Reviews

Daughter of Fire: The Darkness Rising by Karen Frost

hsinjulit's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Content warning: death of minor characters, magical gaslighting, blood, kidnapping, minor character with cancer

This is part one of Daughter of Fire. Though possibly unfair to rate now, it was indeed published as two separate books. I am giving a somewhat positive rating since the story is fairly good so far. With the knowledge of only 50% of the plot, this review might be a little spoilery but not much more than what the publisher’s blurb already stated.

Aeryn (15) is from the Ice Crown. When she begins to show an affinity for fire magic and promise as a war mage if trained, the King’s Regiment soldiers take notice, kidnap her, and strip her of recent memories. Believing she is the sole survivor of a Northmen invasion, Aeryn finds herself on the way to Windhall University. After passing out during admission testing, she wakes up in the lap of a cursed healer Lyse.

The story buildup is good, but it started slow. There were a lot of descriptions and too few dialogues in the first half of this part. But during the beginning, we get to understand more about Aeryn’s world as she grapples with her newfound magical abilities. I like that Frost decided magic should work like meditation. With the kingdom at war with the Southlands, the characters also mention how heroic stories might have glorified and fueled the war. I really appreciate Frost putting a lot of thoughts into constructing the characters’ beliefs.

“The fastest animal in the world is rumor.” — Kaylara


Though told in the first-person point of view, I felt that Aeryn is emotionally detached throughout the story. But at the 50% mark of Conspiracy of the Dark, Lyse shows up and the atmosphere instantly warms. It is almost impossible not to like this caring and loving healer, even when she insists she loves Timo. The chemistry between Aeryn and Lyse is slowly developing, and I hope it will be a beautiful romance.

I am not a fan of magical gaslighting, which is my way of saying using magic to make people forget about their past in order to manipulation them. Apart from being gaslighted though, Aeryn’s self-consciousness and self-deprecation are a little sad to read. I am unsure if those were magical side effects or not.

Frost dropped a lot of information in this first part, and I think it will become important in the second, i.e., The Darkness Rising. I need to point out that there are similarities between the mage school Aeryn attends and a certain magical school that is no longer mentionable. The parallel between the professors in both schools are hard to miss, and even the storyline more or less fits the series. It doesn’t constitute a retelling, but I love that we are getting an actual LGBTQ+-friendly story with magical schools. This fantasy also acknowledges racial and gender diversity, albeit subtly.

“Pavo is much smarter than his teachers and the other students realize, [...] They hear his way of speaking and make assumptions about him because of it, but... he knows much more than he lets on.” — Lyse


This is a short and incomplete review because Daughter of Fire: Conspiracy of the Dark is essentially half a book. But Frost has succeeded in keeping me interested, and I am looking forward to reading the second half.

hsinjulit's review

Go to review page

4.0

Content warnings: death, blood, cult, kidnapping, mind control

This story has certainly kept me on the edge of my seat. Frost made great decisions on where a chapter should break, and I find myself unable to even pause reading.

In part two of Daughter of Fire, Aeryn (16) finally learns that her family is likely alive. And some people around her are definitely up to no good. When things break into chaos, can Aeryn and her fellow students save the kingdom they don’t really care for?

This is an action-packed fantasy that is heavy on magic. It also has very good YA romance. I love Lyse (~18), and she is so kind and helpful. Even though the story is in Aeryn’s first-person perspective, we still get to see Lyse’s struggles, especially since many things take form in magic and thus allowing visualization. The jealousy drama between Aeryn and Lyse makes me a little uncomfortable. Yet it is also kind of adorable because they are teenagers and confused about their future. I feel that Asher is only a plot device for the drama. She definitely deserves more and I am happy that the next installment features her story.

“[W]e should all be the hero of our story.” — Asher


I wondered about many seemingly random facts while reading, but as the story unfurls, almost everything clicks. Frost has done a wonderful job at piecing information together and delivering an intensely paced plot. I did find it odd that spell-casting suddenly becomes very important in this second part, having been addressed little in the previous book. And one question I still cannot get out of my head was whether or not Aeryn could have used magic outside of the university to be banned from the city and subsequently able to go home. Perhaps the consequences would not be worth it.

