Marxist bookclub
time_for_a_system_change's profile picture

time_for_a_system_change's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH: 35%

Simply lost interest for the time being

This book is not very accessible in terms of reading, so I would not recommend it to anyone trying to get into the topic for the first time. However, if you are already familiar with a lot of these concepts, it does provide a thorough, comprehensive alternative to the currently orthodox view of capitalism. If you are researching the topic, I recommend it!
challenging informative reflective sad slow-paced
zachari's profile picture

zachari's review

3.0

Honestly I recommend the works of Robert Brenner supplemented by Capitalism and Slavery by Eric Williams instead.
challenging informative slow-paced
funeralthirst666's profile picture

funeralthirst666's review

4.25
challenging hopeful informative reflective slow-paced

First third or so of the book is a bit of a slog, recounting various debates people have had over time. But the rest of the book is very insightful. It gave me a great understanding of what separates capitalism from just people trading on the market in Ancient Rome, and why capitalism was not inevitable even within places like France and Florence

The best intro to Marxist economic history from the Brenner-ites. Well written and covers a lot, though you'll need to look elsewhere for the close detail
cgoode2000's profile picture

cgoode2000's review

3.5
informative slow-paced

Prose tends to be overly complicated but informative on the historical development of capitalism that reveals its functions and laws of motion.