Reviews

Katherine Carlyle by Rupert Thomson

redroofcolleen's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

A woman-child plays hide-and-seek from her unknowing father, meets some unsavory characters, is used and uses others even more, before deciding that she does, in fact, need and want her father in her life.

lisa_mc's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Can we have memories from before we were born? Katherine Carlyle feels she does: memories from her eight years frozen in storage as an embryo. Cold and dark, those eight years give her a worldliness and insight past what would be expected in a typical 19-year-old.

But Katherine -- who goes by Kit, or Misty, if the mood takes her -- is not a typical 19-year-old.

Motherless, rootless, fierce and independent, sometimes naive and stubborn, she’s on the cusp of adulthood, with a place at a prestigious university, but chooses -- more accurately, is driven by some internal force -- to wander across Europe and eventually to the Arctic.

Kit and her parents moved to Rome from Britain while her mother was fighting cancer, which she would ultimately not survive. Her father is a longtime foreign correspondent, rarely home. Kit is certain he blames her -- her clinical conception, her deliberate birth -- for the illness and death of her mother.

Before she is due to leave for university, Kit decides on another path. She just goes, not telling her father anything, trying to make him worry -- or to see whether he even misses her once he’s back from his latest assignment. She overhears a couple talking about a German friend of theirs, notes his name and heads to Berlin, engineering a “chance” meeting with him and insinuating herself into his life, briefly. From there, she leaves for Moscow, then north to Archangelsk, and finally on to a remote mining colony in the farthest frigid reaches of Russia: “nowhere at all, adrift in subzero waters, virtually unreachable during the winter months.”

Kit is not the most reliable of narrators, and at times we’re left wondering what actually happens and what’s in her head. She constructs an elaborate plan to inform her father of her whereabouts, and then imagines, with varying degrees of plausibility, the conversations he has with people she’s met along the way while he is looking for her. But this is much of the appeal of the story. We have no idea where it’s going or what to expect; we’re along for the ride with Kit, compelled to see it to the end.

Thomson’s writing is straightforward and well-paced while staying thoughtful. His vivid descriptions capture not only what’s being described, but the mood of Kit herself. German names are “truncated, harsh, almost greedy, like bites taken out of something crisp,” while Russian names are “polysyllabic, clumsy … like numb fingers trying to grasp something in the cold.”

A journey in a novel is typically a quest, an escape or a picaresque romp. Kit’s has elements of all of those. She’s searching for something, but she doesn’t really know what; she’s running from something, but it’s nebulous rather than specific; she has some interesting adventures with colorful people.

Kit is not as much trying to find herself as lose herself. “This is not, at heart, a physical journey,” she muses. “It’s more like a journey back in time -- or sideways, into another dimension. … My life is light and tidy now, like a rucksack that holds nothing but the bare essentials.” But what she loses -- and finds -- in the end wouldn’t have been possible without the journey.

michelle_coenen's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark medium-paced

3.0

sharong's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Always love Rupert Thomson's books and this one did not disappoint!

andrew61's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I picked up this book after hearing the author discussed on the backlisted podcast and think I have now found a writer that I am looking forward to exploring if this uniquely interesting and compelling novel is typical of his storytelling.
We are introduced to Katherine as an embryo frozen in a flask eight years before her birth. Fast forward to K at 19,living in Rome, and about to go to university in Oxford. Her father is a reporter who in travelling the world neglects his daughter who is grieving from the recent death of her mother. K disappears, throwing her phone in the river and goes on a trip from Berlin , to Moscow, and eventually to a remote town on the Arctic circle.
In her adventures she is enigmatic as she establishes short relationships and reflects on her loss, her life, and the impact of having to wait to be born.
Imaginative and well written this was a book which I raced through but also didn't want to end.

jmstergas's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

1.0

This book was a huge disappointment. Something very unsettling about a man writing about a young woman who encounters a bunch of random men who want to take advantage of her throughout her journey. Not to mention the whole book was essentially a stream of consciousness with little purpose or plot

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

anatomydetective's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Yet another well-written character study. I read a lot of these lately. Despite its attempt to be plot-driven, it was a story of character and places.

stirling's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional reflective medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? Yes

3.75

bretts_book_stack's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Strange, dreamlike. Someone described this as literary David Lynch and that feels about right. A nineteen year old girl who was an IVF baby goes on a spiritual quest after her Mother dies of cancer. Thomson creates a weird, compelling, foreboding narrative, but I started to give up on dear Kate three quarters of the way through because she quickly became as cold as the cryogenic tank she'd been taken from.

abetterfate's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I have lost my tolerance for old white men writing about their reckless, magical, sexy teenage girls.