Am I being too suspicious of things, or are Aeryn and her friends too naïve? They seem to think that everything is simple and people with power are trustworthy. I guess I got too nervous on their behalf. Too often SFF involves the main characters trying to save everyone while making a mess of things, and I am happy that Aeryn and her friends are not like that. It is very refreshing to see them, eager teenagers, not taking everything into their own hands immediately.

Aeryn and Lyse remind me a lot of Kiena and Ava from Breaking Legacies, respectively. So much so I would consider the ending almost a retelling. And Aeryn’s relationship with fate is also a lot like Joslyn’s from Princess of Dorsa—they both fight for the women they love at a great price. These two novels mentioned here are my favorite sapphic fantasies of all time, so I might be too spoiled by them to love Daughter of Fire.

“The gods stopped paying attention to the mortal world centuries ago. They have their own quarrels to attend to.” — Reddek the Wise, first Chancellor of Windhall University


The book closes on a cliffhanger that I am slightly put off by because purposefully mystifying readers by having main characters withhold information never sits well with me. That being said, this story is too enjoyable to miss, and I am intrigued to find out more in the next book Destiny’s Choice.

Daughter of Fire is a wonderful page-turner of a YA high fantasy with cute slow-burn romance between two teenage girls. If you are up for a thrilling read that also makes you melt a little when the main character looks at her crush, Daughter of Fire: Conspiracy of the Dark (part one) and Daughter of Fire: The Darkness Rising (part two) are a great YA fantasy to read.

I received an electronic review copy from Ylva Publishing in exchange for an honest review.

adrihean's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

 
Aeryn, born and raised in the Ice Crown region of Ilirya, who possesses a rare and uncontrollable magic in the form of blue flames. Fearing the empire's intentions, she conceals her powers, but when her secret is uncovered, she is whisked away to Windhall University to learn how to harness her abilities. As she grapples with her newfound powers, she also navigates complex relationships, including her attraction to her friend Lyse, a skilled healer, and uncovers unsettling truths about her kingdom. 

 

“Daughter of Fire: Conspiracy of the Dark” by Karen Frost was interesting. Not a lot happens and it’s slow at times. A lot of the characters were hard to remember and didn’t really connect with them. I liked how Aeryn uses her powers in fighting and I am really interested in seeing more of it. The characters at Windhall University reminded me of a lot of characters in Hogwarts Legacy which I really liked. 3 out of 5 stars, I think the sequel has promise to have more action and hopefully more in depth of the side characters. 

hehkhatea's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

I’m so confused as to what the book wanted to be. Like did you want to make a magic school book? Did you want an epic fantasy? The pacing of this book was so confusing, I was astounded that there were still things being introduced when the book was almost over. So many plot threads that didn’t need to get introduced or are just dropped for the sake of wanting a sequel. I mean, kudos for having a gay main character, that’s probably the only highlight of this book. I didn’t think it was really possible to make a fantasy book boring but they succeeded.

wordsaretheretoberead's review against another edition

Go to review page

medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated

3.0

__shaked's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

arthurgdean's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Recensione su Book Lover

Aeryn è una ragazza che vive nella Ice Crown, una parte dell'Impero dove ci sono piccoli villaggi dove tutti si conoscono e si aiutano a vicenda, contro la Natura non particolarmente gentile.
Un giorno scopre di essere una Maga, e, anche se non lo sa ancora, la sua vita cambierà per sempre.

Ho trovato questo libro molto interessante: vediamo tutto attraverso gli occhi di Aeryn, e assieme a lei scopriamo un mondo completamente nuovo, fatto di Magia, certo, ma anche di grandi città e persone molto diverse tra loro, di uno stile di vita che contrasta con quello in cui è cresciuta.
La fine del volume è una "non fine", il libro sembra tranciato a metà, e questo un po' mi ha infastidita. Certamente, il secondo volume dovrebbe uscire ad ottobre, ma lo trovo ingiusto verso i lettori. Questo non toglie che, fino alle ultime pagine, questa sia stata un'ottima lettura, on un buon worldbuilding e personaggi interessanti. Con tutte le novità che ci sono per Aeryn, però, fatichiamo un po' a notare alcune cose che dovrebbero portare avanti la storia e che passano quasi in secondo piano.
Del worldbuilding mi è piaciuto anche il fatto che ci sia una mistione di gente di diverse etnie e background, come anche persone lgbt+, e che nessuno lo metta in dubbio. È stato rinfrescante, per una volta.
Da alcuni punti di vista, poi, questo libro mi ricorda quelli della Canavan, che mi sono piaciuti tantissimo.

