Reviews

Daddy Was a Number Runner by Louise Meriwether

libbysbookshelf's review against another edition

Go to review page

DADDY WAS A NUMBER RUNNER by LOUISE MERIWETHER 

I was in @mrbsemporium one day; one of those visits that was supposed to be for browsing only (like they ever go to plan) when this book jumped into my hands. After @reggiereads introduced me (and the rest of Bookstagram) to Ann Petry, I became obsessed. I’ve always enjoyed and sought out literature by Black writers and Zora Neale Hurston, Audre Lorde, Gayl Jones, Toni Morrison, Gloria Naylor are just a few of my favourites. So whenever I see a classic written by a Black woman, I just have to have it. 

This did not disappoint. 

This might be one of my favourites. Where CORREGIDORA and THE STREET follow women living in Harlem in a certain period of history, Number Runner follows a young girl. Where the women have already given up hope, the young girl still holds on to it. All three novels feature poverty like you’ve never seen before, maybe The Street and Number Runner more so. Poverty that makes you want to reach into the pages and give the characters some food and a blanket. MERIWETHER writes about the rats and the bedbugs and the men who flash or touch up the young girl; all three pests of Harlem. It’s heartbreaking to see the girl have to put up with the fondling because that’s the only way to get a little extra for her family. 

The theme, of course, that unites these books, aside from the systematic racism, is the strength of these characters. And that’s what brings a tear to your eye. The characters who face so much hunger and pain and degradation on a daily basis. These books are a snapshot of the life of a Black American in the twentieth century and not only are they exquisite works of literature, they are also revolutionary in a societal and political sense. Anyone who reads this book will have a greater understanding and empathy and isn’t that where we need to start? 

Anyway, I need you all to read this because it’s a great book and MERIWETHER is a great writer. The rest is extra. 

#book #bookstagram #bookstagramuk #bookstagrammer #bookrecommendations #bookreview #bookreviewfeatures #bookrecommendation #bookreader #bookreviewer #bookreviews #bookrecs #daddywasanumberrunner #louisemeriwether 

idlecee's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A book that grew on
me the more I read.

mc900ft's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Powerful depression era coming of age in harlem. Amazing.

roseeileen's review

Go to review page

medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes

3.75

jaymoran's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

It was storming, one of those reddish days that looks like the earth's on fire. It got darker and darker, all in the middle of the day, like the sun had gone off somewhere and died. The rain came down with a roar. The thunder boomed, the lightning cracked across the sky, and as I pressed my nose against the living-room window looking out at the storm, I shivered just a little, for who could tell that this wasn't doomsday. Gabriel, Gabriel, blow on your horn and all ye dead rise up to be judged.

One of the things that drew me to this book was James Baldwin's foreword:

We have seen this life from the point of view of a black boy growing into a menaced and probably brief manhood; I don't know that we have ever seen it from the point of view of a black girl on the edge of a terrifying womanhood.

Daddy Was a Number Runner is the coming of age story of Francie Coffin, a young girl living in Harlem with her family who are struggling to get by, both financially and as a Black family in America.

This is a novel that looks closely at community - how it is simultaneously loving and supportive but also a place of apathy, violence, and abuse. While Francie is trying to navigate her way through puberty, the men around her are trying to use her body for their own sexual gratification, be it touching her body in exchange for goods/money, or directly trying to take her virginity. Within the first few pages of the book, Meriwether details a man who exposes himself to Francie, seemingly every time he sees her, and this also happens to the other girls of her age in her neighbourhood. This is all told through this young girl's eyes, so there is an aspect of innocence and confusion as to what is happening to her. On top of all of that, she is also trying to understand her own sexuality, exploring it through pornographic comic strips that she shares with her friends. This is handled so brilliantly by Meriwether as she deals with Francie's conflicting emotions regarding what the men are doing to her without ever placing the blame on her.

I love the way in which the book explores family relationships, particularly the ways in which they shift as a child grows up and becomes more aware of the subtle family dynamics that they weren't aware of when they were younger. It's very quickly established that Francie is closer to her dad, who she calls Daddy, whereas she calls her mum the more formal Mother. Her father is more lenient with her, not disciplining her the same way that he does her older brothers, while on the other hand, her mother is strict, making Francie run errands that embarrass her, and Francie often states that her mother feels like a stranger to her. However, as Francie gets older, these dynamics begin to change, and she comes to understand that the love she receives from her parents are indeed different but, ultimately, that her mother's love is more substantial and consistent. I really loved the way Meriwether portrayed this - she doesn't do it with loud, dramatic scenes where feelings are overtly stated. Instead, she shows it gradually through small, seemingly insignificant moments, and how they make Francie feel, which I thought was much more effective and realistic.

The majority of the book focuses on the Coffin family and their small community, but she also touches on topics such as police brutality, riots, gangs, and systemic racism. So many moments from those scenes could be transplanted into the news today and they wouldn't feel out of place. Baldwin said: Louise Meriwether has told everyone who can read or feel what it means to be a black man or a woman in this country, and that still stands today's America n 2020. I think this classic should be recommended in the same breath as other coming of age stories such as A Tree Grows in Brooklyn and To Kill a Mockingbird.

sariggs's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

It was, as always, satisfying to read a book set in the same neighborhood I live in. I did not enjoy being trapped in the mind of a naive child, but the fact that it was so uncomfortable is a testament to the quality of the writing. I also didn’t enjoy that this book was written about an African-American girl in Harlem in the 1930s, but except for the lack of technology, it could have been about a working class girl in Harlem today. All the struggles seem to have remained the same. The sexual harassment, the sexism, the racism...GRRRRRR.

austindoherty's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Meriwether has Francie pick up Home to Harlem as if to say, close! Let me give it a try

reggiereads's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Update: 2/10/2020

I read this classic novel in 2019 and loved it.

So much so that I think I want to reread it in 2020.

Probably make it an end of the year favorite all over again.

trhanebutte's review

Go to review page

5.0

This is SUCH an overlooked book. It's a great American coming of age story on par with Catcher in the Rye. Can't say enough about it.
More...