You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

3.68 AVERAGE


Gorgeous writing lifts 'The Pickwick Papers' into an upper stratosphere! It isn't often a farce gets five stars from me. This may be Charles Dickens' first novel, built out of a newspaper serial, but there is nothing here to indicate to me that Dickens was struggling to find his voice! He comes out of the gate full speed! Everything which has most critics adoring his later books is here: social satire, a comprehensive set of lively and memorable contemporary 19th-century comical and lovable characters representing all sectors of society - lawyers, doctors, politically-connected newspaper owners, military soldiers, wealthy educated gentry, the working poor and the middle-class from small farming communities and the slums of London struggling to earn whatever coin they can find whether by legal or illegal means. Also, a ridiculous legal judgement imposed on Samuel Pickwick, the main character whom most of the book follows on several journeys around London and in various adventures in surrounding country inns gives Dickens the opportunity to describe a famous prison where people who could not pay their bills were incarcerated, very likely based on the actual imprisonment of Dicken’s father.

The first chapter opens with a formal proclamation being announced to society of an assignment being given to the most highly respected member of an association, along with other friends:

'That the said proposal has received the sanction and approval of this Association. 'That the Corresponding Society of the Pickwick Club is therefore hereby constituted; and that Samuel Pickwick, Esq., G.C.M.P.C., Tracy Tupman, Esq., M.P.C., Augustus Snodgrass, Esq., M.P.C., and Nathaniel Winkle, Esq., M.P.C., are hereby nominated and appointed members of the same; and that they be requested to forward, from time to time, authenticated accounts of their journeys and investigations, of their observations of character and manners, and of the whole of their adventures, together with all tales and papers to which local scenery or associations may give rise, to the Pickwick Club, stationed in London.

Dickens, Charles (2007-09-18). Works of Charles Dickens (200+ Works) The Adventures of Oliver Twist, Great Expectations, A Christmas Carol, A Tale of Two Cities, Bleak House, David Copperfield & more (mobi) (Kindle Locations 161029-161033). MobileReference. Kindle Edition.

The meeting does not occur quite as smoothly as this proclamation suggests; there is almost a fistfight among members because of, perhaps, misunderstandings and insults. In any case, the 2-year exploratory set of journeys is begun. Adventures great and small (mostly small) are told in many chapters, and many peculiar individuals cross the path of Pickwick and his friends as they travel in search of edifying experiences with which they hope to educate themselves about their world. Although humorous accidents and failures of judgement cause much trouble and consternation for the intrepid travelers, there is also enlightenment, love, dinner parties, dancing and best of all, lots of good strong ale!

Despite some misadventures, the travelers find much that they enjoy:

“In plain commonplace matter-of-fact, then, it was a fine morning--so fine that you would scarcely have believed that the few months of an English summer had yet flown by. Hedges, fields, and trees, hill and moorland, presented to the eye their ever-varying shades of deep rich green; scarce a leaf had fallen, scarce a sprinkle of yellow mingled with the hues of summer, warned you that autumn had begun. The sky was cloudless; the sun shone out bright and warm; the songs of birds, the hum of myriads of summer insects, filled the air; and the cottage gardens, crowded with flowers of every rich and beautiful tint, sparkled, in the heavy dew, like beds of glittering jewels. Everything bore the stamp of summer, and none of its beautiful colour had yet faded from the die.”

Dickens, Charles (2007-09-18). Works of Charles Dickens (200+ Works) The Adventures of Oliver Twist, Great Expectations, A Christmas Carol, A Tale of Two Cities, Bleak House, David Copperfield & more (mobi) (Kindle Locations 164672-164678). MobileReference. Kindle Edition.

‘The Pickwick Papers’ is entirely made of beautiful colors!
adventurous slow-paced

Kinda like the bible in that the first chapter is one of the greatest things ever written, so everything that comes after must be lesser than...

Just finished the David Timson audio reading of Pickwick. What a complete and utter joy. Finished disc 25 and started over again with disc 1. Delightful fun!
adventurous challenging slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
funny hopeful slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Loveable characters: Yes

It is the fate of most men who mingle with the world, and attain even the prime of life, to make many real friends, and lose them in the course of nature. It is the fate of all authors or chroniclers to create imaginary friends, and lose them in the course of art.

Charles Dickens debuteerde in 1836 op 24-jarige leeftijd met The Pickwick papers, een schelmenroman over de avonturen van de heer Pickwick en diens vrienden, de Pickwickclub. Oorspronkelijk werden de avonturen in een reeks van afzonderlijke verhalen gepubliceerd, die destijds tot groot vermaak en de doorbraak van de jonge Dickens leidden.

Helaas deden de verhaaltjes mij weinig. Ze geven in zekere zin een geestig beeld van de Engelse samenleving aan het begin van de negentiende eeuw, maar hebben weinig om het lijf. Het taalgebruik van Dickens is onmogelijk en ik vermoed dat veel referenties uit die tijd me zijn ontgaan. Waarschijnlijk had ik er beter aan gedaan een Nederlandse vertaling met noten te kiezen. Zo nu en dan moest ik tijdens het lezen aan het werk van Tolkien denken: mogelijk liet de schrijver van [b:The Hobbit|5907|The Hobbit, or There and Back Again|J.R.R. Tolkien|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1546071216l/5907._SY75_.jpg|1540236] zich inspireren door Dickens, bijvoorbeeld voor de kneuterigheid van hobbits of de loyaliteit van knecht Sam, een figuur die ook in The Pickwick papers een continue rol speelt.

Met twee sterren doe ik dit werk ongetwijfeld tekort; ze reflecteren uitsluitend mijn eigen gevoelens erbij.

“She has produced some delightful pieces, herself, sir. You may have met with her 'Ode to an Expiring Frog,' sir.”

Meh… not my favourite but I’m trying to read more books by men. Might abandon the goal though, I’m NOT enjoying it.

How a 24-year-old had the depth of understanding of human relationships to write about them with such humor is mind-blowing. Sam Weller, Mr. Pickwick's man servant, may be the greatest sidekick in history.

Charming and blithe but about 50% too long. Seems like another age that I started reading this.