Scan barcode
bargainsleuth's review against another edition
5.0
For this and other book reviews, subscribe to my blog www.bargain-sleuth.com
I have no idea where my interest in Egyptology started. Did Nancy Drew ever go to Egypt? I can’t remember, but archaeology and Egyptology have always fascinated me. Maybe it was in 1977-78, when King Tut’s treasures were exhibited in the United States and my brother’s Steve Martin record had the parody song on it. I was lucky enough years later to find the book that was sold during that exhibit. My favorite adult mystery series are the Elizabeth Peters Amelia Peabody Emerson mysteries, which take place in Victorian and Edwardian Egypt. I was lucky enough to see the King Tut exhibit about a decade ago when it was in Chicago at the Field Museum and bought the companion book and DVD and saved the newspaper article that alerted me to the exhibit.
An author I discovered last year, Gill Paul, writes about a lot of subjects that interest me. She’s written about everyone from Elizabeth Taylor to Wallis Simpson to the Romanovs to Jackie Kennedy Her latest book, The Collector’s Daughter, is set during the 1920’s when King Tut’s tomb was first discovered. When NetGalley and William Morrow offered me an ARC of the book in exchange for an honest review, I jumped at the chance to visit the Valley of the Kings.
What’s not to love about The Collector’s daughter? The story takes place along two timelines: first, the 1970’s, when Eve Herbert, sister of the Earl of Carnarvon, is recuperating from a stroke. Her husband, the most perfect husband, by the way, worries so much about her. Eve’s had mini-strokes before, apparently, but this is a bigger one, one that affects her motor skills and speech. While Eve is in recovery, she receives inquiries from a professor from the University of Cairo about the Tutankhamun dig in 1922, because Eve was there with her father, the Earl, who had funded Howard Carter’s attempts to find the tomb.
The second timeline goes back to the early 1920’s, and Eve’s life leading up to the discovery of Tut’s tomb. She absolutely adores Egyptology and her father encourages her, while her mother just wishes she’d pick some rich, titled man to marry. Her brother, Porchy, could care less. We meet Eve’s husband and wonder how in the world they ever got together because he seems so standoff-ish and remote. But as we discover, he’s Eve’s rock.
In the 1970’s. Eve’s trying to remember everything she can about the dig, and realizes there are some secrets that shouldn’t come out. Apparently the expedition broke into the tomb before the official opening and took some objects before the Egyptian authorities and Howard Carter’s team could catalogue everything. Eve picks a decorative gold box with strong smelling stuff in it. Carter calls it an unguent, which could be used in a variety of ways: as a poison, an ointment for injuries, etc. Eve’s father and Howard Carter also take some pieces from the dig before the official opening.
Also in the 1970’s while Eve is recuperating, the female professor meets with Eve several times, because another ancient document has come to light revealing that about 20 objects from Tut’s tomb were missing. And as Eve is the only remaining member of the expedition, she’s hoping she’ll remember what happened to all the missing artifacts so they can be given back to the Cairo museum. Eve remembers all except one thing: where she stuffed that horrible smelling box.
Throughout the book, there’s mention of the curse of King Tut, and Eve doesn’t believe, or doesn’t think she believes, but her father seems to think so. And then, as anyone knows from studying history, Lord Carnarvon dies shortly after the tomb is discovered. Even though Eve knows there’s no such thing as a curse, time and time again throughout her life, when bad things happen, she wonders if there really was such a curse. Then she’d realize that she was still living, so it is unlikely, until the next bad thing happens, and she starts wondering again.
There’s enough mystery, history, and story depth to make The Collector’s Daughter a hit for anyone who loves historical fiction, Egyptology, even Downton Abbey fans might want to take a spin since parts of this book take place at Highclere Castle. I can’t wait to read or listen to the rest of Gill Paul’s back catalog and get caught up on her excellent writing.
I have no idea where my interest in Egyptology started. Did Nancy Drew ever go to Egypt? I can’t remember, but archaeology and Egyptology have always fascinated me. Maybe it was in 1977-78, when King Tut’s treasures were exhibited in the United States and my brother’s Steve Martin record had the parody song on it. I was lucky enough years later to find the book that was sold during that exhibit. My favorite adult mystery series are the Elizabeth Peters Amelia Peabody Emerson mysteries, which take place in Victorian and Edwardian Egypt. I was lucky enough to see the King Tut exhibit about a decade ago when it was in Chicago at the Field Museum and bought the companion book and DVD and saved the newspaper article that alerted me to the exhibit.
An author I discovered last year, Gill Paul, writes about a lot of subjects that interest me. She’s written about everyone from Elizabeth Taylor to Wallis Simpson to the Romanovs to Jackie Kennedy Her latest book, The Collector’s Daughter, is set during the 1920’s when King Tut’s tomb was first discovered. When NetGalley and William Morrow offered me an ARC of the book in exchange for an honest review, I jumped at the chance to visit the Valley of the Kings.
