Scan barcode
therudielibrarian's review
4.0
This book is kind of all over the place, but you see the loose threads weave together in the end. I am not sure it is smooth storytelling, but it gets the point across in the end.
birdmanseven's review
4.0
I don't understand the choices that were made in the conclusion of this book. I also don't like them. I did like the Booster story. Loved Catwoman and Joker. I was fascinated by all of the different artists and writers coming together. I think it's a special collection, I just wish it was better.
We discussed favorite Batman stories in a special episode of the All the Books Show podcast: https://soundcloud.com/allthebooks/episode-30-batman-v-all-the-books
We discussed favorite Batman stories in a special episode of the All the Books Show podcast: https://soundcloud.com/allthebooks/episode-30-batman-v-all-the-books
hobbes199's review
3.0
Not amazing, which is a surprise considering the build-up, but enjoyable nonetheless. Undoubtedly it's their opening three issues devoted to Booster Gold screwing everything up that are the standouts. Art is great for the majority, especially some of the celebratory pin-ups in issue 50.
josetinocoperez's review
2.0
50/100.
Este volumen se compone de 3 historias:
La primera de ella se titula 'The Gift' (#45 - #47). Tiene como protagonista a Booster Gold, personaje que viene del futuro muy fan de Batman y que quiere traerle un regalo para su boda con Catwoman. A grandes rasgos, y sin destripar la trama, no me ha convencido demasiado.
La segunda se titula 'The Best Man' (#48 - #49). Es una pequeña historieta entre Batman y el Joker. No me ha parecido del todo memorable. No creo que la recuerde en un par de semanas.
Por último, tenemos el número de la boda (#50), el que da sentido al volumen. Un buen tributo a los artistas que han colaborado en Batman, pero, oye, tampoco me ha gustado del todo.
Este volumen se compone de 3 historias:
La primera de ella se titula 'The Gift' (#45 - #47). Tiene como protagonista a Booster Gold, personaje que viene del futuro muy fan de Batman y que quiere traerle un regalo para su boda con Catwoman. A grandes rasgos, y sin destripar la trama, no me ha convencido demasiado.
La segunda se titula 'The Best Man' (#48 - #49). Es una pequeña historieta entre Batman y el Joker. No me ha parecido del todo memorable. No creo que la recuerde en un par de semanas.
Por último, tenemos el número de la boda (#50), el que da sentido al volumen. Un buen tributo a los artistas que han colaborado en Batman, pero, oye, tampoco me ha gustado del todo.
ofmiceandmenudo's review against another edition
5.0
I loved this so much! Bat and Cat's wedding has been a long time coming and I was so excited for this volume and it didn't disappoint! I loved the various Bat and Cat scenes drawn by different comic artists over the years that were included throughout the almost vow like narrative between Bat and Cat at the end (which was also gorgeously written, Tom King rules). I also loved the Joker portions "Your Big Day", "The Best Man", and "The Best Man Finale". Joker's banter with Cat while they're both stuck lying on the floor for hours injured was awesome. Overall, this book was a beautiful and emotional piece of art. Bat + Cat = forever. ❤️
allthetrauma's review against another edition
i refuse to rate this because it was great and beautiful right until the end when they decided to do the stupidest shit ever