Reviews with content warning for Sexual content - Immortality: A Love Story

DONT READ IF YOU DONT LIKE SPOILERS....

I really wish the ending wasn't good in the last book because the ending of the last book is what made me decided to just read this one. I wish I didnt to be honest. I dont mean to be harsh but I just didn't like it. I wanted to. It sounded like a book. I would love to read but I just didn't like it at all. Spoilers ahead...

First off it started really slow. You kind of know Jack is alive and kind of don't. I just didn't like Hazels wishy wash attitude when it came to him. She said she was hopelessly in love with him. Then she's all attracted to someone else and kissing him. I get that she didn't owe anything to Jack but if you say you feel so much for someone and are supposed to be so in love yet turn around and kiss the next handsome guy at least set it up where she's ready to move on or something. It was portrayed like she was so in love with him and couldn't live with out him and she never wanted to be with anyone else. It just got on my nerves in the book.

The story in the middle picked up for me when Jack was brought back. But even then when we saw what happen to him and the reason he didn't reach out to Hazel and just stole her horse. He didn't even have the best reason to just leave her. I mean I get he didn't want to say bye to her just wanted to give up on her becausehe was "immorta". But why write a letter saying he's waiting for her? He just guessed she would think he was dead? That didn't make any sense to me.

Also I didn't get it in the last book still don't get it now but why is making out in a grave yard next to a dead body like a thing for them? I just couldn't see like - ya let's kiss and get hot and heavy here next to a dead person. That was just a strange part of the book.

The part about the some gifted and famous society of immortal people just pulling the strings of the governments of the world. Was a bit quarky it was interesting in a way I guess but when she says at the end she will never be like that. Ya okay, (you cant see it obviously but my eyes are rolling lol) if you have no accountability what would keep you from justifying your actions like they did and saying it was for the good of the people. Especially if you live forever. It seems to me everyone that took the elixir was pretty much the same. They all seemed to justify harming people here and there for the supposed good of the rest of the people. I just think Hazel hasn't lived long enough to say she wouldn't ever be tempted to do that. Like isn't black and white like that. I would hope she could keep her word I just don't think its likely given human nature.

There are also some heavy triggers in here that I wish I knew about. Like mentions of abortion and miscarriage. There is also graphic details of surgeries and such. So it has a bit of gor to it. It also has mentions of sex not completely graphic but there are mentions of nudity. There is also mentions of female chest nudity in a caught in the act part of the book. I feel like in these cases this should be marked as upper YA/NA science fiction section. But that's just my opinion. It's all just my opinion lol.

I really wish I could have liked these books.

Content Warnings

ellenigrace's review

Go to review page

3.5

I much preferred the first book. This one wasn't nearly as gothic, though I did enjoy the

surprise lesbians</>

Content Warnings

annabananawible's review

Go to review page

adventurous emotional mysterious medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

5.0

Content Warnings

frantically's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark mysterious reflective medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

2.0

Unlike other reviewers, I actually liked that Anatomy got a sequel and it had great potential. The plot switches to London, we meet new characters and there are new mysteries.

One of the biggest ones is Princess Charlotte and her illness and without spoiling anything, as a chronically ill woman, the "solution" to her problem was such a cop-out and just straight up disappointing.

There's also a group full of other immortal philosophers, scientists and the like and I really enjoyed that plot but the end was so dramatic with them lmao.

My main issue was probably that it took so long for Jack to arrive again (after all, this is called "A Love Story") and you really spend all the time leading up to it just "???? why are all these other people here". It takes Jack & Hazel way too long to get back to their former relationship and then the ending with them.felt really rushed sadly.

I'm not sure how this could've been handled better, maybe as a shorter novella or a longer book to explore Hazel and Jack's new relationship more but this way just didn't work as smoothly.

Content Warnings

More...