You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.03 AVERAGE
4.03 AVERAGE
3.5 stars.
Again, this was from the original Marvel comic run.
The main problem that I had specifically with this volume, was how quick the end was. The final fight with Vader was the most important scene in the whole damn saga and this just glanced over it. My favorite part of the whole film is the final discussion Luke has with Vader and I feel this was done poorly in the comic.
A problem that I had with the whole series in comic form was that they gave Luke a damn 8-pack and Leia size G breasts. Completely inaccurate and unnecessary.
Again, this was from the original Marvel comic run.
The main problem that I had specifically with this volume, was how quick the end was. The final fight with Vader was the most important scene in the whole damn saga and this just glanced over it. My favorite part of the whole film is the final discussion Luke has with Vader and I feel this was done poorly in the comic.
A problem that I had with the whole series in comic form was that they gave Luke a damn 8-pack and Leia size G breasts. Completely inaccurate and unnecessary.
adventurous
hopeful
inspiring
slow-paced
The art style was pretty good. I like it if it is realistic. But tbh I skipped most of the speech bubbles and text. It was just too much especially because you usually already know the plot
The speed at which the story is told, in four issues rather than six, makes everything feel especially exciting. I found this to be just as good as the film, though I do wish that there was more of Princess Leia in the book, as she had some great moments in the movie. Goodwin's script is incredibly epic in tone, giving a really legendary feel to the story. Chris Sotomayor's colors are stunning, as always.
adventurous
medium-paced
adventurous
emotional
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
The only thing that was off putting was some weird changes to the dialogue. Other than that an excellent adaptation
Just like the previous comics from the original trilogy this was released before the movie. As such this was just like the others in that key moments that made this movie great, as well as my favorite, are missing. The battle is skipped over entirely, settling for poor narration instead of brilliant visuals I expect and demand of the comics I read. Lots of key moments for characters are missing, such as the death of Yoda, Vader's reveal, Han's moment with Leah at the generator, and everything with Wicket. All but a few shots of the battle are skipped. It's just... Lame.
I would say it's the age when the comic came out, but the first volume was better. I've read it but that's all that I can say for it. Very blah and poorly done.
I would say it's the age when the comic came out, but the first volume was better. I've read it but that's all that I can say for it. Very blah and poorly done.
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
3.5 Stars
I love how vintage this feels. It was great. The art was stunning, but the type font was quite hard to read. Overall, it's a graphic adaptation of a film do it wasn't anything new.
I love how vintage this feels. It was great. The art was stunning, but the type font was quite hard to read. Overall, it's a graphic adaptation of a film do it wasn't anything new.
I really liked this installment and loved to see the movie visualized in comic form.