Reviews

The Winter Spirits: Twelve Ghostly Tales for Festive Nights by Catriona Ward, Imogen Hermes Gowar, Kiran Millwood Hargrave, Stuart Turton, Elizabeth Macneal, Andrew Michael Hurley, Jess Kidd, Bridget Collins, Laura Shepherd-Robinson, Susan Stokes-Chapman, Laura Purcell, Natasha Pulley

there_and_book_again's review against another edition

dark tense fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? N/A
• Strong character development? N/A
• Loveable characters? N/A
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

write_read_rose's review against another edition

dark mysterious tense medium-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix

4.0

drjoannehill's review against another edition

dark mysterious fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? N/A
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? No
• Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

Another good collection, like The Haunting Season, with some excellent and some not bad. Natasha Pulley excellent, Laura Purcell too, and Jess Kidd better than in the first collection. 

eshalliday's review against another edition

3.0

I’ll sadly start by saying that ‘Host’ by [a:Kiran Millwood Hargrave|5868487|Kiran Millwood Hargrave|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1579440732p2/5868487.jpg] just isn’t a strong enough curtain-raiser for this collection, although I am a follower of her work. Something more atmospheric like ‘Carol of the Bells and Chains’ by [a:Laura Purcell|22701274|Laura Purcell|https://s.gr-assets.com/assets/nophoto/user/u_50x66-632230dc9882b4352d753eedf9396530.png] (an out-of-the-ordinary, totally creepfest-y retelling of the Krampus legend, which concludes the collection), would make more of an impact; would draw back the bolt on this collection with a bit more flair.

‘The Winter Spirits’ contains a number of stories by truly sensational authors whom I’d count as favourites, such as [a:Bridget Collins|14717647|Bridget Collins|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1548771665p2/14717647.jpg], [a:Elizabeth Macneal|17715039|Elizabeth Macneal|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1540803664p2/17715039.jpg], and the abovementioned Laura Purcell, which elevate it above your ordinary literary Christmas Selection Box. There are a couple of contributions that I had to DNF (including ‘The Master of the House’ by Stuart Turton) because they just aren’t quite up to the standard of the rest. And even though I did listen to all of ‘Jenkin’ by [a:Catriona Ward|13801540|Catriona Ward|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1438105097p2/13801540.jpg], I kind of wish I’d DNF’ed it too, because, although it has an intriguing principal idea, it’s just as distasteful as [b:Looking Glass Sound|60784412|Looking Glass Sound|Catriona Ward|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1667233877l/60784412._SY75_.jpg|93526489] in its awful misrepresentation of lesbian women.

The standout contributor is [a:Natasha Pulley|8446650|Natasha Pulley|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1490274030p2/8446650.jpg] (whom I credit with getting me back into reading-for-pleasure with [b:The Silent Companions|35458733|The Silent Companions|Laura Purcell|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1500725504l/35458733._SY75_.jpg|55746774] in 2017, after a long period during my Ph.D and then lecturing&teaching, where reading was mostly ‘for work’). With ‘The Salt Miracles’, Pulley successfully achieves what [b:The Colony|57977494|The Colony|Audrey Magee|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1634231936l/57977494._SY75_.jpg|90846914] by Audrey Magee was reaching for last year in terms of conveying the otherness of the stranger new-arrived into the midst of an established community, as well as the touch of naïveté with regard to that community’s practices when seen through the other’s eyes. For me, this extraordinary short story also brought to mind last year’s similarly themed holy-pilgrimage-to-an-island novel [b:Haven|59801788|Haven|Emma Donoghue|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1655070093l/59801788._SY75_.jpg|91026101] by the exceptional [a:Emma Donoghue|23613|Emma Donoghue|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1591714728p2/23613.jpg], in terms of the tenor of the mood, in terms of the rewriting of religious tropes, and in terms of striking imagery. And ‘Ada Lark’ by [a:Jess Kidd|15044123|Jess Kidd|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1564173437p2/15044123.jpg] is just as unforgettable as ‘The Salt Miracles’! In fact, they both feature fully ornamented characters and each premise twinkles with all the colour and energy of a full-length novel. I'd highly recommend this collection as a treat, if only to collect the incredible seasonal stories by the five or so authors highlighted above.

