Scan barcode
kirstenrose22's review against another edition
3.0
So. It's okay. I don't really think we needed a Part 8, but whatever. Lots of fannish shout-outs, lots of revisiting, so-so story of the next generation. I'm just kinda meh.
ethemcd2023's review against another edition
3.0
It was a good storyline, and pretty heart-wrenching, but it seemed like a fanfiction to me because the characters kept saying things that were out of character.
chitraa's review against another edition
3.0
Considering the fact that I started this book thinking that it's going to be an utter garbage, I was pleasantly surprised. I was thoroughly entertained and I'll take this book as an official weird fanfiction in a play format rather than a part of the franchise.
megstro's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
1.5
wademitchell's review against another edition
4.0
It was great to be in this world again, but I really would have loved it more if it was a proper J.K. Rowling novel.
kath_m_'s review against another edition
disorganized thoughts/feelings
-not a lot of emotional resonance for me in any of this
-except the friendship between albus and scorpius i guess, and some of draco's stuff
-ron's characterization is disappointing
-i can buy that harry might be sort of incompetent and awkward when it came to his kids but not in the way it happens here? (is there a moment where he blames albus for getting him riled up? yes?)
-humour and lots of the general speech that was trying to be cutesy felt forced and awkward....maybe it would come off differently on the stage
-why would hermione hide a time-turner with a series of riddles that would allow someone to find it???
-i'm not a fan of the ~what if it never haaaaappened~ scare in general; more than being an easy device, i think it's a mean way to stir up emotions in readers; so the plot premise was just disinteresting for me
-also the play format requires so much to be left out that the things i'd be really interested in, life and living details, school life, albus' siblings, all the relationships - these don't fit (or were pared down considerably here); so i guess this just isn't the form i'd choose for more harry potter world
i'm not incorporating this into my mental harry potter canon so w/e
-not a lot of emotional resonance for me in any of this
-except the friendship between albus and scorpius i guess, and some of draco's stuff
-ron's characterization is disappointing
-i can buy that harry might be sort of incompetent and awkward when it came to his kids but not in the way it happens here? (is there a moment where he blames albus for getting him riled up? yes?)
-humour and lots of the general speech that was trying to be cutesy felt forced and awkward....maybe it would come off differently on the stage
-why would hermione hide a time-turner with a series of riddles that would allow someone to find it???
-i'm not a fan of the ~what if it never haaaaappened~ scare in general; more than being an easy device, i think it's a mean way to stir up emotions in readers; so the plot premise was just disinteresting for me
-also the play format requires so much to be left out that the things i'd be really interested in, life and living details, school life, albus' siblings, all the relationships - these don't fit (or were pared down considerably here); so i guess this just isn't the form i'd choose for more harry potter world
i'm not incorporating this into my mental harry potter canon so w/e
adenhoy's review against another edition
3.0
the play was good but this should not have been a screenplay im sorry thats my opinion
bexterrr's review against another edition
4.0
I won't go too in depth as people are still reading and so on. But I will say: ignore negative comments. Read it for yourself.
It's like the epilogue, really. It's a little self serving but there's something nice about things being rounded off.
It's cheesy, yeah, but it's a nice dip back into the world of Harry Potter. And the plot surprised me, characterisation surprised me, crying like a little bitch at the end surprised me. ok, that last one didn't. I'm an emotional wreck.
It's like the epilogue, really. It's a little self serving but there's something nice about things being rounded off.
It's cheesy, yeah, but it's a nice dip back into the world of Harry Potter. And the plot surprised me, characterisation surprised me, crying like a little bitch at the end surprised me. ok, that last one didn't. I'm an emotional wreck.