Reviews with content warning for Toxic relationship - The Girl Before: Sie war wie du. Und jetzt ist sie tot.

Reviews tagging 'Toxic relationship'

The Girl Before: Sie war wie du. Und jetzt ist sie tot. by JP Delaney

20 reviews

_mack_jack_'s review against another edition

dark mysterious sad fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? N/A
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.25

it was out best by another review i saw: yet another book choosing to subvert expectations with a nonsensical twist instead of giving the plot and characters the follow-through they earned. this book was a page-turner but ultimately lackluster.

what i wanted from the book initially was to be shocked and to have my expectations subverted. as i learned more about the characters, i wanted to see the natural conclusion come about. i think the author focused on shock value over realism when coming up with plot points. the complexities of the characters, specifically the men, are unexplored to their fullest because the author takes them off course at random. the women are flawed and emotional humans, which is always good to see, but emma specifically is written to be almost a villain as the book progresses. at first it was a captivating twist, but again the path it took broke my suspension of disbelief.

did i enjoy reading it? yes. would i recommend it? no.

Content Warnings

bookishmillennial's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional mysterious sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

disclaimer: I don’t really give starred reviews. I hope my reviews provide enough information to let you know if a book is for you or not. Find me here: https://linktr.ee/bookishmillennial

This is The Girl Before by JP Delaney, which is a pseudonym for Anthony Capella, who writes under this name and another. This book was adapted into a mini series on HBO Max, which I watched before reading this. It was actually the reason I decided to read it. I felt the ending of the show was somewhat of a letdown so I wanted to see if the book had a different ending. I don't want to spoil it for those of you who haven't watched the show but this was a fairly quick and easy read - I ravished through it in about 3 hours!

This book rotates between two people's perspectives - Emma, who is prefaced as "Then". She and her boyfriend Simon have just experienced a break in at their old flat and they are looking for a new rental property. Emma was held at knifepoint during this break in and Simon was out.

The other perspective is from Jane, who is prefaced as "Now". Jane has suffered the loss of her baby, and is looking for somewhere new to live. One Folgate Street, is recommended to both of them -which is a unique property, not only in its minimalistic and almost cold design, but that there are a set of over 200 rules that you have to follow while you live there, such as no children, no pets, no cushions, no frames or photos..

I already know that no one on BookTok could live here because no books are allowed either. I know, the outrage! Anyway, Edward Monkford is the owner, the architect and the creator of this house and its rules. He personally interviews everyone who fills out the application questionnaire successfully and approves Emma and Jane, albeit in different times. Also, they look a lot alike.

Emma and Simon clearly have a struggling relationship, and as more of Emma's trauma comes to the surface, it puts a wedge between them, pushing her towards Edward and they begin an affair. Then, Jane starts an eerily similar relationship with Edward, a few years into the future. It is made known to Jane and the readers early on that Emma died in this house and Jane begins to question everything about the house's technology, the past and Edward.

I would say that if you haven't watched the show, this could be a fun quick vacation or weekend read. If you have watched the show, mmmmm you might not be missing too much. However, I did appreciate that they clarified what the relationship was with Jane's previous baby daddy, which I didn't get clarity in the show. I also thought Edward was just as annoying in this book as in the show, like when he tells Jane she should be cleaner down there for him. I liked that in the book, these people are definitely white and in the show, they are Black with a great cast (Gugu Mbatha-Raw is my wife) so I do recommend it!

Content Warnings