You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3 reviews for:
The Unreliable Life of Harry the Valet: The Great Victorian Jewel Thief
Duncan Hamilton
3.6 AVERAGE
3 reviews for:
The Unreliable Life of Harry the Valet: The Great Victorian Jewel Thief
Duncan Hamilton
3.6 AVERAGE
El libro se me hizo un poco meh, pensé que iba a ser algo más emocionante o que habría algo más de acción. Se me hizo un poco pesado a ratos, puede ser porque no estoy acostumbrada a leer biografías, pero bueno. Además, llegados a cierto punto, se me hicieron todos los robos iguales, tipo que seguía el mismo modus operandi y al final me acabó aburriendo un poco… No sé, me dejó algo indiferente.. Aun así, me gustó mucho conocer un poco más las circunstancias del ladrón, lo que le impulsó a dedicarse al crimen y cómo planeaba y llevaba a cabo los diferentes robo. No sé, me pareció bastante interesante conocer la historia de este ladrón de joyas de la era victoriana.
Note: This book was received from the publisher in exchange for a fair and honest review.
The story of Harry the Valet may not be particularly familiar to modern readers, but he was something of a celebrity in the Victorian age. He achieved notoriety by stealing thousands of pounds worth of jewels from the Dowager Duchess of Sutherland - much to the delight of many people who disliked the lady, which appears to have been pretty much everyone who ever met her. Having pulled off this audacious theft, Harry seemed to be invincible - but he was brought down by his love for a Gaiety Girl, and ended up facing a trial which the papers fell over themselves to report on.
Author Duncan Hamilton takes an impressive list of sources - chiefly the Valet's own autobiography, which he admits is not necessarily the most accurate of documents, but also hundreds of newspaper and magazine articles and another two hundred or so books about the era - and weaves a compelling tale out of this fascinating character. The Valet himself is portrayed fairly sympathetically; far more so than the Dowager Duchess, the girl he falls for, or some of the other criminals mentioned in passing. That's not to say his crimes and the effect they had on others are completely glossed over - just that it's made clear that he was something of a Robin Hood figure, robbing from the rich and giving to a rather small section of the poor (namely, himself.)
I've now read several true crime stories set in this era and on balance I think this probably stands out as the best - Harry is a really interesting central figure, and the pacing is perfect, giving us lots of information about the trial and his many crimes without ever overloading us. It's also really atmospheric, capturing the flavour of the Valet's times, in locations ranging from London clubs to country estates to the Continent.
Overall this is a strong recommendation to fans of true crime or the Victorian era in particular, and thrilling non-fiction in general.
The story of Harry the Valet may not be particularly familiar to modern readers, but he was something of a celebrity in the Victorian age. He achieved notoriety by stealing thousands of pounds worth of jewels from the Dowager Duchess of Sutherland - much to the delight of many people who disliked the lady, which appears to have been pretty much everyone who ever met her. Having pulled off this audacious theft, Harry seemed to be invincible - but he was brought down by his love for a Gaiety Girl, and ended up facing a trial which the papers fell over themselves to report on.
Author Duncan Hamilton takes an impressive list of sources - chiefly the Valet's own autobiography, which he admits is not necessarily the most accurate of documents, but also hundreds of newspaper and magazine articles and another two hundred or so books about the era - and weaves a compelling tale out of this fascinating character. The Valet himself is portrayed fairly sympathetically; far more so than the Dowager Duchess, the girl he falls for, or some of the other criminals mentioned in passing. That's not to say his crimes and the effect they had on others are completely glossed over - just that it's made clear that he was something of a Robin Hood figure, robbing from the rich and giving to a rather small section of the poor (namely, himself.)
I've now read several true crime stories set in this era and on balance I think this probably stands out as the best - Harry is a really interesting central figure, and the pacing is perfect, giving us lots of information about the trial and his many crimes without ever overloading us. It's also really atmospheric, capturing the flavour of the Valet's times, in locations ranging from London clubs to country estates to the Continent.
Overall this is a strong recommendation to fans of true crime or the Victorian era in particular, and thrilling non-fiction in general.
A really interesting magazine article, unfortunately presented at book length. This should have had a lot more psychological insight into the protagonists, or a lot less, because the author's speculations didn't really add much to explain Harry or Maud's actions. I am probably being a bit unfair but I was really looking forward to this and am accordingly disappointed that it really didn't hold the attention. It may be that real life is to blame and the story should have been rewritten as fiction.