Reviews

Kiki de Montparnasse by Nora Mahony, Catel, José-Louis Bocquet

kaelino's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I admire the artwork and the extensive research that I am sure went into the creation of this book. Kiki was a real woman who met many important figures in the art and literary world (example: Marcel Duchamp, Man Ray, Pablo Picasso, Ernest Hemingway). However, the end result was, for me, a portrait of a person who was not very endearing. I couldn't root for her as a lot of the things that happened to her or the hardships she endured were because of her own actions and choices. She was a woman who yearned for love, yet her desire to live a "free" life (i.e. with sex, drugs, and alcohol) sabotaged any chance she had for it. Interesting as an examination of the times (1920s-40s) and how gender roles were changing for women but, ultimately, I saw Kiki more as a tragic figure than the hero of her own story. Did not impact me like I hoped it would.

lattelibrarian's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

All I can say is "Wow." Kiki's life has been an incredible one, and the ending of it left me speechless--partially because of how her life ended, and partially how beautiful it was narrated and illustrated. A must-read. Kiki was surely a woman ahead of her time.

heidenkind's review against another edition

Go to review page

Just cannot get into this one.

lindsayb's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Not being quite the arty type, I was introduced to and fell in love with Man Ray's work during an art appreciation class my freshman year of college. I melted when I got to see a lot of his work in the flesh at an amazing Surrealist exhibit at the Met in 2002. "Le Violon d'Ingres" has adorned the background of my MP3 player ever since I got it five years ago. His output with Kiki de Montparnasse as his muse remains some of my favorite work of his, but never have I come across anything about the personal life of this woman. So I was extra excited when I read about the existence of this graphic novel.

This hefty tome covers a near yearly account of Kiki's life, and we get a clear picture of just how rooted she was in the art world from the late 1910s onward. I wondered, though, by the time I was deep in the novel, about the aims of the author. I had a feeling he wanted to elicit a feeling of sympathy for the tragedy in Kiki's life, but I found her to be simply neurotic much of the time. Sure, her hard-knock upbringing didn't give her a terribly strong foundation, and there were a few instances where I truly felt sorry for her, but mostly I just saw a woman who didn't know what she wanted and demanded a lot without any real consideration for those around her. Her naivete seemed to have persisted through most of her life. This hardly seems emancipated, as the book's synopsis claims her to be...unless you consider emancipation the ability to live in Paris by hopping from one man's bed to another and doing lots of blow. Not quite the person I'd suggest a young woman to look up to. DESPITE THIS, I really did appreciate the chance to get a glimpse into the life of this legend, which I might not have otherwise come across, and it has prompted me to go back and search through all my books for images of Kiki now that I have a better understanding of her as a person.

christajls's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

The story of Kiki de Montparnasse is both an admirable and a tragic one.

The back of the book describes her as “one of the first emancipated women of the 20th century.” And the authors of this graphic novel, certainly make that case. But when all was said and done I found myself wondering if that was the most accurate description of the Queen de Montparnasse.

Kiki (born Alice Prin) is the definition of coming from nothing. Born an illegitimate child in a small French village, her mother ran off to Paris, leaving her to be raised by her very poor grandmother. She was a bit of a wild child – running unencumbered through the streets. But when she was twelve they could no longer afford the extra mouth and sent her off to Paris to live with her mother. Unable to live the way her distant mother wanted her to, she began to pursue her own unique lifestyle as model to some of the greatest artists of the early 20th century. And this is where the admirable part of her story kicks off.

To read the rest of this review check out Paris Month on Just a Lil Lost

goldenabs's review

Go to review page

emotional funny sad medium-paced

4.5

sallywilde's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Ouvrage très complet sur la vie de cette muse et artiste des années folles, dans un Paris décidément tout petit où se croise, se percute, s'enlace le destin de ses (futures) célèbres compagnons de route: Man Ray, Breton, Fujita, Modigliani... Les dessins en noir et blanc de Catel Muller sont énergiques et pleins de détails. J'ai aimé par exemple le fait que chaque chapitre est marqué par une nouvelle coupe de cheveux de Kiki, reflet historique des modes de l'époque. Une fois la BD terminée (ce qui prend du temps, on en a pour son argent), une chronologie et une série de biographies des artistes mentionnés viennent compléter l'oeuvre.

elemmakil's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Tämän naisen selkä ja ahteri olivat ennestään minulle tuttuja valokuvien kautta, ja nimi Montparnassen Kikikin kuulosti etäisesti tutulta. Itse ihmisestä en kuitenkaan tiennyt mitään, ja tämä upeasti taustoitettu massiivinen graafinen novelli kertoi hienolla tapaa Kikin melko traagisen elämäntarinan. Vaikka kirja vilisee 1920-luvun taiteilijoita, niin heitä ei tarvitse tuntea tai olla kiinnostunut heidän taiteestaan, jotta tätä jaksaisi lukea.

taleofabibliophile's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous funny reflective medium-paced

4.0


Expand filter menu Content Warnings

jamiezaccaria's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

A brilliant graphic novel for a brilliant woman. I confess to knowing nothing about Kiki before reading and am now fully invested in her story. The funny, sad, amazing story of a woman surviving, and at times thriving, in a world often unkind to creative and free women. I hope she knows she got her own graphic novel, I think that would please her. Bravo!