What’s not to love about The Collector’s daughter? The story takes place along two timelines: first, the 1970’s, when Eve Herbert, sister of the Earl of Carnarvon, is recuperating from a stroke. Her husband, the most perfect husband, by the way, worries so much about her. Eve’s had mini-strokes before, apparently, but this is a bigger one, one that affects her motor skills and speech. While Eve is in recovery, she receives inquiries from a professor from the University of Cairo about the Tutankhamun dig in 1922, because Eve was there with her father, the Earl, who had funded Howard Carter’s attempts to find the tomb.
The second timeline goes back to the early 1920’s, and Eve’s life leading up to the discovery of Tut’s tomb. She absolutely adores Egyptology and her father encourages her, while her mother just wishes she’d pick some rich, titled man to marry. Her brother, Porchy, could care less. We meet Eve’s husband and wonder how in the world they ever got together because he seems so standoff-ish and remote. But as we discover, he’s Eve’s rock.
In the 1970’s. Eve’s trying to remember everything she can about the dig, and realizes there are some secrets that shouldn’t come out. Apparently the expedition broke into the tomb before the official opening and took some objects before the Egyptian authorities and Howard Carter’s team could catalogue everything. Eve picks a decorative gold box with strong smelling stuff in it. Carter calls it an unguent, which could be used in a variety of ways: as a poison, an ointment for injuries, etc. Eve’s father and Howard Carter also take some pieces from the dig before the official opening.
Also in the 1970’s while Eve is recuperating, the female professor meets with Eve several times, because another ancient document has come to light revealing that about 20 objects from Tut’s tomb were missing. And as Eve is the only remaining member of the expedition, she’s hoping she’ll remember what happened to all the missing artifacts so they can be given back to the Cairo museum. Eve remembers all except one thing: where she stuffed that horrible smelling box.
Throughout the book, there’s mention of the curse of King Tut, and Eve doesn’t believe, or doesn’t think she believes, but her father seems to think so. And then, as anyone knows from studying history, Lord Carnarvon dies shortly after the tomb is discovered. Even though Eve knows there’s no such thing as a curse, time and time again throughout her life, when bad things happen, she wonders if there really was such a curse. Then she’d realize that she was still living, so it is unlikely, until the next bad thing happens, and she starts wondering again.
There’s enough mystery, history, and story depth to make The Collector’s Daughter a hit for anyone who loves historical fiction, Egyptology, even Downton Abbey fans might want to take a spin since parts of this book take place at Highclere Castle. I can’t wait to read or listen to the rest of Gill Paul’s back catalog and get caught up on her excellent writing.
lolalu's review against another edition
emotional
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
avreereads's review against another edition
5.0
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC of this well-crafted and well-researched story about such an exhilarating event. I felt like I got to be a fly on the wall in the discovery of King Tut's tomb and I especially enjoyed being transported to a time I don't often get to go in books. I love the 1920s and I love ancient Egypt and this rolls it nicely into one. I'm glad I was reading the Kindle version because I had fun selecting a term or name and being able to Google it to learn more about it or see a visual. Made for an even more immersive story!
This story came precisely when I needed an escape from my life; and this was so beautifully written, with some descriptions being sheer poetry. The love story was so beautiful to witness and it was fun to see the unveiling of the story, even at a relatively slow pace. I found myself always excited to pick it back up again, and that's when I know I have a good read on my hands—doesn't matter the pacing, as long as I look forward to revisiting that world the author so enchantingly creates.
I'm impressed with the research that went into creating this seamless story and the editing was top-notch even for an ARC. I truly enjoyed EVERY moment of this book and I look forward to rereading this one again.
This story came precisely when I needed an escape from my life; and this was so beautifully written, with some descriptions being sheer poetry. The love story was so beautiful to witness and it was fun to see the unveiling of the story, even at a relatively slow pace. I found myself always excited to pick it back up again, and that's when I know I have a good read on my hands—doesn't matter the pacing, as long as I look forward to revisiting that world the author so enchantingly creates.
I'm impressed with the research that went into creating this seamless story and the editing was top-notch even for an ARC. I truly enjoyed EVERY moment of this book and I look forward to rereading this one again.
sstinchecum's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
informative
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
srm401's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.75
blairconrad's review against another edition
2.0
Disappointing. I found Ms. Paul's prose to be bland and awkward, and I wanted more interesting Egypt stuff (mostly we got boring Egypt stuff). I did enjoy the bits that described Evelyn's present-day infirmities, but those were the only parts that had merit, IMO, and weren't enough to pull the book up to a 3* rating.
machadofam8's review against another edition
3.0
This was a fun read. I was fascinated by King Tut when I was younger so this really piqued my interest.
erinremen's review against another edition
5.0
A masterpiece of storytelling across two very different time periods as Eve relives her time with Howard Carter as the tomb of Tutankhamun was discovered. As she struggles with her memories of current event's, her memories of that time in her life are crystal clear. Eve lived a lustrous life with the love of an incredible man and the magic and wonder that she felt digging in for ancient artifacts shines through the pages. An interesting storyline that hooked me from the very beginning and I loved everything about it.
hrial310's review against another edition
DNF: I really wanted to like this; an historical fiction book about a woman and the discovery of King Tut's tomb is literally a dream novel for me, but I hated that it was technically being told in the future by the woman when she was old. It would have come off much better if it just took place in the early 1900s and I couldn't get past that.