Non ho molta simpatia per i soldati/maghi incontrati fino ad ora, soprattutto i primi due che becchiamo nella storia: due stronzi, passatemi il francesismo. Arrivati alla scuola di Magia, però, gli studenti non sono male.
Il mio preferito è Pavo, che è molto più intelligente di quello che sembra ed è un po' iperattivo. Spero davvero che in generale sia uno dei personaggi principali, perché è davvero fantastico.
Aeryn è una ragazza coraggiosa, anche se con molte debolezze, e mi piace il fatto che, comunque, si rialza sempre. Cerca di andare avanti nella sua nuova vita, cerca di essere quello per cui "è nata". È completamente diversa dai ragazzi di città, mostra empatia e sentimenti molto forti, mentre gli altri sembrano quasi fregarsene di quello che succede intorno a loro a meno che non sia qualcosa che li coinvolge direttamente.
So che Lyse dovrebbe starmi simpatica, e che quello che si crea lentamente con Aeryn è qualcosa di molto bello e sincero. Ma anche lei sembra assuefatta alla vita di città. Se all'inizio mi è sembrata simpatica e gentile, proseguendo con la lettura ho avuto i miei dubbi.

Questo è il primo libro che leggo di Karen Frost, e ho adorato lo stile in cui è scritto. È molto vivido e si legge molto bene, anche se credo che l'inglese sia ad un livello intermedio. Insomma, chi fa fatica a masticare l'inglese non penso riuscirebbe a leggerlo bene, mentre chi è a un livello più alto (diciamo B1) lo leggerebbe tranquillamente.
Nel complesso, un buon libro, e aspetto con ansia la seconda parte!

arthurgdean's review

Go to review page

5.0

Recensione su Book Lover

All'inizio pensavo che questa fosse una duologia, quindi ero abbastanza confusa dal finale, ma poi ho letto che ci sarà un terzo volume. Quando, non lo so, ma dovrò assolutamente leggerlo.

Aeryn continua ad indagare sulle persone scomparse nella città. Questa volta, però, oltre che da Lyse si fa aiutare anche da da altri personaggi. Continuando a scavare, però, trovano le radici di una cospirazione che potrebbe distruggere il regno.
Parallela a questa linea avventurosa c'è anche quella amorosa: Aeryn e Lyse cercano di entrare a patti con i sentimenti che provano l'una per l'altra, che potrebbero cambiare le dinamiche che stanno loro attorno.
In poche pagine succede di tutto, cospirazioni, scontri, spionaggio. Sono sorpresa che la Frost sia riuscita a mettere tutto quanto senza farlo sembrare affrettato.

Questo secondo volume è molto più serio e dark del precedente, una cosa che sinceramente non mi aspettavo ma che mi ha lasciata felicemente sorpresa. Alcune cose sono forse un po' ovvie fin dal primo libro, ma per il resto è una storia che si fa leggere.
Forse la cosa che amo di più è il modo in cui viene usata la magia, come viene messa in delle "scatole" a seconda di ciò che si controlla e come l'autrice mostra, in The Darkness Rising, che invece i personaggi possono usarla come meglio credono (c'è una particolare scena con Pavo che è interessantissima da questo punto di vista).
E, come ho già accennato, la parte dark di questo libro fa interessare ancora di più il lettore alla storia. Forse è un po' troppo ovvio chi siano i cattivi, ecco, ma non sempre questo è un male, anche perché la Frost ci mostra quanto in là quei personaggi possano spingersi nel suo universo.

