Reviews

The Best American Science Writing 2001 by Timothy Ferris, Jesse Cohen

coleycole's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Not as good as last years... More meh.

toniclark's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Really good collection this year -- but my absolute fave was "The Deadly Choices at Memorial" -- which was riveting. Sheri Fink won a Pulitzer for that (didn't know when I was reading it).

jackgoss's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This was kind of hit or miss. A lot of the articles are great, but a few left me so bored that I put the book down for a few months.

balletbookworm's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

A very well-curated collection of science essays spanning from perennial sources The New York Times Magazine, The New Yorker, and Discover to Vanity Fair and Mother Jones to the Speakeasy Science and Not Exactly Rocket Science blogs. Great breadth of sources.

Must-read articles include "What Broke My Father's Heart" (included in [b:The Best American Essays 2011|11664009|The Best American Essays 2011|Edwidge Danticat|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1328836776s/11664009.jpg|16609105], "BP's Dark Secrets", "The Estrogen Dilemma" (this one is really good, I took a course in clinical epidemiology from one of the original researchers on the WHI study that was terminated due to unexpectedly poor outcomes), "Cary in the Sky With Diamonds", and "The Enemy Within".

pattydsf's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I obviously like the Best American series since I have ten volumes from six different series on my bookshelf here. I have more of them on my real wooden bookcases, that I glance through from time to time. I know that trying to keep up with these series is an impossible task, but I keep acquiring them.

I suspect family and friends would prefer that I didn't read this kind of book. My inclination when I learn new facts that are fascinating to me, is to share them with anyone within earshot. So while I was reading these 25 essays, I told people about fermentation, weather forecasters who don't believe in climate change, underground coal fires and even how long a home run could possibly be. I know that no one would believe that there were facts I learned that I didn't tell them. But I figured I had bored them enough.

If you enjoy learning about new worlds, new ideas, or encountering creative writers and thinkers, there is a Best American series for you.

callieisreading's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

A decent collection of science writing, although a bit on the bleak side. The first three stories were about the author discovering he is a hoarder, a father being kept alive by pacemaker while suffering dementia, and a mother who has two sons diagnosed with a rare form of muscular dystrophy, and her attempts to procure funding for research. What's great about these articles is that even when they occasionally get technical, they never feel too pretentious or bogged down.



bakudreamer's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Didn't know the ' Conficker ' computer worm was such a big deal

bakudreamer's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Going to read all of these as well

carrie562's review against another edition

Go to review page

"The Mess He Made" -- author's personal experience with hoarding. Not very science-y, but interesting.

"What Broke My Father's Heart" -- another personal essay, about the downside of a pacemaker artificially extending the life of an elderly man unable to care for himself after a stroke. Powerful & informative.

alexctelander's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

BEST AMERICAN SCIENCE WRITING 2007 EDITED BY GINA KOLATA: Since this is the “best American science writing” of the year, you know it’s going to be good. What’s amazing is the variety of subject matter that just the term “science” covers. The result is a collection of incredible articles covering the latest discoveries and breakthroughs in the many different fields of science.

While this collection may not be for the average person who has little-to-no knowledge of science – some background is necessary – the beauty of a collection of articles, like a collection of short stories, is if you don’t like the particular article or find it too complicated, you can simply skip to the next. The first article, “The Theory of Everything” by Tyler Cabot covers the completion next year of a vastly superior particle accelerator in Switzerland. With the results from this giant machine, physics and science may be advanced greatly, with astonishing discoveries made. Cabot talks about this new device, as well as providing a summary of the important theories in science right now proposing possible answers to the famous Unification Theory: the theory linking relativity and quantum mechanics, or in Douglas Adams’s words: “Life, the Universe, and Everything.”

Robin Marantz Henig provides the latest ideas and technology on telling whether someone is lying or not in “Looking for the Lie.” Joshua Davis discusses the unique condition of prosopagnosia, or “face blindness.” A lot of people don’t even realize they have it; some develop it after a severe head wound or a stroke. It is a condition where the person simply does not recognize faces at all, as if they are blank pages that mean nothing to that person. The people suffering from this condition often have to use clues like clothes and the sound of a voice to recognize a person. But now with online groups linking these people together, breakthroughs are being made, as science goes one step closer to finding out the root cranial cause of this condition.

In “A Depression Switch,” David Dobbs talks about a new technique for helping patients who suffer from a form of depression so severe that no medication will help, and they are left with no choice but to remain in a padded cell. The procedure involves implanting tiny electrodes to a specific point in the brain, known as Area 25, attached to a small pacemaker that emits a minute four-volt charge. Miraculously, patients feel the depression go away, and whatever was missing in their lives returns instantly. It really seems to act like a switch and be as simple as that. With almost twenty patients, the new procedure is very much still in its infant stages, but could one day be a successful cure to this form of severe depression.

Oliver Sacks, Elizabeth Kolbert, Sylvia Nasar and Atul Gawande are just a few of the authors whose articles are featured in this collection, running the gamut from space and the universe, to mathematics, to neuroscience, to global warming and environmental awareness, to what science aids on blockbuster movies like The Hulk actually do. The Best American Science Writing 2007 will teach you things you never even knew were being studied, as well as give you hope that there are still many people out there working to make this place a better world.