Back to Trout River examines the impact of China’s Cultural Revolution and the impact of immigration through four key characters, Momo, Dawn, Cassia and Junie. Momo and Dawn meet at university. He is training to be an engineer but is drawn to music when he hears Dawn, a violinist and composer, playing. He eventually marries Cassia. Their daughter Junie is born without lower legs. When her parents migrate to the United States she is left in the care of her grandparents until her parents get established.

The writing quickly drew me in and I appreciated the four main characters in very different ways. Each had their own back story with individual hardships to overcome. Seeing the impact of the Cultural Revolution and migration through four different perspectives contributed to a more complete and nuanced picture than any one would have alone. The settings were also deftly handled, with the village of Trout River being especially vividly depicted.

I especially loved the way Chinese culture in the form of language was woven into this novel, almost as a key theme. Yuanfen and zaohua are introduced and an understanding of these words provides an invaluable lens through which to view the characters and their interactions.

Music, and art more generally, was a key thread throughout the novel, often bringing people together and providing solace at crucial junctures. The contrast in attitudes to the arts in China during the Cultural Revolution and in America was stark.

Janie’s disability and the reaction of others to her was another aspect of the novel I found interesting. While some people were unable to see a future for her, Momo was always optimistic and Junie focussed on what she could do.

While I enjoyed my reading experience I did have some reservations. I would have liked the novel to be a little longer so that we could see more of Junie and also of Dawn’s journey. The ending left me a little unsatisfied because it brought two characters together without any explanation. It just felt too coincidental and convenient.

Content Warnings

spaghettireads's review

Go to review page

emotional reflective sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

I’d had my eye on this book for a while, but decided to pick it up after it was long listed for the Giller prize this year. It tells the story of 4 people, 3 of whom are from the same family, through growing up during the cultural revolution in China, and immigrating to America.

I quite enjoyed this reading experience. While I think that the description on the book jacket doesn’t represent very well what you actually get in the book, I was really impressed with the writing. The way that the 4 storylines were interwoven over quite a long period of time and with many different side characters was well done. I felt invested in all of their stories. The way the author writes about music is beautiful, and I think that if you are a music person this is worth a read just for that.

The book description makes it sound like the book is more plot-centred than it is in my opinion. I wish that I hadn’t read the description because it left me expecting something from the book that I didn’t get. However, after more reflection on the book I did really enjoy it for what it was and would recommend it!

Content Warnings

hilaryreadsbooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional reflective sad slow-paced

5.0

Linda Rui Feng's debut novel, SWIMMING BACK TO TROUT RIVER, weaves together tendrils of its characters' lives to create a beautiful, complex but interconnected web of life, death, and 造化—the human and nonhuman transformations of things. Momo crosses the sea post-Cultural Revolution to seek the American Dream and establish a home for his wife and daughter back in China. However, unbidden memories and traumas hold on tightly to these survivors and immigrants; past missed chances with people and things deemed "bourgeois" by the Red Guard surface tantalizingly close in a way that makes you catch your breath. These characters in the book, so devastatingly human and whole and broken, navigate emotional and physical loss and yet find ways to reorient themselves towards healing (and sometimes forgetting).

SWIMMING BACK TO TROUT RIVER is about leaving your roots, but also the ways that 缘分 (fate, destiny) brings you right back to them. Reading this book during this period of my life, locked-down in my childhood home after flying back to be with my mother in her last moments, feels oddly like 缘分, connected in Momo's unfinished aria of grief.

Thanks to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for the advance reading copy in exchange for an honest review, out May 11, 2021.

Content Warnings

More...