Scan barcode
naomiiixo's review against another edition
2.0
The start was good until mei yee and dai met then the book went downhill into an instalove spiral that I barely managed to finish!
natidelgadov's review against another edition
4.0
Muy buena lectura, me mantuvo enganchada todo el libro, el único problema que tuve fue que no vi un desarrollo muy profundo de los personajes.
hiveretcafe's review against another edition
4.0
4.5 stars.
This review was originally posted on my blog, Hiver et Cafe with the moodboard.
I was provided with an e-ARC of this book from Little, Brown Books for Young Readers via NetGalley. This fact does not affect my review whatsoever and this review is my complete, honest opinion. I was not compensated for this review in any shape or form.
This is seriously the first book I've ever read that takes place in Hong Kong, and it's fascinating and refreshing.
My parents are from Hong Kong so I can understand some of the cantonese-isms that take place in this book. It's a little bit hard to understand because the english "ping-yum" or romanization of cantonese is a little weird.
Anyways, this book takes place in The Walled City in Kowloon, Hong Kong. At first, I had thought that it was a dystopia because of the whole, being in a walled city thing and having to run for their lives. I was sorely mistaken and instead this book, takes place in the 80s in Hong Kong.
This book switches between three points of view, Dai, Jin Ling and Mei Yee. Jin Ling and Mei Yee are sisters. Two years ago, Mei Yee was taken and put in a brothel run by the gangsters known as the Brotherhood, inside The Walled City. Jin Ling cut off her hair and disguised herself as a boy in order to find her sister. Dai is very mysterious in the beginning and he's on a mission. He's counting down to something, but the reader isn't aware until the whole "reveal" happens even from Dai's POV.
I really liked Jin Ling's character. She's strong, determined and loyal. She's not going to let anything get in the way of finding her sister. Dai is interesting. Very, very interesting. He may just seem mysterious in the beginning, but as things get revealed, his backstory really adds some depth to his character, some but not much. Mei Yee is stuck in the brothel and she displays a different kind of strength compared to her sister. She's strong in a quiet way, while Jin Ling's is loud.
I never knew what to expect from the storyline of this book. It really threw me for a loop with the whole being in HK thing. I could kind of predict some things just because of experience and generally how stories progress. But I seriously didn't predict too much of how it was exactly going to go about. It also helped that I didn't really know anything about The Walled City until I googled about it afterwards.
I seriously loved the setting and the world that THE WALLED CITY takes place in though. There's a sort of familiarity to the setting that is both strange and comforting. However, because this book is in an Asian setting about Asian characters, (all of them Asian btw. <3), I guess some things just don't translate well into English language. Some of the metaphors were just really weird to me and seemed like it was trying too hard to prove to be Asian.
Hong Kong is an interesting place to write a book about, especially fiction, because although they do mainly speak Cantonese, the British ruled Hong Kong for some time and so it was a mandatory thing in school to learn English, unlike now as China has taken Hong Kong back and thusly it's Mandarin that is taught in schools.
This book is a standalone and I really enjoyed it. I think that it would have ruined it if it were to have been a series. However, I would absolutely LOVE to read more YA that takes place in Hong Kong or Asia in general that focuses on an all Asian cast.
This review was originally posted on my blog, Hiver et Cafe with the moodboard.
I was provided with an e-ARC of this book from Little, Brown Books for Young Readers via NetGalley. This fact does not affect my review whatsoever and this review is my complete, honest opinion. I was not compensated for this review in any shape or form.
This is seriously the first book I've ever read that takes place in Hong Kong, and it's fascinating and refreshing.
My parents are from Hong Kong so I can understand some of the cantonese-isms that take place in this book. It's a little bit hard to understand because the english "ping-yum" or romanization of cantonese is a little weird.
Anyways, this book takes place in The Walled City in Kowloon, Hong Kong. At first, I had thought that it was a dystopia because of the whole, being in a walled city thing and having to run for their lives. I was sorely mistaken and instead this book, takes place in the 80s in Hong Kong.
This book switches between three points of view, Dai, Jin Ling and Mei Yee. Jin Ling and Mei Yee are sisters. Two years ago, Mei Yee was taken and put in a brothel run by the gangsters known as the Brotherhood, inside The Walled City. Jin Ling cut off her hair and disguised herself as a boy in order to find her sister. Dai is very mysterious in the beginning and he's on a mission. He's counting down to something, but the reader isn't aware until the whole "reveal" happens even from Dai's POV.
I really liked Jin Ling's character. She's strong, determined and loyal. She's not going to let anything get in the way of finding her sister. Dai is interesting. Very, very interesting. He may just seem mysterious in the beginning, but as things get revealed, his backstory really adds some depth to his character, some but not much. Mei Yee is stuck in the brothel and she displays a different kind of strength compared to her sister. She's strong in a quiet way, while Jin Ling's is loud.
