Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.4 AVERAGE
4.4 AVERAGE
informative
reflective
Provided a valuable new lens for me to reconsider American history. Well researched and well documented and often painful to read because of the content. Also difficult to read in places with a complex, academic writing style.
informative
sad
medium-paced
This book was depressing, as (honestly) is the history of indigenous people in the United States. Really emphasizes the point that America was founded on a crime and land theft, however it really moves slowly for the first half, and the second half was overly repetitive. The conclusion did provide an interesting retrospective and introduced the idea of over-militarization in America, which I found interesting.
informative
challenging
dark
informative
medium-paced
Content Warnings
Graphic: Genocide, Racism, Colonisation
Moderate: Animal cruelty, Slavery, War
Minor: Alcoholism
This should be required reading for every student in the United States. It is also informative for folks outside of the US - to learn a fuller/more accurate history, and there are sections on the US as a colonizer/imperialist elsewhere around the world.
challenging
dark
emotional
informative
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Probably one of the most important books I’ve read in my entire life. I wish this had been taught to me in school. American exceptionalism is such a lie and the only way we will ever have a free nation for all people is if we admit to the past atrocities we have committed and dismantle our system from its imperialist and colonialist/capitalist roots. This also gave me a lot of context for why America is so pro-Israel and it’s because we have been committing genocide against indigenous people since DAY ONE. Israel is just taking notes from our playbook. This is a must read for all Americans to understand the true context in which we live. “Until we are all free, none of us are free” may the native Americans see freedom as well as all oppressed people groups around the world.
challenging
emotional
informative
sad
slow-paced
I went into this book knowing of the grave injustice that’s been perpetuated by the United States against indigenous people going as far back as colonial days. But there’s knowing and then there’s KNOWING. I don’t count myself in that second category because I’m not of native descent, so I will never “know” to that extent, but if I had been peering at the truth before, this book blew my eyes wide open.
It’s common knowledge that there are two sides to every story. It’s also commonly spoken though not commonly acknowledged that it is the winners who write history. My American education as it related to indigenous people focused primarily on the idyllic view of the first pilgrims sharing a meal with Native Americans, a brief overview of the Trail of Tears, Sacajawea guiding Lewis and Clark, and Disney’s movie, Pocahontas. More effort was put into teaching us how great our country was, how it amassed power under its credo of “manifest destiny” as was our God-given right. I remember thinking back then how proud I was to be a citizen of the most powerful nation on earth. Then on Thanksgiving one year, I remember thinking yes, we are very grateful that the native people helped the pilgrims and settlers, but look how they were repaid for their kindness. This started my search for native stories asked points of view.
Dunbar-Ortiz walks us through a comprehensive telling of this nation’s (and others’ by association) history as was experienced by indigenous people, giving us the other side of the story, the one that’s been suppressed, swept under the rug, and largely ignored. It’s much easier to ignore any poor behavior than to take ownership of it, after all. Murder, manipulation, systematic genocide, theft of their lands, historic and religious sites, and property, broken treaties and promises, and systemic racism that continues today, the author doesn’t shy away from any of it. She gives us the facts, cut and dried, undeniable.
Now that my eyes are open, I can’t help but see how prevalent this treatment still is. This book was written 10 years ago, but you’ve only got to read the latest in the news to see the same patterns reemerging with our current president. Just look at the name change of Alaska’s famous mountain from Denali (a local Alaskan indigenous word for “the great one”) to the moniker Mt McKinley, placed on it by a white gold rusher in honor of President McKinley (whose annexations of Puerto Rico, Guam, the Philippines, and Hawaii were further examples of the US policy of expanding its territory at the expense of native populations) and became officially adopted by the federal government in 1917. President Obama changed the name back to Denali in 2015, but President Trump has changed it back again. Additionally, President Trump renamed The Gulf of Mexico, which borders more Mexican shoreline than American but which was actually named for the ancient indigenous city of Mexico, to the Gulf of America. Whether intentional slights or just entitled white men being entitled white men, these are tiny examples of the systemic racism toward indigenous people evident today.
Comprehensive, enlightening, heartbreaking, this book will make you rethink everything you were ever taught in a history classroom.
It’s common knowledge that there are two sides to every story. It’s also commonly spoken though not commonly acknowledged that it is the winners who write history. My American education as it related to indigenous people focused primarily on the idyllic view of the first pilgrims sharing a meal with Native Americans, a brief overview of the Trail of Tears, Sacajawea guiding Lewis and Clark, and Disney’s movie, Pocahontas. More effort was put into teaching us how great our country was, how it amassed power under its credo of “manifest destiny” as was our God-given right. I remember thinking back then how proud I was to be a citizen of the most powerful nation on earth. Then on Thanksgiving one year, I remember thinking yes, we are very grateful that the native people helped the pilgrims and settlers, but look how they were repaid for their kindness. This started my search for native stories asked points of view.
Dunbar-Ortiz walks us through a comprehensive telling of this nation’s (and others’ by association) history as was experienced by indigenous people, giving us the other side of the story, the one that’s been suppressed, swept under the rug, and largely ignored. It’s much easier to ignore any poor behavior than to take ownership of it, after all. Murder, manipulation, systematic genocide, theft of their lands, historic and religious sites, and property, broken treaties and promises, and systemic racism that continues today, the author doesn’t shy away from any of it. She gives us the facts, cut and dried, undeniable.
Now that my eyes are open, I can’t help but see how prevalent this treatment still is. This book was written 10 years ago, but you’ve only got to read the latest in the news to see the same patterns reemerging with our current president. Just look at the name change of Alaska’s famous mountain from Denali (a local Alaskan indigenous word for “the great one”) to the moniker Mt McKinley, placed on it by a white gold rusher in honor of President McKinley (whose annexations of Puerto Rico, Guam, the Philippines, and Hawaii were further examples of the US policy of expanding its territory at the expense of native populations) and became officially adopted by the federal government in 1917. President Obama changed the name back to Denali in 2015, but President Trump has changed it back again. Additionally, President Trump renamed The Gulf of Mexico, which borders more Mexican shoreline than American but which was actually named for the ancient indigenous city of Mexico, to the Gulf of America. Whether intentional slights or just entitled white men being entitled white men, these are tiny examples of the systemic racism toward indigenous people evident today.
Comprehensive, enlightening, heartbreaking, this book will make you rethink everything you were ever taught in a history classroom.