Scan barcode
tmleblanc's review
3.0
Winter by Sarah Remy took me by surprise. I haven’t read much urban fantasy and when it comes to fantasy, I don’t have much experience with fay folklore. It didn’t seem to matter much that I had little experience with either of these as the main focus of the story was on the arrival of Aine, who she was and what her arrival meant to the Manhattan Exiles.
The best part of the novel was that the author didn’t feel the need to share every bit of fay history. As the story moved along, bits and pieces of why the fay were stuck in our world were revealed when it was relevant to the plot. It wasn’t done with long winded explanations either. It was usually an off-handed comment which revealed that the exile wasn’t something that just happened yesterday and showed how characters really felt about each other.
While this approach worked for the overall history of this group of exiles, I did struggle that more of Winter, the main protagonist of the story, was not shared. I struggled to understand why he was in D.C. when his family was in Manhattan. What exactly did his fancy earbobs do? Why did he hate himself so much? Why are Gabby, Lolo and Richard even friends with him? There was a lot of backstory there that I felt I was missing to truly connect with the character.
It was the greater mystery that kept me reading Winter. The girl that emerged from the wall, Aine, shared my confusion regarding Winter and his crazy family (both his biological and adoptive families). While at first she seemed weak and whiny, as the story moved on, she became one of the strongest, most caring female characters in the book. Once she got her footing, she was determined to achieve her goal.
This novel would be for readers who don’t like a spoon-fed plot. Remy deftly hands out pieces of the Exiles history and only begins to reveal the psychology behind the actions of her troubled characters. This is a complex story where, at the end, not all is known and some readers might find that frustrating. For me, it was refreshing. I don’t mind open-ended plots when the story is well-written. Winter left me wondering if the characters will be able to overcome themselves as that seems to be their greatest obstacle. It made this urban fantasy seem real and alive.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
This review was originally posted on Second Run Reviews
The best part of the novel was that the author didn’t feel the need to share every bit of fay history. As the story moved along, bits and pieces of why the fay were stuck in our world were revealed when it was relevant to the plot. It wasn’t done with long winded explanations either. It was usually an off-handed comment which revealed that the exile wasn’t something that just happened yesterday and showed how characters really felt about each other.
While this approach worked for the overall history of this group of exiles, I did struggle that more of Winter, the main protagonist of the story, was not shared. I struggled to understand why he was in D.C. when his family was in Manhattan. What exactly did his fancy earbobs do? Why did he hate himself so much? Why are Gabby, Lolo and Richard even friends with him? There was a lot of backstory there that I felt I was missing to truly connect with the character.
It was the greater mystery that kept me reading Winter. The girl that emerged from the wall, Aine, shared my confusion regarding Winter and his crazy family (both his biological and adoptive families). While at first she seemed weak and whiny, as the story moved on, she became one of the strongest, most caring female characters in the book. Once she got her footing, she was determined to achieve her goal.
This novel would be for readers who don’t like a spoon-fed plot. Remy deftly hands out pieces of the Exiles history and only begins to reveal the psychology behind the actions of her troubled characters. This is a complex story where, at the end, not all is known and some readers might find that frustrating. For me, it was refreshing. I don’t mind open-ended plots when the story is well-written. Winter left me wondering if the characters will be able to overcome themselves as that seems to be their greatest obstacle. It made this urban fantasy seem real and alive.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
This review was originally posted on Second Run Reviews
maureensbooks89's review
3.0
When I first saw the cover of ‘Winter’, I knew this was a book I wanted to read. I really fell in love with this book cover. It just looks magical to me and I couldn’t wait to start reading it. So when I got an email and learned I would be a part of the blog tour, I was super excited.
From the very first page ‘Winter’ is a book that grabs your attention. The strangest thing is, you don’t even get everything that’s going on in this book. There is a lot happening but the author doesn’t really explain it at the beginning. Slowly on, while reading this book you find out what is going on. Sounds weird? Yep, I know.. but this really made this book interesting. And it really makes you want to keep reading because you just want to know what is going on and why. This was definitely a unique part about this book.
What I also really liked about this book was the fantasy part. This story was interesting, unique and definitely well thought of. The characters are very interesting. And although all the different characters confused me at times, (I really can’t keep all those different names a part) it was fun to read about their friendships, families and their struggles with each other and their lives.
Although this book was really enjoyable I had some difficulties with it. I didn’t feel a connection to anyone of the characters. And there were some things I just didn’t really understand, and some stuff just stayed unexplained. I, for example, didn’t really get why humans and fey people didn’t really get along. There are still a lot of questions I would have liked to get an answer to.
On the other hand, Sarah Remy really did make sure I want to read her next book. I just need to learn more about this world and the characters.
This book was a fun and interesting read, which definitely never got boring.
From the very first page ‘Winter’ is a book that grabs your attention. The strangest thing is, you don’t even get everything that’s going on in this book. There is a lot happening but the author doesn’t really explain it at the beginning. Slowly on, while reading this book you find out what is going on. Sounds weird? Yep, I know.. but this really made this book interesting. And it really makes you want to keep reading because you just want to know what is going on and why. This was definitely a unique part about this book.
What I also really liked about this book was the fantasy part. This story was interesting, unique and definitely well thought of. The characters are very interesting. And although all the different characters confused me at times, (I really can’t keep all those different names a part) it was fun to read about their friendships, families and their struggles with each other and their lives.
Although this book was really enjoyable I had some difficulties with it. I didn’t feel a connection to anyone of the characters. And there were some things I just didn’t really understand, and some stuff just stayed unexplained. I, for example, didn’t really get why humans and fey people didn’t really get along. There are still a lot of questions I would have liked to get an answer to.
On the other hand, Sarah Remy really did make sure I want to read her next book. I just need to learn more about this world and the characters.
This book was a fun and interesting read, which definitely never got boring.
More...