I never knew what to expect from the storyline of this book. It really threw me for a loop with the whole being in HK thing. I could kind of predict some things just because of experience and generally how stories progress. But I seriously didn't predict too much of how it was exactly going to go about. It also helped that I didn't really know anything about The Walled City until I googled about it afterwards.
I seriously loved the setting and the world that THE WALLED CITY takes place in though. There's a sort of familiarity to the setting that is both strange and comforting. However, because this book is in an Asian setting about Asian characters, (all of them Asian btw. <3), I guess some things just don't translate well into English language. Some of the metaphors were just really weird to me and seemed like it was trying too hard to prove to be Asian.
Hong Kong is an interesting place to write a book about, especially fiction, because although they do mainly speak Cantonese, the British ruled Hong Kong for some time and so it was a mandatory thing in school to learn English, unlike now as China has taken Hong Kong back and thusly it's Mandarin that is taught in schools.
This book is a standalone and I really enjoyed it. I think that it would have ruined it if it were to have been a series. However, I would absolutely LOVE to read more YA that takes place in Hong Kong or Asia in general that focuses on an all Asian cast.
josiesaccount's review
dark
emotional
informative
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
lilereads's review against another edition
3.0
3.5*
talvez eu gostasse mais se tivesse com a mente mais livre no momento. muito disso se deu pela narração. talvez a nota mude depois, quem sabe.
talvez eu gostasse mais se tivesse com a mente mais livre no momento. muito disso se deu pela narração. talvez a nota mude depois, quem sabe.
truequeenofchaos's review against another edition
3.0
Actual rating: 3.5 stars
What good is a locked door when the threat might be inside?
While I didn't enjoy this as much as I would have liked, I do feel like it was an important read because of its basis on facts. There actually was a walled city that was much like this one, although it was in Hong Kong. Before reading The Walled City I was totally unaware of such a thing existing, so this has spurred me to research and learn more about it. I'm grateful for that. But what makes this novel even more important is that is brings awareness to sex trafficking.
The characters were all very fleshed out and enjoyable. The things that they had to endure and suffer were unimaginable. I really liked the 3 main characters, but I honestly didn't care what happened to them. So I connected with them, but not well enough, I guess? That may have been due to the writing style, which was nice, but wasn't anything unique or enchanting. Ryan Graudin does get an A+ for her creativity and originality though! She decided to write this after learning about the real place and I think that's wonderful.
There are still more wishes in my soul than there are stars.
Honestly the major downfall to this book was the pacing. There were intense scenes throughout the entire thing, but it still read extremely slow. I found myself not even wanting to pick it up most of the time. Most of the action happened in the last 30-50 pages.
Characters - 13/20
Plot line - 14/16
Originality - 16/16
Writing Style - 10/16
Pace - 7/16
Ending - 16/16
76/100
3.5/5 stars
I'd recommend this novel to someone that's looking for something a little different or who would like to learn more about the walled city or sex trafficking. I did enjoy it, but I probably won't ever re-read it.
What good is a locked door when the threat might be inside?
While I didn't enjoy this as much as I would have liked, I do feel like it was an important read because of its basis on facts. There actually was a walled city that was much like this one, although it was in Hong Kong. Before reading The Walled City I was totally unaware of such a thing existing, so this has spurred me to research and learn more about it. I'm grateful for that. But what makes this novel even more important is that is brings awareness to sex trafficking.
The characters were all very fleshed out and enjoyable. The things that they had to endure and suffer were unimaginable. I really liked the 3 main characters, but I honestly didn't care what happened to them. So I connected with them, but not well enough, I guess? That may have been due to the writing style, which was nice, but wasn't anything unique or enchanting. Ryan Graudin does get an A+ for her creativity and originality though! She decided to write this after learning about the real place and I think that's wonderful.
There are still more wishes in my soul than there are stars.
Honestly the major downfall to this book was the pacing. There were intense scenes throughout the entire thing, but it still read extremely slow. I found myself not even wanting to pick it up most of the time. Most of the action happened in the last 30-50 pages.
Characters - 13/20
Plot line - 14/16
Originality - 16/16
Writing Style - 10/16
Pace - 7/16
Ending - 16/16
76/100
3.5/5 stars
I'd recommend this novel to someone that's looking for something a little different or who would like to learn more about the walled city or sex trafficking. I did enjoy it, but I probably won't ever re-read it.
aoosterwyk's review against another edition
2.0
One girl fighting, one girl enduring. A rich prince tries to save them both, but they have to help. Sex slaves and kid gangs among the gangsters. Seems a bit, a bit, like Oliver Twist.
comradealex's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0