Scan barcode
robin1010's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
mysterious
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
I really enjoyed this book! Great classic high fantasy, with interesting, well developed and diverse characters. Its definitely a slow burn, both in sense of plot and in the romance, but the author builds tension and pays it off well. I'll definitely be reading at least the next book (originally a duology) to finish the plot.
One of the biggest contentions in the reviews seems to be the writing/world building. The writing was honestly not that dense and reasonably easy to follow, especially compared to some other high fantasy books. The author didn't waffle too much, and anything she did linger on was more of a Chekov's gun situation. Bits of lore/world building or political intrigue were definitely densely packed though and needed a close reading to understand what was going on. If you're a particularly fastidious reader it can be helpful to have notes, but you'll manage fine without.
As I mentioned, the plot is a slow burn, but the slower pace suited the novel, and gave us appropriate time to get used to the characters, give us world building, and get a sense of the scale of place we're dealing with. It also gave the characters room to grow between major plot points so their victories felt more hard won. An exception to this is Nysander's magic. Often it felt his magic seemed to circumvent the plot or offer an easy escape, like at the last conflict where he turns them into birds, despite never having done so or mentioned doing so before. It is a fantasy novel and the magic added is interesting, but it felt a bit like it was cheapening the conflict in some places . The political plots were a bit more difficult to follow, and does often feel like you're reading in loops with no end, but I felt it paid off to a satisfying ending, and it feels rather straightforward in hindsight. There were definitely bits that felt needlessly complicated - the Lerans for example, we're only told they have an heir to put on the throne towards the end of the book, not when their desire to overthrow the queen is mentioned even though one of the characters in that scene does know this, so for a while they seem an utterly nonsensical group that want to overthrow the only lineage that can keep Skala safe . There are some classic fantasy tropes here and there that feel a bit well worn, but they're done well and I didn't mind them so much.
The characters were overall very well developed and distinct. I definitely found myself partial to the protagonist, which is always nice, although i found the insistence on his naivete a little bit excessive. Seregil was also an interesting character, if a bit predictable in his heritage and his general 'lovable scamp' nature . The dynamic between them was a touch awkward for decent amounts, honestly. Much of Seregil's interaction with Alec is very condescending, and Alec is repeatedly tricked or made a fool of for actions or aspects of himself that have literally saved Seregil's life in the past. There was a brief bit of confrontation about this towards the end that was satisfying, so I hope this improves in the second book. It does also settle better that the characters in the novel feel aware of it and its Seregil's flaw rather than it being an unself-aware author. Micum and his family were a great part of the novel. Women in general were excellently written, which is very rare in fantasy and classic fantasy especially as I'm sure most people are aware. All felt as distinct and well developed as the male cast, despite the fact that we didn't have a female 'main' character. The queen, Klia, and Beka are the most obvious examples, but I also enjoyed that Kari was a mother and a wife and still had her own goals, conflicts and personality. Being more overtly feminine/maternal didn't strip her of the rest of her character. I don't quite know if the same can be said of Ylinestra.
Despite some nitpicky bits here and there, I did have a good time reading this book, and I will continue on with the sequels.
One of the biggest contentions in the reviews seems to be the writing/world building. The writing was honestly not that dense and reasonably easy to follow, especially compared to some other high fantasy books. The author didn't waffle too much, and anything she did linger on was more of a Chekov's gun situation. Bits of lore/world building or political intrigue were definitely densely packed though and needed a close reading to understand what was going on. If you're a particularly fastidious reader it can be helpful to have notes, but you'll manage fine without.
As I mentioned, the plot is a slow burn, but the slower pace suited the novel, and gave us appropriate time to get used to the characters, give us world building, and get a sense of the scale of place we're dealing with. It also gave the characters room to grow between major plot points so their victories felt more hard won.
The characters were overall very well developed and distinct. I definitely found myself partial to the protagonist, which is always nice, although i found the insistence on his naivete a little bit excessive. Seregil was also an interesting character, if a bit predictable in
Despite some nitpicky bits here and there, I did have a good time reading this book, and I will continue on with the sequels.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Torture, Death, Violence, and Confinement
Moderate: Xenophobia and Animal death
Minor: Sexual violence, Miscarriage, and Sexual content
More...