Scan barcode
krhe's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
4.0
breboe89's review against another edition
emotional
funny
hopeful
informative
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Grief, Emotional abuse, Death, and Sexual content
avoryfaucette's review
4.0
In line with the first edition, but with more of my favorite webcomic authors. A trans man/trans woman story by blue deliquanti is particularly delightful.
codalion's review
3.0
Well-executed and high-quality, for what it is, just ultimately not my cup of tea. I basically knew that going in, so it wasn't a disappointment or anything--just a mostly cute, vaguely interesting browse-read. It's always nice to see an anthology where the creators obviously had a lot of fun.
nerdinthelibrary's review
4.0
1) Smut Peddler: 2012 Edition ★★★★
I honestly don't really have any overall thoughts that I didn't have with the first edition. This remains a fantastic collection of sexy comics that are all thoroughly enjoyable. Something I didn't mention the first time around is how much I appreciate how woman-lead these are, and you can definitely tell while reading judging just by how many women get eaten out.
Anyway, quick thoughts on each comic (favourites are in bold):
Ambrosia, Arbutus : m/m, historical
How You Gonna Keep Em' Down on the Farm : m/m, alien, dubcon
The Wedding Gift : m/f, indian mc's
Glasses & Jones : f/f, woc, bdsm
Divers : m/f, time travel, sci-fi
Farmgirl : f/f
Honesty : f/m, asian mc, trans mc's
Last Word : f/f
Battleines : m/m, historical
Destination Wedding : m/f/m, polyamory
Merger : f/robot, fat woc
Complete : f/m, poc
The Witch : f/f, fantasy
Work of Art : m/f, fat woc
Who Watches the Watchmen? : f/m
Ill Met by Conlight : m/m
Now, You Don't : f/f
Big Booty Jane : f/m, fat mc, SFF
Tiger Bride : f/m
Gorgeous : f/f, woc
Intimacy Procedure: Informal : f/robot
One Night Off : m/m, fat mc
Big Babies : m/f
Clay : f/f, swampish monster
Phone Tag : m/m/f, polyamory, semi-public sex
I honestly don't really have any overall thoughts that I didn't have with the first edition. This remains a fantastic collection of sexy comics that are all thoroughly enjoyable. Something I didn't mention the first time around is how much I appreciate how woman-lead these are, and you can definitely tell while reading judging just by how many women get eaten out.
Anyway, quick thoughts on each comic (favourites are in bold):
Ambrosia, Arbutus : m/m, historical
How You Gonna Keep Em' Down on the Farm : m/m, alien, dubcon
The Wedding Gift : m/f, indian mc's
Glasses & Jones : f/f, woc, bdsm
Divers : m/f, time travel, sci-fi
Farmgirl : f/f
Honesty : f/m, asian mc, trans mc's
Last Word : f/f
Battleines : m/m, historical
Destination Wedding : m/f/m, polyamory
Merger : f/robot, fat woc
Complete : f/m, poc
The Witch : f/f, fantasy
Work of Art : m/f, fat woc
Who Watches the Watchmen? : f/m
Ill Met by Conlight : m/m
Now, You Don't : f/f
Big Booty Jane : f/m, fat mc, SFF
Tiger Bride : f/m
Gorgeous : f/f, woc
Intimacy Procedure: Informal : f/robot
One Night Off : m/m, fat mc
Big Babies : m/f
Clay : f/f, swampish monster
Phone Tag : m/m/f, polyamory, semi-public sex
tangleroot_eli's review
4.0
I loved a lot of these, liked several others, and was "meh" about a few. That's the way it should be, I think. Even with the ones I didn't like, there's something cool about knowing that while it's not for me, it's for someone. Hooray for sex-positive comics!
jensonja's review against another edition
5.0
Such adorable smut storty telling. 100% approve for anyone and everyone (18 and older, of course).