Scan barcode
meggiebennett's review
3.0
Midpoint review originally posted at www.bookertease.blogspot.ca
This is a fairly small book - only 225 pages, so it didn’t take me very long to finish, however it’s also possible that I read it so quickly because I am not completely sure that I understood it - there are a lot of politics in this book! The book starts off with an elderly man and his quite-a-bit younger companion attempting to get a room in a Crimean Hotel. Baruch Kotler is a soviet Russian dissident and a disgraced Israeli politician on the lamb with his mistress Leora, one of his staffers. They are not able to get a room, so end up taking a room in the house of a Russian woman and her Jewish husband. There is much made of the fact that the woman’s husband is Jewish; Kotler taking it as a sign of something and his companion, Leora reluctantly and wearily giving in.
I enjoyed the story, even though I definitely did not following all of the politics. I tried doing a little research, but was not even completely sure what I was looking for. The story seems to revolve around the Israeli/Palestinian conflict as well as Russian Zionism. Kotler is a Jewish cabinet minister who has been publicly opposing the prime minister, and a Zionist hero who, years earlier, spent 13 years in jail for treason after being denounced by a KGB plant. His current predicament has come about as a result of the opposition of the current government – news of his affair has been splashed all over the papers, leading to his desertion of this wife, son and daughter.
The story gets interesting when the owner of the house that Kotler and Leora are staying at turns out to be the man who decades earlier betrayed him to the KGB. Vladimir Tankilevich is a sad, bitter old man for whom life has not turned out well. And now believes that Kotler has come to gloat about his success, while Kotler believes that he has arrived at Tankilevich’s house by divine providence.
While I found the story interesting, I really think I would have gotten more out of it if I knew more about Israeli politics or Russian Zionism. As it is, I don’t know much, so the political part of this story has really just been in the background for me. I do think it is a little cliché that the old man has run off with his beautiful young secretary, although Bezmozgis makes a comment on this as well – about all the old men running around with young women nowadays. The thing that I don’t understand is why Kotler has decided to run off with Leora in the first place. He doesn’t seem like the type of man to back away from a fight, which he says himself before the news ‘goes viral’. “… I will be as clear as I can. I spent thirteen years in Soviet jails and camps fighting for my right to come to Israel. If you or the people you represent think that I can be intimidated by this sort of KGB thuggery you are mistaken.” So why has he run away? I get that it needs to happen to further the story, but I needed a little more than that. The history is definitely interesting however, and I enjoyed learning about a culture that I have not been much exposed to.
I believe the old adage goes “don’t meet your hero, they’ll only disappoint”; this story turns that around to don’t meet your betrayer. As we all know, people are never what we think they are, and you never know what is going on on the inside.
This is a fairly small book - only 225 pages, so it didn’t take me very long to finish, however it’s also possible that I read it so quickly because I am not completely sure that I understood it - there are a lot of politics in this book! The book starts off with an elderly man and his quite-a-bit younger companion attempting to get a room in a Crimean Hotel. Baruch Kotler is a soviet Russian dissident and a disgraced Israeli politician on the lamb with his mistress Leora, one of his staffers. They are not able to get a room, so end up taking a room in the house of a Russian woman and her Jewish husband. There is much made of the fact that the woman’s husband is Jewish; Kotler taking it as a sign of something and his companion, Leora reluctantly and wearily giving in.
I enjoyed the story, even though I definitely did not following all of the politics. I tried doing a little research, but was not even completely sure what I was looking for. The story seems to revolve around the Israeli/Palestinian conflict as well as Russian Zionism. Kotler is a Jewish cabinet minister who has been publicly opposing the prime minister, and a Zionist hero who, years earlier, spent 13 years in jail for treason after being denounced by a KGB plant. His current predicament has come about as a result of the opposition of the current government – news of his affair has been splashed all over the papers, leading to his desertion of this wife, son and daughter.
The story gets interesting when the owner of the house that Kotler and Leora are staying at turns out to be the man who decades earlier betrayed him to the KGB. Vladimir Tankilevich is a sad, bitter old man for whom life has not turned out well. And now believes that Kotler has come to gloat about his success, while Kotler believes that he has arrived at Tankilevich’s house by divine providence.
While I found the story interesting, I really think I would have gotten more out of it if I knew more about Israeli politics or Russian Zionism. As it is, I don’t know much, so the political part of this story has really just been in the background for me. I do think it is a little cliché that the old man has run off with his beautiful young secretary, although Bezmozgis makes a comment on this as well – about all the old men running around with young women nowadays. The thing that I don’t understand is why Kotler has decided to run off with Leora in the first place. He doesn’t seem like the type of man to back away from a fight, which he says himself before the news ‘goes viral’. “… I will be as clear as I can. I spent thirteen years in Soviet jails and camps fighting for my right to come to Israel. If you or the people you represent think that I can be intimidated by this sort of KGB thuggery you are mistaken.” So why has he run away? I get that it needs to happen to further the story, but I needed a little more than that. The history is definitely interesting however, and I enjoyed learning about a culture that I have not been much exposed to.
I believe the old adage goes “don’t meet your hero, they’ll only disappoint”; this story turns that around to don’t meet your betrayer. As we all know, people are never what we think they are, and you never know what is going on on the inside.
sophronisba's review
4.0
Lovely prose, spare to a fault. I liked the ideas here, and thought Kotler was a great, complicated character. I wish this book had been longer, though, and fleshed out the relationships and themes it only hinted at. In particular, I would like for Bezmozgis to do more with the women--Leora, Miriam, Svetlana--who all seemed a bit one-note.
sarahc3319's review
3.0
I'm not confident I understood all the underlying history of the plot, but this is a good book. The characters are well-constructed and the prose is succinct and descriptive.
sujata's review
3.0
really fast read and then it just ended, abruptly, like all the other books I've read recently.
chocolatelady1957's review against another edition
5.0
In this fascinating novel, Bezmozgis takes real-life Israeli figures, mixes them together and puts them into practically impossible situations with consequences that a lifetime. You can read my revised review here https://tcl-bookreviews.com/2014/10/11/protections-and-professions/
nashvillebookgirl's review
4.0
Great great piece. Honestly thought that the author lived in Crimea for some time- turns out he was just very very good at his research.
Depicts spectacularly the Jewish/Ukrainian/Russian aura of Crimea, dialogues and thought process of the characters: spot on. Truly enjoyed it.
Depicts spectacularly the Jewish/Ukrainian/Russian aura of Crimea, dialogues and thought process of the characters: spot on. Truly enjoyed it.
robinf's review
5.0
I picked this one up because it won the National Jewish Book Award. It was a very interesting, intriguing read with a different point of view that I had not considered before. I recommend this one!
northstar's review
4.0
If you can get past the credibility-straining coincidences of the plot, this is a beautiful book that explores the gray areas of morality and ethics among Jews who survived the refusenik era of the Soviet Union. Baruch Kotler is an Israeli cabinet minister whose political rivals reveal his adulterous affair with a much-younger woman. The couple escape to Yalta and Kotler hopes to relive the magic of a childhood vacation, but instead he encounters the man who denounced him to Soviet authorities forty years earlier.
guiltyfeat's review
3.0
Shortish novel brimming with interesting ideas about fate, faith and fidelity. This was much more about contemporary Israeli politics than I had anticipated having read a collection of Bezmozgis's short stories a decade ago and nothing since. Neat, rather than breathtaking.