Reviews

Angel #1 by Gabriel Cassata, Bryan Edward Hill, Dan Panosian, Gleb Melnikov

jodi_ice's review

Go to review page

4.0

Cawpile: 7.86 4*

queenkoko's review

Go to review page

3.0

Not a fan of when comics or novels talk about how teenagers are so into social media and don't have a brain. It started off strong and I was intrigued, but then broody Angel, the broody vampire that we all know, started off with his brooding and I was over it. I was also over the cliche plot. I did enjoy the artwork and more sadness for Angel. I was never an Angel fan. Interesting start but I will not be continuing.

denizerkaradag's review

Go to review page

4.0

I can't wait to see them together again.

kimberlea's review

Go to review page

4.0

I actually ended up liking this a lot more than I did Prologue. In fact, I would go so far to say that this is the best comic that BOOM! Studios have produced for their Buffyverse reboot so far. I think it introduces Angel as a character a lot better, slips in Angel's backstory — or rather, this reimagined version of his backstory — for anyone who hasn't seen the television show before, and is just all around a more interesting story than what we were originally given. I'm glad I didn't write this series off after Prologue.

I'll admit that I didn't really enjoy Melnikov's style illustration in Prologue, especially when compared to Dan Mora's. Here it is used to full effect, and somehow just seems to work better. Melnikov's illustrations look like rough sketches, yet they somehow add to the dark tone of the comics. He also manages to pack a lot of detail into 20 pages. The tone of the comics is fairly similar to that of the television show, and Hill pretty much nails Angel's dialogue and broody behaviour. The story that we were given in this issue actually reminded me of the episode 'I've Got You Under My Skin' from season one of Angel, so I'm hoping that Hill has come up with a story of his own (or at least an interesting spin on the original!).

I did enjoy that Hill dived right into Angel's history as Angelus. We open on Angelus murdering what appears to be a Slayer, and it means that the creative team can touch on themes such as redemption right off the bat, which is really what the television show was all about  — after all, one of the most famous quotes from the show is, 'If nothing we do matters, then all that matters is what we do.'

One thing I would like to see more once this series gets on its feet is perhaps some connection to the Buffy comics. While I didn't expect a crossover straight away, Angel avoids referencing both its sister comic and the Buffyverse at large. I don't really have any interest in the original characters produced, with the exception of Lilith, and a familiar face would be nice. I'll be interested to see if Cordelia pops up in the Angel comics, since she's currently busy befriending Spike over in Buffy, but also wouldn't be opposed with Doyle, Fred, or Gunn making an appearance.

If the rest of this series is as good as this, I think it's going to be a hell of a reboot.

theramenreader's review

Go to review page

5.0

I love it! The artwork is amazing and the modern elements are great.

shannonleighd's review

Go to review page

2.0

1.5

This was so generic that if it hadn't been called "Angel" I wouldn't have even made the connection.

theresidentbookworm's review

Go to review page

2.0

What I Thought Of Angel Being Broody in 2019 (Or My Thoughts on Angel #1)

1. I really liked the opening sequences. Stupidly, I was hoping Mara was a Slayer who would
live, and then I saw that it was Angelus, and I knew there was no hope.
Still, it's a really cool way to start the issue and show Angel as Angelus.

2. I am really into Gleb Melnikov's artwork in this issue. It fits the mood of Angel as a character and the world he inhabits, and I love the style, particularly how thick the lines are and the way he draws Angel.

3. Predictably, Angel does not think much of 21st century teens, social media, or how 21st century interact with it. However, there was an unexpected sympathy to Angel's judgement and dismay. It's like he's observing them and feels bad this is the path they're choosing. He wants them to have innocence longer, which is admirable if misguided.

4. Angel's interaction with the Instagram teenager is golden. I laughed so hard. I feel like Angel could have a small following of teenagers if he wanted. I could see 2019 teenagers bein into his aesthetic. Also, though, since when can't Angel be photographed? Is that new? Or is that lore I'm missing.

5. Who is this random dude Angel goes to visit for advice, a kid whom he once saved? Is this supposed to be Doyle? Please say no. I want Doyle to be a real character.

6. I'm not sure who Lilith is. Maybe she's a character from the Angelverse that I haven't gotten to yet, or maybe she's a new character. Either way, I love her. She is goals for me. I love that she just comes to give Angel vague prophecies and cryptic advice. What goals.
More...