Reviews with content warning for Injury/Injury detail - Wonderland

In a book where everyone’s a suspect it’s hard to know who to trust. In this case, that also includes the author. She strung me along with her cohesive writing style and great dialogue and tricked me into believing she had a grand plan for this story. She did not.

This whodunit kept me hooked ALMOST until the very end. Author Jennifer Hillier threw practically every curveball she had in her arsenal into the final five chapters, and it came out exceptionally underwhelming. However, for the first 85% Jennifer had me thoroughly inthralled with her very well written and engaging mystery. By the last 50 or so pages, I was more so anticipating the book to be over than to find out who was behind all of Seaside’s Wonder Workers disappearances.

I was left with a couple of questions by the end. Some of which that were technically answered in a “this was necessary for the purposes of helping the characters solve the crime” and not in a sensical, realistic, kind of way. The others weren’t even set up for you to be able to form your own conclusions; they were just left open. Definitely would have benefited from having a couple additional chapters to properly wrap things up if not a time jump epilogue.

Some characters were given back/side stories that offered absolutely nothing to the plot or to the character’s development. Oscar and his restaurant. Vanessa having an affair and murdering her husband. A security guard who killed his mother. Hovey and his gambling and porn addictions, to name a few.

The relationships evolved entirely too quickly and ended just the same. Most of those scenes felt like rough drafts. The instantaneous development between Vanessa and Tanner whose feelings for one another evolved “off screen”, and after only one interaction, was crazy. Not to mention the love octagon that involved everyone being infatuated with the “Dragon Lady” Bianca, for seemingly no reason whatsoever. Fourteen year old Ava and eighteen year old Xander? Vanessa and oozing red flags Oscar?

There is also a scene where a security guard attempts to rape a fourteen year old Ava, which was only a means to get said girl into the underground tunnel so that she can discover the hostages. This, amongst many other things toward the end of the book, inevitably led me to change my initial four star rating into a two.

I would recommend this book to someone who is into murder-mystery and not so much horror/thriller. There were no jump scares or gore. The dialogue between most of the characters felt natural despite all the pop culture references. You genuinely won’t know who the villain is until the end, because you can’t trust anyone throughout the book. Lastly, this book is good as a buddy read to be able to share your predictions and bounce your theories off of someone else.

Content Warnings

neverlandpages4's review

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional mysterious sad tense slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

• This is an older thriller that’s been resurfacing lately because the audiobook was recently released and it had a lot of good reviews so I picked it up because it’s by one of my favorite thriller authors!! I kind of wish I listened to the audiobook because this was pretty slow compared to the other books I’ve read by Jennifer Hillier.

• I was immediately hooked and intrigued because a lot is going on and I loved how this is more investigative. We’re following Vanessa, a deputy chief officer that’s trying to solve the mystery of the missing person.

• This is mainly set at a theme park in a shady small town and the writing perfectly captured the eerie feeling. I felt for the characters that were trying to leave the town and leave behind all the negative energy it has.

• I loved Vanessa and how determined she is to bring justice to the victims and didn’t let anyone, especially the men, tell her what she could or couldn’t do.

• The ending was not my favorite which is why this is a 4⭐️. The first 90% of the book was pretty slow and calculated, a lot was going on and there are a ton of characters introduced. And then the last 10%, everything felt rushed and I felt like there were some loose ends and unanswered questions. The killer was also a bit predictable but I still felt bad for Vanessa when she had to find out.

• By the end of the book, I wasn’t sure whose side I’m on. The characters that I was rooting for turned out to have done questionable things and some of them weren’t brought to justice and I didn’t like how they didn’t get charged for their crimes.

• Check trigger warnings if you’re planning on reading this, it’s pretty heavy with topics like SA and adult-minor relationships.

Content Warnings

covublitz's review

Go to review page

dark mysterious slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

ICK. I like the general idea of this book (

serial killer in a theme park

), but omg.
-
The trigger warning list for this book is a mile long (it would have been shorter to select what’s NOT in it), and it is WILDLY problematic. Characters are horribly unlikeable and should certainly all be in prison. The casual homophobia and transphobia are disgusting, as is the graphic and frequent pedophilia . Main character runs around with a victim mentality when she’s one of the worst of the bunch. Honestly, if they had all died I would have cheered.
-
Two stars only because I couldn’t figure out the killer right away (

thought it was going to be the original park owner/child molester and faked his death in the fire so he could continue to kidnap teenage boys and lock them in the sex dungeon he built under the park — nope. Turned out to be an incel revenge plot because the new sexual predator/CEO had rejected this dude when he got too old to be her type, so he kidnapped all the people that aged out of her abuse, put them in the OG sex dungeon because they weren’t good enough for her anyway, and murdered them when he ran out of space and needed to go grab someone else.

).
-
Picked it up for a horror/thriller bookclub. Hate-read my way through it, then took a really long, hot shower to get the ick off my skin. This book sticks with you, and not in a good way. Do not recommend.

Content Warnings

mysterymom40's review

Go to review page

dark mysterious tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.25

Content Warnings

More...