Scan barcode
fromthefoxhole's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
6 stars, maybe more. this book is about to be my whole personality. I can't even begin to articulate how much I enjoyed it!! I wanted to start it over again the second it ended. ðŸ˜
Frankenstein is one of my all time favorite books, and when I heard "queer feminist retelling" I could not sprint to Libby faster. Having finished Our Hideous Progeny, I would term it more as a sequel - our FMC is Mary, the grand niece of Victor Frankenstein, who only knew of him through the letters our dear Captain Walton left behind. Luckily for us, that voracious curiosity that once consumed Victor very much also has had its claws in Mary since she was young. While she was barred from a formal education as a scientist, she makes up for it with force of will and wit, an insatiable desire for knowledge, and tenacity shaped by a lifetime of exclusion and rejection.
The plot for the first third of the novel is largely to allow us to get to know Mary. We get to see flashbacks of her past alongside instances in the "present" that give weight to her frustration with the scientific society as well as her love for paleontology and natural history. I feel like this slower beginning pace can be frustrating, but it lets our impatience mount with Mary's until finally we arrive at the exciting bit - actually moving forward with attempting to recreate Victor's experiment.
The pace picks up from here for us as the reader as well as for Mary, and things start to spiral out. I won't spoil anything, but relationships take turns, altercations occur, and I ate. it. up. McGill does a phenomenal job getting to the heart of Mary's motives, focusing on her grief, queerness, and living as a woman in a society that regularly demeans women. I found myself getting riled up right alongside Mary, especially in every instance with my new nemesis, Finlay Clarke.
I LOVED the real world references, that the author rooted so much of the story in real and period accurate science. Mary and Henry speak with and are referred to scientists whose work we can still read and those dinosaur sculptures are still up at the Crystal Palace!! The absolute nerd in me couldn't get enough.
Especially for a first novel, I think Our Hideous Progeny hit every target it intended to. I personally cannot wait to see what else McGill writes.
Frankenstein is one of my all time favorite books, and when I heard "queer feminist retelling" I could not sprint to Libby faster. Having finished Our Hideous Progeny, I would term it more as a sequel - our FMC is Mary, the grand niece of Victor Frankenstein, who only knew of him through the letters our dear Captain Walton left behind. Luckily for us, that voracious curiosity that once consumed Victor very much also has had its claws in Mary since she was young. While she was barred from a formal education as a scientist, she makes up for it with force of will and wit, an insatiable desire for knowledge, and tenacity shaped by a lifetime of exclusion and rejection.
The plot for the first third of the novel is largely to allow us to get to know Mary. We get to see flashbacks of her past alongside instances in the "present" that give weight to her frustration with the scientific society as well as her love for paleontology and natural history. I feel like this slower beginning pace can be frustrating, but it lets our impatience mount with Mary's until finally we arrive at the exciting bit - actually moving forward with attempting to recreate Victor's experiment.
The pace picks up from here for us as the reader as well as for Mary, and things start to spiral out. I won't spoil anything, but relationships take turns, altercations occur, and I ate. it. up. McGill does a phenomenal job getting to the heart of Mary's motives, focusing on her grief, queerness, and living as a woman in a society that regularly demeans women. I found myself getting riled up right alongside Mary, especially in every instance with my new nemesis, Finlay Clarke.
I LOVED the real world references, that the author rooted so much of the story in real and period accurate science. Mary and Henry speak with and are referred to scientists whose work we can still read and those dinosaur sculptures are still up at the Crystal Palace!! The absolute nerd in me couldn't get enough.
Especially for a first novel, I think Our Hideous Progeny hit every target it intended to. I personally cannot wait to see what else McGill writes.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Animal cruelty, Misogyny, and Animal death
Moderate: Slavery, Sexual harassment, Medical content, Miscarriage, Racism, and Blood
More...