ryan_oneil's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This collection of short stories is all about what happens when people have access to a machine that tells you how you will die but not in a detailed way. For example, if it says, "Car accident," it could be that you get hit by a car but it could also be that you slip on a toy car and fall down a flight of stairs.

The stories range from interesting to funny to sad to thought-provoking. I enjoyed most of them.

nevermore's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A little morbid, but a great concept. I'm really interested by all the different directions the various authors took the basic concept of the Machine of Death.

elbaso's review

Go to review page

3.0

Some stories were better than others, but on the whole, kind of meh.

rheren's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I read this on a lark, and I was amazed at the creativity and cleverness of the amateur authors who penned the collection of stories based on this oddball but intriguing premise. It's mostly full of humor and irony, but there's a good bit of philosophical introspection, too. I enjoyed it immensely. Looking forward to reading the second one.

misterjay's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Flaming Marshmallow by Camille Alexa - Fun and optimistic. 3/5

Fudge by Kit Yona - Cryptic. 3/5

Torn Apart and Devoured by Lions by Jeffery Wells - This was great. Interesting take on optimism. 5/5

Despair by K.M. Lawrence - Thoughtful and sad; about blame and questions. 4/5

Suicide by David Michael Wharton - A little too clever. 3/5

Almond by John Chernega - Great story about the people who run the machine. 5/5

Starvation by M. Bennardo - Good military fiction about survival and fate. 4/5

Cancer by Camron Miller - Sadder than a lot of the other stories here. 4/5

Firing Squad by J. Jack Unrau - One of the better stories here. About the consequences of good deeds. 5/5

Vegetables by Chris Cox - Interesting. First story in the collection to look at the more sinister aspects of knowing how others will die. 5/5

Piano by Rafa Franco - Good; similar to many other stories in that it is a story about how the machines' readings and actual death may differ. 4/5

HIV Infection from Machine of Death Needle by Brian Quinlan - Hah. Kind of clever. 3/5

Exploded by Tom Francis - Good story about the men who invented the machine and how they died. 5/5

Not Waving But Drowning by Erin McKean - I liked this one. It’s got poetry in it. And hope. 5/5

Improperly Prepared Blowfish by Gord Sellar - Good, tight action story about the Yakuza and revenge. 5/5

Love Ad Nauseum by Sherri Jacobsen - Clever take on dating after the machine. 4/5

Murder and Suicide, Respectively by Ryan North - This one left me a little cold. It’s about murder, and suicide. 3/5

Cancer by David Malki - Heartbreaking, but very well written. 5/5

Aneurysm by Alexander Danner - Sleight of hand at a dinner party is almost never a good idea. 4/5

Exhaustion from Having Sex with a Minor by Ben Croshaw - Twist at the end that kind of short-serves the first half. 3/5

After Many Years, Stops Breathing, While Asleep, with Smile on Face by William Grallo - Trying to form relationships when everyone knows how they’re going to die can be hard. 3/5

Killed by Daniel by Julia Wainwright - Sad story about avoidance and acceptance when the name of your killer is the name of your son. 3/5

Friendly Fire by Douglas J. Lane - Interesting story about terrorism in the face of the machine. 4/5

Nothing by Pelotard - Some people get to live forever. The trick is figuring out who they are. 3/5

Cocaine and Painkillers by David Malki - Sales and infomercials sell lots of machines, but at what cost? 4/5

Loss of Blood by Jeff Stautz - Chilling story about a future society where in everyone’s worth is determined by the passivity of their death. 4/5

Prison Knife Fight by Shannon K. Garrity - Is someone whose life is planned from kindergarten to career actually free? 4/5

While Trying to Save Another by Daliso Chaponda - Sad story about true love in the face of certain, inevitable doom. 5/5

Miscarriage by James L. Sutter - Surprisingly, a happy story of sorts. About the decision to have children even when you can know how they’ll die. 4/5

Shot by Sniper by Bartholomew von Klick - Some other sniper, some other war. 5/5

Heat Death of the Universe by James Foreman - The machine is the universe imposing order on itself; even still we cannot know what this means. 4/5

Drowning by C.E. Himont - Psychics and dream readers don’t like the machine. It’s bad for business. 3/5

? by Randall Munroe - Hmm. Not sure what to think about that one; it’s by far the angriest story in the collection. Demanding answers in the face of wilful ignorance. 3/5

Cassandra by T.J. Radcliffe - Nothing like a saving the world story to round out the collection. 4/5

theaurochs's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Re-read for the umpteenth time; still a fantastic collection of existentialist short stories.
Ranging from laugh-out-loud funny, to thoughtful, to heartbreaking, to intriguing; there's a little bit of everything is this collection. And yet the central premise ties it all together so as not to feel jarring.
Will keep this review short, as the only other option is a multi-page essay to talk about all my thoughts and feelings about this book.
It's great though, please read it.

lkthomas07's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I just love both of the Machine of Death books. I adore short stories, and especially when they're (mostly) written by different authors. You get so many different POVs about the machine, the world, etc. Always worth the read!


[12/28/23 edit: Reread and still loved! This year I read it for the PopSugar 2023 challenge prompt: A book you read more than 10 years ago]

pammy_taylor's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

34 short stories by different authors with the same prompt about a machine that tells you how you will die. The culmination of 34 different perspectives world-building around the same new element was so unique and fascinating, it became one of my favorite collections. 

jennitheghost's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I loved this book! The stories were amazing, varied, funny, sad and all so interesting! I will think about this book for a long time.

jeffmauch's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A collection of short stories by a multitude of authors all based on the same premise....There's a machine that with a simple prick of a needle can tell you how you're going to die, but there's a catch, it's often ambiguous and more importantly it's always right. You'd think you'd find a way to avoid it, but nobody ever does. Maybe your slip says "plane crash" so you never fly again, but just maybe one crashes into your office building, maybe it says something as basic as "test" then what? These stories were varied and each author put their own spin on the endless possibilities available for the premise. I enjoyed almost all of them to some extent and will probably go so far as to read the next book in the series someday.