I personaggi a cui già avevo cominciato ad affezionarmi nel primo volume ricompaiono qui, e molti di loro sono fondamentali: la ricerca non ricade solo sulle spalle di Aeryn e Lyse. Le due convincono anche i loro amici, che, con notevole sprezzo del pericolo, aiutano le due giovani come possono.
Di sicuro il mio preferito è Pavo; tra tutti è il più particolare, e qui ha mostrato di avere più di qualche risorsa. Spero di vederlo ancora nel prossimo volume.
Il mi odio verso alcuni cavalieri e maghi continua, ma in mezzo alle mele marce ce n'è qualcuno che si può salvare. Pochi, eh, ma buoni. Forse un po' ingenui nel non vedere quello che hanno sotto al naso.
E la relazione tra Aeryn e Lyse? Be', dire complicate è dire poco, anche per via di Timo. C'è un avanzamento graduale che poi diventa sorprendentemente veloce, quasi assurdo e forse non proprio positivo, però è una bella coppia. Forse non quella che ci si aspetta, ma bella.

Per quanto riguarda lo stile, scorre molto velocemente, tanto che non ti rendi conto di quanto hai letto fino a che non lo guardi. Continuo a pensare che per qualcuno che abbia un livello B1 o più alto di Inglese potrebbe leggere questa serie tranquillamente e non avendo problemi.

Nel complesso, un'ottima lettura.


judeinthestars's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This is a frustrating read. Like other reviewers before me, I wonder why the story is being told in two different books. This one feels like an introduction and not much more. The world building is good (though it feels too much like Harry Potter meets GoT, I was having plenty of déjà vu feelings) and so is the writing, but I kept waiting for the real story to begin.

When we first meet Aeryn, she’s a child, living in a tiny village in the Ice Crown region, in the north of the kingdom. The villagers are not used to visitors and when a mage comes by unexpectedly, Aeryn is fascinated. We meet her again at fifteen, when she discovers she has magic. She trains as best she can to control the fire and bolts her body produces, not sure she can (nor is willing to) get proper training as a mage at university. Then she’s taken away from her family by soldiers of the King’s Regiment and brought to said university by a Hagrid-like knight. She makes friends there and learns that the world is not always as it seems. Also, there’s a war happening in the south of the kingdom and it all sounds very ominous. It also explains why Aeryn is being trained, as obviously war mages are needed to win and / or stop the war.

The first part ends on some sort of cliffhanger which is not a real surprise to the reader, even if it is to Aeryn.

As annoying as it felt to be stopped right when the story gets interesting, I’m looking forward to reading the second part, to find out what happens to Aeryn, whether she grows up to become a war mage and if the fledgling romance with Lyse gets anywhere. It’s announced for November, so not too long to wait.

I received a copy from the publisher and I am voluntarily leaving a review.

judeinthestars's review

Go to review page

4.0

As I was hoping, the first book, [b:Daughter of Fire: Conspiracy of the Dark|44431673|Daughter of Fire Conspiracy of the Dark (Destiny and Darkness #1)|Karen Frost|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1552596167l/44431673._SY75_.jpg|68995079], was setting the scene and this one is where the action really takes place. Yet not all the action since it, once again, ends on a cliffhanger, although it’s a lot less frustrating than the end of book 1.

Daughter of Fire: The Darkness Rising starts where the previous book ended, with Lyse restraining Aeryn, preventing her from attacking the ambassador of the people she holds responsible for her family’s death. There’s a lot Aeryn doesn’t know, and Lyse shares her theory with her on what really happened. At the same time, the two students keep investigating the unexplained disappearances throughout King’s City. While doing so, they meet Lady Asher, a young knight, whose interest in Aeryn displeases Lyse. Aeryn and Lyse try to navigate their feelings for each other, despite Lyse being bonded to Timo. If that wasn’t enough, a Dark mages conspiracy seems more and more plausible, and the little group of students at Windhall University might be the only ones able to fight it.

There’s a lot of action and growth and excitement happening in this second book and it all makes for a very enjoyable read, even though I couldn’t shake the Harry Potter feel. Some scenes drag on a little, which messes with the otherwise fast-paced rythm, usually when the heroine is overwhelmed. That said, who wouldn’t feel overwhelmed in her place?

Aeryn is the perfect YA heroine, in that she’s responsible and earnest, and sometimes unyielding. She’s arrogant in that way only gifted teenagers can get away with. Lyse is also becoming an interesting character. She’s much stronger than she lets on and I hope we’ll get to see more of that side of her in future instalments.

I enjoyed this book more than the first one, and am looking forward to the next one, hoping I’ll like it even more.

I received a copy from the publisher and I am voluntarily leaving a review.