serenedancer's profile picture

serenedancer's review

2.75
dark informative mysterious medium-paced

While it was a good retrospective on the case and what happened, it was not a good book. All throughout it was written as: X happened and then y happened and so on and so forth. It didn't really delve into the case and people's psychology while it was happening. 

For example, during the book it is mentioned that Chad is excommunicated from the Mormon church but doesn't go into what that would mean for him or really talk about it at all other than presenting it as a thing that happened. Really the book could have delved into the Mormonism and how that lead them onto their path. 

Overall, the book doesn't really provide any new information and was written before any sentencing even occurred. Maybe pick it up if you want to know the facts of the case, but otherwise it's not worth picking up.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

arod_'s review

3.75
dark

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
raspberryrenegade's profile picture

raspberryrenegade's review

3.0
dark slow-paced

Chronologically easy to follow. Handles subject with sensitivity overall, but audiobook narrator sounds robotic.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
informative sad slow-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark informative mysterious sad slow-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark emotional informative sad fast-paced

This gives a lot of background and detail to this case and everything that led up to it

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
challenging dark emotional mysterious reflective sad tense medium-paced

THE DOOMSDAY MOTHER is a very interesting book detailing the life and mental collapse of Lori Vallow Daybell as she navigated youth in a neglectful home and religious extremism.

STORY 3.5/5: this was a very large case in the US -- if you were following along, a lot of the information in this book will not be new but personally, i didn't know much about Lori's childhood so that was helpful to have. i did follow the case as it was unfolding but due to the nature of the US justice system things take awhile and details are lost in the mix so i did appreciate having the entire story in a concise timeline. 

there have been a lot of complaints ive read about the book that the author was a bit too sympathetic to Lori (insinuating that she is just as responsible to what happened as Chad) but i think the author did a great job portraying this situation for what it was.
Lori is mentally ill -- she was in an unstable household and then fell into a string of abusive relationships and was pining for something stable and secure (religion). the more she needed to feel secure, the more she travelled down that rabbit hole until it got her to an extreme, bastardized version of mormonism. that also left her super susceptible to manipulation from people she put on a pedestal. do i think Lori is guilty -- yes, but i dont think that she would have killed her kids if she got mental health counseling. i dont think she would have killed her kids if she didnt meet Chad. Chad did pull a lot of the strings and purposefully got the cult to one area in utah, had them agree to certain things like not talking to the police and actively lying to the police.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
kaileywicked's profile picture

kaileywicked's review

3.0
emotional informative slow-paced

I don't know how to begin how I feel about this book. I was struggling to get through it and attribute my finishing it in 3 days to listening to the audiobook for most of my reading. It felt like a choppily put-together timeline of events spanning years of complex family relations, minute details that are mentioned once and never brought up again, and agony. I went into this knowing most of the story about what happened to JJ and Tylee but this threw me into the world of Lori and Chad Daybell in a way I wasn't ready for. I still can't wrap my head around the incident and this furthered my confusion.

I did not like the writing, there was confusion surrounding people who had the same no with little clarification as to who was being talked about at which time, and I constantly had to backtrack and reread portions of the book to understand where I was at in the case. The first half was immensely boring. For two religious fanatics and doomsday preppers, Lori and Chad were so boring. Nothing about the recap of their lives was told in an interesting fashion to keep me gripped and I kept wondering when I'd get to the part I actually picked up this book for. Coming out of this book was like walking through a maze I'd been wandering around in for 3 days with no clear indication of where I was going, only to realize that this book ends with no real conclusion and that it should have been shelved to be published when this case is over. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
avidreaderandgeekgirl's profile picture

avidreaderandgeekgirl's review

3.25
dark emotional informative fast-paced

The crazy true story of Lori Vallow, Chad Daybell, and the deaths surrounding them. 
I felt like the author blamed Chad for everything. I feel like Lori had more power in the relationship than the author gave her, especially in the crimes surrounding her relatives. I also felt like he didn't get enough into the details. I learned a few new details, but the book also missed some things about the case I've learned from other sources.
Overall, an okay overview of the case. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark emotional informative fast-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings