Reviews

City Under the Sand by Jeffrey J. Mariotte, Jeffrey J. Mariotte

randalm's review

Go to review page

2.0

From the cover alone, I knew this would be bad. But it was also terribly uneven. There were, however, times when I actually found myself enjoying the writing, only to encounter pieces of plot development crudely forced in. Characters were single-dimension at best. And the whole thing needed a feminist makeover. (Female characters aren't even mentioned until chapter 3 or so. And the supposedly powerful templars back stab one another and go around naked.) Look elsewhere for your D&D fix.

ipacho's review

Go to review page

1.0

Sloppy storytelling, plain characters, and a straightforward plot. The worst way to help revive one of AD&D's best settings.
More...