Scan barcode
befrankwithme's review
adventurous
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.75
An interesting way to bring these two universes together. The art style was beautiful (and I love that it changed when it showed kirks era . There was less interaction or explanation from one side to the other about what they're doing out here, which was a bit of a bummer, but overall I has a good time reading this.
snowwolf75's review against another edition
4.0
A great cross-over comic that I would recommend, especially for fans of both series. I was pleased to see on of the characters from the Next Generation cast, since she was my favorite. The conversation between her and the Doctor is great, too.
teanahk's review against another edition
3.0
The dialogue from the Star Trek crew members was right on point for their characters, and the art for the spaceships and battle sequences was quite nice.
The characters art ranges from roughly sketched to nearly photo-realistic, but rarely shows a really expressive face. The story seemed to drag on a bit, which is almost an impressive feat to achieve in Graphic novel format.
Overall this ends up being a slightly disappointing cross-over with a really pretty cover.
The characters art ranges from roughly sketched to nearly photo-realistic, but rarely shows a really expressive face. The story seemed to drag on a bit, which is almost an impressive feat to achieve in Graphic novel format.
Overall this ends up being a slightly disappointing cross-over with a really pretty cover.
jedi_indyjones's review
4.0
I love crossover comics and this one was written pretty well. I could hear the actors' voices in my head and it made it seem like a lost episode. I also loved the OG Trek crew and the 4th doctor making a cameo. This was just such a blast to read.
jaycatt7's review
4.0
I've never read a commercial crossover that knocked my socks off--the respective owners seem too jealous of their properties. The best crossovers are fan fiction. But this story was almost as good. The characters stayed mostly in character, and the different universes' elements of the story blended seamlessly. Still, the overall plot seemed simpler than we'd enjoy in an episode.
But the art! The art is amazing. Each page, each panel, is a painting. All the characters look like themselves most of the time. And the spacescapes and starships are just gorgeous. I felt chills seeing Borg and Cybermen together in the opening pages. Unfortunately the beginning is the strongest part of the book in terms of story, but the art stays strong throughout.
But the art! The art is amazing. Each page, each panel, is a painting. All the characters look like themselves most of the time. And the spacescapes and starships are just gorgeous. I felt chills seeing Borg and Cybermen together in the opening pages. Unfortunately the beginning is the strongest part of the book in terms of story, but the art stays strong throughout.
More...