jstuartmill's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Book is very dense and takes an eternity to read but it's well worth it. I learned more from this book than any science classes I took in college (I wasn't a science major).

bibliocyclist's review

Go to review page

3.0

"Everything not reported remains the same."

adiamond's review

Go to review page

3.0

I wanted to like this book, but it fell short of the title's promise on too many counts. The biggest problem was that so many of the theories were not adequately and certainly not elegantly explained. As other reviewers point out, many of the one- to three-page explanations from experts in various fields read like unedited emails.

If a reader can't summarize a three page article after a single pass, it often means the article wasn't very clear. The elegance of elegant theories usually comes from their clarity and simplicity. A better title for this book might be This Explains a Few Things: Ramblings from My Inbox.

It is a good bathroom reader, though. The better articles make you think. The muddled ones remind you it's time to get on with your day.

UPDATE Jan. 5, 2020: Upgraded from two stars to three. While the book is uneven, there are a few thought-provoking pieces here and there.

tofugirl's review

Go to review page

1.0

Disappointing. Inaccessible to the non-academic man on the street. Don't bother.
More...