fawnsbooks's review against another edition

dark fast-paced

3.0

annaelisabeth6's review against another edition

5.0

4.8⭐️

Top 5:

1. Banished - Elizabeth Macneal
2. Ada Lark - Jess Kidd
3. Host - Kiran Millwood Hargrave
4. The Master of the House - Stuart Turton
5. Widow’s Walk - Susan Stokes-Chapman

narwhal13's review against another edition

dark emotional mysterious tense

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? It's complicated
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

barbs0822's review against another edition

dark mysterious tense fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? Plot
• Strong character development? N/A
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? N/A
• Flaws of characters a main focus? N/A

4.5

ems_99's review

dark mysterious sad tense fast-paced

4.5

I really enjoyed every single story in this collection. They were all eerie and atmospheric. Each story was so well written with satisfying endings. I particularly enjoyed the final 5 stories as they just got better and better (didn’t expect any less from these authors though!)

amalia1985's review against another edition

dark mysterious tense fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? Yes
• Loveable characters? It's complicated
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

 

‘’Tuppence for a bag of salt, tuppence for a bag of pins. Tuppence for a dead man’s hand, tuppence and I’ll eat thy sins.’’

Well, I thought I would finish this collection within three days but work and life in general got in the way. This was for the better since I had the chance to truly savour each story, to fully experience the darkness and the eerie silence of each tale. As February ends and the nights get shorter and shorter, this beautiful volume seems only appropriate for me to bid goodbye to an excellent winter (reading-wise, mind you…)

Mainly set during the days leading to Christmas, in a variety of places and eras, these stories will transport you to haunted mansions and theatres, to wuthering moors and threatening marshes, to foreboding churches and graveyards. Spirits that seek justice and mortals that seek wealth or validation will lead you to a wintery world where the holly and the ivy bear blood and not white blossoms…

Host (Kiran Millwood Hargrave): An affluent couple wants to communicate with the spirit of their daughter. They obey the medium’s wishes, but their despair will cause all Hell to break loose. There’s been a plethora of medium stories lately, but this one is quite unusual, and atmospheric.

Inferno (Laura Shepherd-Robinson): A man who tries to escape from the sins he has committed, finds refuge in a strange villa in Lake Garda, inhabited by an enchanting young woman and an elderly servant. The end will shock you and the story itself is a masterpiece of twists and psychological terror.

‘’All the children in town knew the story of the Old Play, even if they’d never seen it. Parents would tell it to them at bedtime. Everyone knew the plot - how the beautiful Maiden Queen was bewitched by the Tuppenny Hag and put to sleep in the faraway world. How the Tuppenny Hag tempted the Beggar to take the Maiden Queen’s golden locker, which he did so as to feed his starving family. How the Greenwood Folk offered to guide him out of the forest but led him to the Magistrate instead, who pronounced him a sentence of death.’’

The Old Play (Andrew Michael Hurley): Oh, my God, what a story! An actor, who has a few demons to fight, prepares for the annual performance of a strange Christmas play. However, tonight’s show is special…I’ve always thought there is something eerie when it comes to the backstage energy and the preparation of a play and here this aura of uneasiness and nervousness is communicated to perfection. One of the most unique stories I’ve ever read.

‘’Nobody should be in the attic. Nobody should be sewing on the machine. It simply cannot be. And yet it rumbles on. Outside the wind is blundering about the house, and the sea on my horizon is roaring, but still the rattle of the sewing machine penetrates it all, persistent, accusatory, until I press the pillow over my head to block it out, and still the noise comes and comes. Even when I take the laudanum I keep at my bedside the rhythm penetrates its fog: ‘It’s me,’ it seems to purr. ‘It’s me, it’s me, it’s me.’’

A Double Thread (Imogen Hermes Gowar): A selfish woman has moved to Penzance, haunted by a family scandal. Her one concern is the outstanding silk gown she wants to prepare for Christmas. Her new seamstress is impeccable but even that is not enough for such an entitled, spoiled human being. Even though the ending may seem predictable, Imogen Hermes Gowar creates an eerie story and a protagonist that is insufferable, yet fascinating. 

The Salt Miracles (Natasha Pulley): A priest travels to the remote island of St Hilda in Scotland to investigate a series of strange occurrences, characterised as ‘miracles’.

   This story had so much potential. Had a truly talented writer written this tale, it would have been a masterpiece. But now? I feel that Natasha Pulley needs to stop treating every theme as material for readers who only read idiotic YA ‘books’. How she teaches Creative Writing is utterly beyond me. The story is supposedly set in the era of Arthur Conan Doyle and the language is like a composition of a 10-year-old pupil. Or perhaps, even worse. Her incompetence turned an eerie folk tale into a pitiful comedy…

Banished (Elizabeth Macneal): A healer is summoned by a powerful man to exorcize the troubling ghost of his wife. The woman doesn’t know that she has stepped into the heart of a terrible case of injustice, cruelty and revenge. A remarkable story set in Edinburgh during the 1700s based on a true incident.

The Gargoyle (Bridget Collins): Jesus, what a story! Do you know the feeling when you watch a really good horror film and you just know there is something worrying even though the frame only shows thick darkness and nothing else? That’s how effective this story is. You’ll walk through the eerie graveyard, and you’ll listen to the rain on the window and you’ll smell old house decay, while you’re sympathizing with the writer who tries to exorcize her demons through her work.

The Master of the House (Stuart Turton): I’m sorry but if I were Thomas, I’d choose to flee with the Devil too! Set in 1901, this rather unusual, yet no less terrifying story, is a mad mix of A Christmas Carol and The Omen, forming a hallucinatory Gothic fantasy.

‘’She dances with it out across the lawn, down the slope, loving the cold air on her face and the crunch underfoot. Only her footprints in this bright frozen world. She misses a catch and the ball rolls down the path and under the gate. The girl gives chase. Ignoring the calls of the nanny, the gardener, she bolts through the gate and out into the wide-open space of the marshland, benign under the sun-dazzled sky. A place of wading birds, waving reeds, low hillocks, rushes rustling, greedy pools, sucking earth, the closing of the day, hot panic, missed footing, the winter moon, dead calm.’’

Ada Lark (Jess Kidd): Written in Jess Kidd’s signature present tense style, this is the haunting story of a gifted child and a trap in the form of a seance. But spirits and children have a mind of their own…

‘’But I get stronger with each of your deceptions. And you get thinner and thinner. Soon there will be nothing of you left.’’

Jenkin (Catriona Ward): How would you like to be haunted by a strange cat-like creature which would appear when you behave in a ‘dishonest’ way? An outstanding story, full of twists and true pain that you simply HAVE TO read.

‘’Widow’s Walk. The townsfolk called it this on account of the churchyard on the other side of the hedge, where, buried in a line spanning the length of it, were the graves of unfortunate women who had lost their lives in some unhappy way, each and every one of them a widow.’’

Widow’s Walk (Susan Stokes-Chapman): A French woman, who has followed her husband to England, is now alone. Struggling with the aftermath of this loss, her only consolation is her art, her beautiful fans, beloved by the high society of the city. But when she comes home every night, a dark presence is lurking in the shadows of her chamber, and someone is following her, night after night, as she passes through Widow’s Walk.

   Although I was able to suspect the route the story would take, the closure was no less shocking. A darkly beautiful, haunting Christmas tale.

Carol of the Bells and Chains (Laura Purcell): It’s no wonder that in a collection full of excellent stories, Laura Purcell’s tale is the jewel in the crown. She takes a governess (whose life seems to be filled with secrets), troublesome children and the terrifying legend of Krampus and creates a quintessentially British masterpiece.

I was amazed to read a reviewer’s opinion that stated how ‘’similar these stories felt’. Are we even serious? Excuse me. Having read most novels by the writers whose stories grace this collection, I can assure you that their distinctive voices can be heard loud and clear. Unless you read smut and YA in which case this volume is not for your little minds.

Keep these exceptional collections coming, please. They are Christmas presents in print.

‘’It was a blessed sight that greeted me: fires blazing in the hearts, a plate of steaming mince pies, so hot that I scalded my mouth. Garlands were slung from the picture rails, in great big bushels - holy and ivy for eternal life, the berries for Jesus’ shed blood - and the air was thick with the scent of ground cloves and ginger.’’

My reviews can also be found on https://theopinionatedreaderblog.wordpress.com/